News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by eschutte2 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @06:38PM (#16806226)
The $800 "minimum tax" on LLCs and C-corps is assessed whether you have any revenue or not.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dlisboa on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @06:40PM (#16806250)
If you can't come up with US$ 800 a year to pay a business tax you're pretty much bankrupt already and it wasn't the tax that killed you.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by Karishma1234 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:04PM (#16807478)
> If you can't come up with US $800 a year to pay a business tax

That is not only condescending but also insulting to people who are working very hard to just survive.

I would respectfully request you to come down from your ivory tower of tech employment and notice the small people. My brother has an LLC and does landscaping. After paying all sort of bills and liabilities his company made $4K profits last year. $800 is pretty big amount compared to those profits. The profits might look negligible but he was able to employ 2-3 people on hourly wages, invest in buying a vehicle, equipment and so on.

When we talk about inequality we should realise that $800 flat tax hurts the poorest of poor lot more than people like you and me. This eventually adds up into making poor people even more miserable than rich people.

It could have been lot more sensible to say don't pay any taxes if you are making less than $20K profits. That would help poor people more.

I am not saying this about you but I come across so many people in tech industry who claim to have bleeding heart for poor and yet are totally ignorant of reality of poor people.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by m0llusk on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:01PM (#16806410)
That isn't true at all. Most small businesses start out extremely lean and at risk.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by SlowBro on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:46PM (#16807376)
$800 to obtain the privilege of operating in one of the world’s largest economies seems like a bargain to me. Were I one of those small businesses I would find some way to get that funding. A loan, a credit card, something. There are plenty of reasons people want to be in CA to do business, and that’s not that big of an expense for the value of operating there, in my opinion.

And by the way I’m not in agreement with most taxes; I am almost a Libertarian. I’m also not a Californian. I’m just saying, I think it’s not that big a deal in the grand scheme.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by geggam on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:00PM (#16807697)
Calling "starting a business" a privilege completely moves you very far away from the libertarian space.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by SlowBro on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:06PM (#16807719)
It’s the world we live in. Ask me personally what I think and I’ll tell you it’s a God-given right to start a business with little government mettling. In the real world, especially one largely run by statists, it’s considered a privilege.

I'm using the language of statists because most people today are statists. It doesn't necessarily follow that I also personally agree with the idea, though I can see why you'd draw that conclusion.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:46AM (#16808106)
> $800 to obtain the privilege of operating in one of the world’s largest economies seems like a bargain to me.

It might be, but that's not what the tax is for. The $800 tax applied to LLPs, LLCs, and corporations isn't a tax on the privilege of operating a business in California: sole props and non-limited-liabilty partnerships can operate as businesses in California and don't pay the tax.

The privilege you pay for with the tax is that of offloading business failure risk onto the public while protecting your own personal assets with a publicly granted corporate liability shield.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by twohlix_ on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:36AM (#16808068)
From personal experience: Hiring your designer buddy who lives in San Diego while the two other guys in your company lives elsewhere entitles you to pay $800 a year in somewhat unexpected tax, even though you're not selling any services to any CA companies. Yea, jumped in feet first, but really did not enjoy the $800 bill that came with it.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:42AM (#16808093)
> From personal experience: Hiring your designer buddy who lives in San Diego while the two other guys in your company lives elsewhere entitles you to pay $800 a year in somewhat unexpected tax, even though you're not selling any services to any CA companies

No, it doesn't, you can do that as a sole prop or (non-LLP) partnership, and not pay the $800 tax applied to corporations, LLPs, and LLCs.

Asking the public at large to absorb for you (by granting you a personal liability shield) the risk that that the resources you give to the business plus those it is able to earn will not be able to meet the businesses liabilities is what you pay the $800 for. Which is why only the limited liability entities pay the tax.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:57AM (#16808161)
Many small businesses start out as sole proprietorships or general partnerships that don't pay the tax for the privilege of a corporate-style liability shield for investors that applies to LLCs, LLPs, and corporations.

They often convert to an LLC or corporation if they scale beyond a very small operation, because at any but the smallest scale $800/year is nothing (it's less than the wages—not total cost—of a full time minimum wage employee in the state for two weeks.) But, you only need to start that way when you have or are seeking early investors that are protecting substantial assets outside the business; lots of people starting a small business sink most of their personal assets into them initially anyway, so the corporate liability shield isn't protecting anything: if the business fails, they are personally wiped out with or without it, and their exposure is limited more by personal bankruptcy than anything else.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by briandear on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:30PM (#16806653)
What’s the benefit to the business of that $800 fee? Why is it almost 4 times more than Delaware? Do I get a nice engraved plaque or something? I am being serious: WHY does it cost $800 just to exist?
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:39PM (#16807337)
> What’s the benefit to the business of that $800 fee?

Doing business in California: both local and foreign LLCs doing business in CA pay it.

> Why is it almost 4 times more than Delaware?

Why shouldn't it be?

> WHY does it cost $800 just to exist?

You can do business as a sole proprietor or general (or limited, but not limited liability) partnership without the franchise fee. You are paying for the right to do business in CA with a liability shield. The potential value to you (and cost to the public) of such a shield, all other things being equal, is greater in a bigger market. California has more than 30 times the population and 40 times the GDP of Delaware.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by mark212 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:58PM (#16807692)
Delaware is 5x South Dakota for exactly the same thing, just to exist. At a certain level of receipts it doesn’t matter and the tax rate is more important, or what the corporate law structure is like.

But yeah, there’s really no valid reason other than the fact that California can get away with it.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by neo4sure on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @07:43PM (#16806751)
No, you get to do business in the 6th largest economy in the world. If you don't like it don't do any business here.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by exclusiv on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:06PM (#16807209)
That type of thinking has pushed entrepreneurs and businesses to move to more friendly and competitive states.

It's simply a bad policy to start aspiring small businesses in debt. $800 isn't much to many of us on here but it is for a lot of people that want to be entrepreneurs in different fields from different backgrounds. Most businesses have other startup costs as well.

California already has the highest state income taxes. The privilege of doing business here is already accounted for. The franchise tax fee is just a bad policy and it's regressive.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:43PM (#16807360)
> $800 isn't much to many of us on here but it is for a lot of people that want to be entrepreneurs in different fields from different backgrounds.

And, so, they start businesses as sole proprietorships, or general or limited partnerships, and reorganize as LLCs or corporations once they've proven the idea. They are exposed to more (and the public exposed to less) risk of unmet business liability, but they can still run a business.

We always see entrpreneurs praised for taking risk, why are we hearing so much complaint that California charges for the privilege of offloading risk on to the public?

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by inferiorhuman on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:53PM (#16807670)
> California already has the highest state income taxes.

California has a pretty progressive income tax. It's the highest at the top income bracket (> $1 mil is taxed at around 13%), but it's significantly lower at the low end than many other states including Alabama, Arizona, Connecticut, Kansas, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and DC.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by jjeaff on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:15AM (#16807987)
That is much more a result of the much higher basic cost of living vs those other states than it is CA's progressiveness when it comes to taxes.

I'd be willing to bet that if you adjusted the brackets for cost of living, CA is taxing the poor more than those other states are.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by inferiorhuman on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @01:35AM (#16808336)
> I'd be willing to bet that if you adjusted the brackets for cost of living, CA is taxing the poor more than those other states are.

Why bet when you could actually look up the figures yourself? California has a very progressive income tax with more brackets (ten) than other states, starting at 1% for the lowest bracket. Meanwhile North Carolina charges a flat 5.75% and Wisconsin's lowest income tax bracket is 4%.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by jjeaff on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:12PM (#16892845)
Because a cursory lookup doesn't tell you much. Taxes are much more nuanced than a tax table. There are studies showing that a flat tax without loopholes or special deductions is a higher effective rate for the wealthy than a "higher" marginal rate in a progressive system. Additionally, states vary in what is deductible or non-taxable income.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by JKCalhoun on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @10:39PM (#16807611)
> That type of thinking has pushed entrepreneurs and businesses to move to more friendly and competitive states.

Or simply get an LLC from another state. Seems like there are states (Utah?) where there is no annual fee/tax.

I believe you only need a CA LLC if you hire employees in CA.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by mark212 on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @11:01PM (#16807701)
Not quite that simple but you’re right that if you can be physically present outside the state and do business for California clients then you’re probably not going to pay the franchise tax.

But no state allows you to register any entity for free. Lowest I’ve seen is South Dakota at $50 per year with no other tax on receipts.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by jjeaff on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:23AM (#16808020)
ND is $50 to renew, but $150 filing fee. Wyoming is $100 filing fee and also $50 to renew.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by stickfigure on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @01:40AM (#16808351)
If you don't like it don't do any business here.

Ask Detroit how that worked out for them.

Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by neo4sure on Thursday April 12, 2018 @08:20PM (#16826111)
Seems to me like all the states where its so easy to do businesses there are no businesses. Maybe that's why they are making it so easy because no one comes there. You are complaining about CA but forget why it grew in the first place. CA governments have been leading the way for many years on what is required to be done for the economy.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by homero on Tuesday April 10, 2018 @09:02PM (#16807183)
There's a few businesses I wanted to try but paying $800 was absurd so I forgot it
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by jjeaff on Wednesday April 11, 2018 @12:21AM (#16808009)
You do know you don't have to form an LLC to try out a business? Just got for it as a sole proprietorship and file an LLC later if it starts working.
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by homero on Thursday April 12, 2018 @09:51AM (#16820866)
No you can get sued pretty quick
Re:Form a California LLC in 10 minutes for $70 by jjeaff on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:07PM (#16892821)
And when you are sued, your one man, tiny operation LLC will offer essentially zero protection. Unless you are selling parachutes to base jumpers, you'll be fine.