Even the DOJ even weighed in (https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4390361/Views-Ltr...) and said it will make catching traffickers more difficult. When you have the DOJ opposing a proposal to strengthen a law, that should be a significant red flag.
Of course, I understand my comment is specifically about the implications for trafficking, not self-decided/employed sex workers.
In regards to the latter, I think the article describes it well, regardless of it being illegal, SESTA/FOSTA only makes it more dangerous for both groups.
That use of the Travel Act to combat prostitution has been used to get any site they wanted to shut down. In other words, since Congress isn't about to reign them in nor the courts prosecutors at the Federal level can do about what they please. This is not to say backpage was innocent, only in how non Federal crimes can become such by stretching intent
The last 20 years of web innovation begs to differ. Killing user-generated content will make us all worse off.
"AI" is not the answer. AI is not adequate or comparable to human moderators which small businesses employ. AI is a "solution" for providing lip service to accountability without spending the money to actually provide any sort of responsible service.
Of course, they don't, because thanks to Section 230 immunity, they have no obligation to.
If you can't think of any moral hazards around prostitution, then I don't believe that you are trying very hard.
>I don't think Christian views should be the determining factor in our legislature
Is Christianity the only moral system that looks poorly upon prostitution?
The only reason to make prostitution a crime is if you think prostitutes themselves are committing evil. That is 100% a religious position with no rational support.
This seems like a pretty outrageous claim. It seems obvious that:
1) There are moral hazards surrounding prostitution
2) The legal status of prostitution has a negative effect on the number of people participating in it.
So while legalizing prostitution certainly could (and anecdotally would) negate some of the hazards, to say that it would negate all of them seems foolish, or at the very least extremely poorly reasoned.
For instance: we don't allow people to work for less than minimum wage. We have things like OSHA which set minimum safe working requirements for dangerous jobs, etc.
You may claim "yes, that's why we want sex-work regulated".
Sex work already is regulated. Pornography is legal, stripping is legal, "cam" work is legal, burlesque is legal, etc. etc.
The classic example is: suppose a drug addict who has a moral opposition to selling their body for sex, but is being coerced into doing so by their drug addiction. We have protective regulations around that which strongly disincentive it.
Selling penetrative sex for money is where we as a society have drawn a line and said "everything up to this point is okay."
Just like we drawn a line for dangerous working conditions and said "everything up to this point is okay". We're not saying that there are no risks to dangerous physical work (sex work included), we're saying that anything beyond the line is intolerable.
--
Just to be clear: I'm not making some claim that strongly supports any side of this argument. I'm just annoyed by the claim that there is no discussion to be had here, and that the only reason that prostitution is illegal in most of the US is "Christians".
First off, that is an extremely broad moral hazard and one that applies to pretty much all types of employment and not just prostitution.
Secondly, making prostition legal allows an organiztion like OSHA to set (and more importantly, enforce) safe working requirements. This is precisely and example of a moral hazard that is limited/negated by legalizatin.
> I'm just annoyed by the claim that there is no discussion to be had here
I've yet to see anyone make argument for keeping prostitution that isn't either A) Factually incorrect or B) Based on christianity. I'd be happy to discuss such an arguement if you have one.
However, the real debate that we should be having is the best ways to legalize prostitution to make sure that the moral hazards are minimized.
The "Scandinavian Approach" (make buying sex illegal but don't penalize selling) is certainly better than what we have in the US as it makes the justice system available to prostitutes who no longer face jail time for reporting crime committed against them. However helping buyers not get caught is a selling point for sellers, so it still drives the activity into hiding. Hidden activity is harder to regulate and increases the probability that violence can be committed against the sellers.
And then adults being drugged and forced into prostitution?
And then adults feeding a drug addiction?
At which point of this ladder do you start to say "no, this is where we need to make it illegal"?
That's already illegal. You've just made discovering it harder.
> And then adults being drugged and forced into prostitution?
Also already illegal. You've made discovering it harder.
> And then adults feeding a drug addiction?
That's actually none of your business.
> At which point of this ladder do you start to say "no, this is where we need to make it illegal"?
There's no need since you don't actually solve coerced prostitution by making it illegal.
Maybe we should just make one singular law that says "be nice".
Hey, I bet you could make a religion out of that!
/s
Saying there is already a law that covers something is disconnected from reality, or at least disconnected form language and the way that humans communicate.
For instance: "drugging people is illegal". You haven't defined "drugging" or "people" in that case. Is it drugging a person when a school nurse gives a child a acetaminophen? You're definitely changing both their physical and psychological state, and are in some way establishing a relationship of dependence.
This is why we have more than one law, and why we don't base our laws on religion.
A lot of adults work jobs for a wage to feed their drug habit. Should we make that illegal too?
Kidnapping is already a serious crime.
>And then adults being drugged and forced into prostitution?
Say it with me, kidnapping is already a crime.
>And then adults feeding a drug addiction?
A legal and regulated sex industry will no longer provide the 'safe haven' for addicts that the illegal one does today. Note - I'm not claiming it will eliminate it.
>At which point of this ladder do you start to say "no, this is where we need to make it illegal"?
We need not start. By your logic, we should outlaw cars for all the deaths they cause.
No, but is it probably one of the most vocal.
They are not immune from that and Section 230 doesn't make them immune to that.
What section 230 means is that "implementing any moderation or filtering of user content does not automatically make you an editor and thus liable for all content on your site".
Without section 230, Dang cannot do moderation on HN without HN becoming liable for EVERYTHING that is posted to the site. Facebook, Google and Twitter will be economically forced to stop filtering abhorrent content to avoid massive legal liabilities.
The missing discussion is that people need to stop jumping into the discussion without understanding the historical and legal context of section 230.
Pretending that Section 230 willing enables participation in an illegal enterprise is a complete fabrication with no grounding in reality.
Prosecuting Backpage without SESTA/FOSTA was possible which is why Backpage was taken down and indicted BEFORE the law was signed (and therefore, enforceable).
Why do you think all the torrent sites get taken down? Or YouTube was sued? or 2903420934230 other things where a site violates some law be profiting from otherwise illegal UGC? Or the various dark net markets like the one Dread Pirate Roberts ran?
Section 230 has _never_ provided more than a reasonable barrier to overcome to prevent absurd legal attacks.
The problem is that there's no good reason for prostitution in general to be illegal in the United States. While I have no interest in partaking in such activity myself, I realize that the sole interest in banning it appears to be religion... something which cannot and should not govern our country's laws. I'm a Christian, but I don't think Christian views should be the determining factor in our legislature... that's the Constitution's job.