News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products?

One particular thread tonight astounded me: the one showing AwesomeReminders at more than 750 PAYING users.

What other super simple, quick-to-build websites/apps are there that generate a non-trivial amount of revenue? (At least a few thousand a month.)

I want to study/think about them.

( 26 comments | 24 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by patio11 on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:49AM (#1678208)
Don't study the product. Study the distribution mechanism. (In AwesomeReminders' case, national press coverage due to having an appealingly quirky narrative.)

I've had half a dozen people clone my software product. They are apparently under the impression I'm in the software business. I'm actually in the educational publishing business, and I'm really good at distribution via SEO for it. That is the missile, the software is just the warhead. Without the missile, you can only blow yourself up.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by heliodor on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:41AM (#1678971)
quirky narrative? i don't think that's what's getting people's attention. for me (and i'm going to guess most other people) the reason why i find it interesting is because the concept is so ridiculous! And simple.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by acangiano on Friday September 10, 2010 @11:13AM (#1679076)
I think you mean the same thing. The idea is odd and makes people smile. Journalists are in the business of selling you a story, and this product happened to be a ridiculous, quirky idea that may actually work. That's a good story.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by pascalchristian on Saturday September 11, 2010 @08:14PM (#1682688)
Can you share resources for studying the distribution mechanism?
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by bmelton on Friday September 10, 2010 @01:57PM (#1679608)
"Don't study the product. Study the distribution mechanism."

I'll do you one better -- study both

It's primarily your example that speaks to the distribution mechanism aspect, but if the product weren't any good, you'd likely end up as a case study for your competitors as they beat you into the ground (just as you posted the screenshot the other day of the horrible bingo app that motivated you).

You can't JUST do one half of it, unless you get very lucky, or have some kind of viral appeal, or are Craig Newmark, or whatever. The key to being best in class AND being perceived as best in class at the same time is to nail every aspect of product, which includes distribution in most cases.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by moconnor on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:48AM (#1678205)
If I knew a way to develop over $7k monthly revenue that quickly, I'd be doing it. I suspect that goes for everyone here. Props to jacquesm - I didn't think AwesomeReminders would take off like this but I think it's, well, awesome that it has!
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by swombat on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:54AM (#1678213)
I thought AwesomeReminders was Zackattack's, not Jacquesm's?
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by wdewind on Saturday September 11, 2010 @11:30AM (#1681672)
Yeah it is Zackattack's
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by bmelton on Friday September 10, 2010 @01:54PM (#1679601)
I think he's referring to pre-existing apps, though I'm sure he'd be happy to have suggestions (I know I would.)

In this same vain, Twitter is, effectively, a super simple idea that seems to have at least taken to legs in adoption, though I have absolutely zero idea what they're doing for revenue.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by coryl on Friday September 10, 2010 @03:38AM (#1678189)
I want to clone/steal their ideas!

But actually, their originality and novelty is what gets them popular in the first place. I think if I tried to copy AwesomeReminders today, I'd probably fail the way most people expected the original AwesomeReminders to fail. Being first matters?

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by petercooper on Friday September 10, 2010 @06:16AM (#1678400)
You might not be able to, but being first isn't everything. The right person could copy AwesomeReminders with the right twist (and the twist is key). Being first is, in fact, harder since the first entrant into a market has to prove it exists! We now know there are > 700 people who like the idea of someone validating them over the phone each day.

I suspect that most self help gurus could sell a similar service to their user bases at a higher rate. Would I pay $100/mo for Tony Robbins to call me for 1 minute once a week with an inspirational message? Probably not, but I'd bet my left arm that 100 or more of his devotees would, and it'd be a $10k/mo revenue stream for 2 hours per week.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by fezzl on Friday September 10, 2010 @04:15AM (#1678239)
cf. MillionDollarHomepage.com epic fails
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by wlievens on Friday September 10, 2010 @04:26AM (#1678250)
"a few thousand a month" is quite ambitious for a single, "super simple" app. You should consider building a dozen super simple apps that bring in "a few hundred"... seems more doable.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by frobozz on Friday September 10, 2010 @06:04AM (#1678377)
I believe that the "million dollar homepage", and "one red paperclip" were quite financially successful. Both super simple and quick to build, however, as others have mentioned - it's not the thing itself, but the marketing of it that is important.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by matthewphiong on Friday September 10, 2010 @07:28AM (#1678530)
Super simple it may seems to most of us -- simple website, etc but the work, effort, energy needed behind the scene is whole lot than you think. This is real human calling every day, not a computer-cron job call.

I believe there is no such thing as super simple, deploy and forget money making product. The amount of time, effort, energy are the key things that make the money counts.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by vijayr on Friday September 10, 2010 @02:12PM (#1679669)
I remember coming across this one

http://www.calendarsquick.com/printables/index.html

no clue how much money it makes, but I was thinking can such a simple service make money?

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by danielhodgins on Saturday September 11, 2010 @11:39PM (#1682984)
I wonder though if the 700 subscribers figure is legit. Would be easy to fake that. Perhaps a good chunk of the subscribers are all curious internet marketers and developers wondering how they can spin off their own variation/twist on the concept.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by what on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:50PM (#1684637)
I think most people bought it as an annoying joke gift for their friends. I know I did.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by revorad on Friday September 10, 2010 @07:04AM (#1678482)
AwesomenessReminders in other languages could work, if you can hack the relevant distribution channels (as patio11 pointed out).
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by mahmud on Friday September 10, 2010 @07:20AM (#1678520)
Who could be as vein? I speak 5 languages, other than English, and couldn't fathom a market for it.

But then, I was actively against the idea when Zack announced it, so what do I know?

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by revorad on Friday September 10, 2010 @08:53AM (#1678669)
Well yeah, I thought it was a pretty weird idea too. I speak a few Indian languages, but I can only imagine desi people hurling abuses back at random people calling them to say "Bhai waah aap ka to jawaab nahi!". Might work with some niche like Indians abroad doing it for their extended families or something.

Or maybe people from other countries might buy it.

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by envain on Friday September 10, 2010 @04:51AM (#1678282)
well, if i could, i would have already.

There seems to be some lore about doing good SEO over possibly syndicated content and google ads your way to profit. have heard different people say this in one form or the other, and have seen some sites based on this model ...

can only guess what the investment/returns involved would be

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by percept on Friday September 10, 2010 @10:09AM (#1678864)
Who's got the "Mail-a-Letter" app? That one's pretty simple and I think it was doing a few thousand a month.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by ezl on Friday September 10, 2010 @02:50PM (#1679798)
http://snail.dustincurtis.com/ is one such app. I don't recall seeing any revenue numbers on it though.
Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by percept on Monday September 13, 2010 @01:44PM (#1687434)
Nah, it was this one, basically low-volume direct mail:

http://mixergy.com/mailfinch-paul-singh-interview/

Re:Ask HN: Super simple, revenue generating products? by iterationx on Sunday September 12, 2010 @05:43PM (#1684626)
craigslist, yahoo answers