News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by dmihal on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:01PM (#16738702)
It's incredible how fast the sentiment has changed regarding Facebook. Back in 2010/2011 Facebook was being praised for fueling the Arab Spring, which toppled dictators and spread democracy (also lead to the horrific war in Syria).

Today, stories bounce from fake news, to Russian propaganda, to user data mishandling, to fueling genocide in Myanmar.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by FilterSweep on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:06PM (#16738743)
> Back in 2010/2011 Facebook was being praised for fueling the Arab Spring, which toppled dictators and spread democracy (also lead to the horrific war in Syria).

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought that was Twitter as the major player RE: Arab Spring.

I think 8 years is a more than long enough time for backend changes in a platform to change sentiment. Also, the platform may not have been used for as many nefarious purposes in the past.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by ghostbrainalpha on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:43PM (#16739088)
I visited Facebook during this period, and the whole company was celebrating their role in the Arab Spring, which was large as well.

The rhetoric around this has shifted, not because Facebook has done anything different. Or because subsequent uprisings have been any different.

But those mini revolutions of the Arab Spring were not what we thought they were. "The People" taking power from the dictators, created the society they want, but it is LESS in line with liberal values than the previous one. This is what we failed to realize at the time.

Facebook has done an amazing job empowering the will of the people. Which we are still inclined to view as positive.

But when the majority of people WANT a government that is less tolerant of other religions than a dictator would be, what should we do? Should we blame Facebook? Or should we try to use Facebook to counter the hateful ideas that are being spread?

How trivial would it be to make sure this leader in the article who 'never met a Muslim', was forced to scroll through a feed with positive messages about Muslims and religious tolerance?

If Ghandi or Martin Luther King Jr. were alive today could they sway our elections with a billion dollar ad budget? We can't force any other group to live by our values. But we can promote what are values and ideas are, in a way that might be help them spread.

Maybe we should ask Facebook to help with this, instead of trying to take down the whole network just because some groups are using the platform in a way that we don't like.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by pjc50 on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:25PM (#16739503)
> But those mini revolutions of the Arab Spring were not what we thought they were. "The People" taking power from the dictators, created the society they want, but it is LESS in line with liberal values than the previous one. This is what we failed to realize at the time.

This is tragically true. A revolution is a re-spin of the the roulette wheel when it comes to outcomes, the result is absolutely not guaranteed. In the case of Egypt, the semi-secular military dictatorship was overthrown and became .. an Islamic theocracy, which was actually worse for the average woman on non-devout Muslim, and the ensuing counter-revolution back to military dictatorship was reluctantly acquiesced to.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by enimodas on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @07:14AM (#16743532)
Revolutions have a really bad track record. For example http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1043463970090030...
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by lulmerchant on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:33PM (#16740822)
>How trivial would it be to make sure this leader in the article who 'never met a Muslim', was forced to scroll through a feed with positive messages about Muslims and religious tolerance?

So when the users don't conform to the world view of the platform operators, the answer is platform sponsored propaganda? That is incredibly dystopian.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:10AM (#16744267)
> So when the users don't conform to the world view of the platform operators, the answer is platform sponsored propaganda? That is incredibly dystopian.

Advertising is propaganda dedicated to getting you to conform the advertiser's preferences, and it's already targeted however the advertiser prefers, which could be by lack of conformance to those preferences.

You are basically suggesting that the platform operator doing themselves what they already build their business around allowing anyone with a checkbook to do is dystopian.

I would suggest it is no more dystopian than the status quo.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by jnbiche on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:51PM (#16740945)
> So when the users don't conform to the world view of the platform operators, the answer is platform sponsored propaganda?

Facebook sponsors propaganda all the time. Its algorithms favor certain posts and messages over others, based on a long list of attributes, including ad dollars. But apparently that's OK, while suggest that Facebook display some positive third-party post about Muslims in Myanmar - while a genocide is underway - is suddenly "platform-sponsored propaganda"?

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by lulmerchant on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:06PM (#16741023)
I don't support any of the propaganda that Facebook pushes. This also doesn't have anything to do with ads. The issues is that when these mega-platforms decide that they are going to promote one side of a political issue, and suppress another (as they have been doing more and more), this comes at the cost of freedom of expression, and all you're left with is corporate approved discourse.

Of course this is much easier to rationalize in this situation. However that's how you end up giving away liberty. You give it up in little pieces in response to extreme situations, then when you go back about your life you don't get it back.

The real issue here is that this gets the whole problem backwards. We shouldn't be looking at a state-sponsored genocide and then claiming that "if only Facebook had more control over public discourse then we'd be able to solve this problem". The "problem" in that statement can be anything from this genocide taking place, to your preferred candidate losing an election. "We need more propaganda" isn't going to solve any of that, and in reality it's just a veiled power grab by companies that wish to control public discourse more effectively.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by jnbiche on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:17PM (#16741088)
> We shouldn't be looking at a state-sponsored genocide and then claiming that "if only Facebook had more control over public discourse then we'd be able to solve this problem".

The genocide in Myanmar has both state-sponsored and spontaneous characteristics. Facebook can and should help with the latter, if it's going to allow folks to pass around pro-genocide messaging using the site.

In the end, I advocate for everyone to abandon all large-scale, centralized, corporate social media, but given how unrealistic this goal is at present, my next hope is for the large social media companies to assume more responsibility for their actions. The same standards that we've traditionally held all media companies to.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by lulmerchant on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:52PM (#16741262)
But why is propaganda your preferred option over traditional content moderation? I doubt many people would considering it controversial to censor calls to violence. However when you start to focus on "hate speech" (which is where this line of reasoning will take you) and add propaganda to your moderation toolkit, then you start to cross the line into full blown dystopia territory.

Again, this may be a more compelling example of how you might define "hate speech". But if you think facebook has a responsibility to start moderating speech based on its perceived "hatefulness", then you're still going to end up at the same destination, where genuine public discourse is gradually replaced with corporate approved discourse.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by ghostbrainalpha on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @11:10AM (#16745366)
You think 'content moderation' is less dystopian than 'propoganda'....

I think you are hearing something I didn't say.

I'm just talking about promoting some TED Talks. Making sure everyone can name at least 1 good Muslim. Maybe trying to raise the profile of the people who should be winning the Nobel Peace prize.

If someone is IN a hate group. I would like them to have some limited exposure to the views of the other side. I don't think that's propaganda.

I think 'content moderation' has a much higher potential for abuse, and a nightmare future.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by haldean on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:06PM (#16738737)
...except it didn't really spread democracy, at least not in a particularly long lasting way. Maybe what we've learned is that fueling populist uprisings isn't something that is particularly good, and that seems to be what Facebook is good for, politically.
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by nostalgeek on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:06PM (#16739294)
It did make Tunisia a bit more democratic since Ben Ali left, which is where everything started. But Egypt, where all the US reporters rushed to witness the "revolution", is back to a US backed dictatorship, Syria is in shambles, Libya is in chaos, Nothing changed in Morocco or Algeria. And curiously nobody on Facebook or Twitter was talking about the violent revolts inside the gulf monarchies that were harshly repressed by their respective governments.
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by castle-bravo on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:30PM (#16740808)
The way you describe it, it's as though American social media companies were used as tools to further the geopolitical objectives of the United States and its allies.
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by Consultant32452 on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:22PM (#16738921)
I had to look up populism to make sure:

>A political philosophy supporting the rights and power of the people in their struggle against the privileged elite.

The idea that the government is going to go after Facebook because it is used to fuel the rights and power of the people in their struggle against the privileged elite is very scary.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by dragonwriter on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:33PM (#16739008)
You need to read the rest of the Wikipedia article you quoted withoit attribution, and he recognize that a frequent use of “populism” without qualifiers is to refer more specifically to authoritarian populism, particularly emergent authoritarian populism built around a mythologized virtuous people opposed by an equally mythologized evil “elite” (which often is not an actual elite, just a recognizable group around whom a conspiracy theory of behind-the-scenes power has been constructed.)
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by Consultant32452 on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:28PM (#16740012)
That's funny, I use DDG and when I searched "define populism" that's the result that came up from DDG itself, which they say came from Wordnik.

https://www.wordnik.com/words/populism

I disagree with your sense of unqualified populism implies authoritarian populism. In my experience it's used without qualifiers to describe both Trump and Bernie. I suppose whether you think those two are authoritarian probably depends a lot on your own political leanings. But generally it means "fight the power." Or in Trump's case, "drain the swamp [0]." Here's a NYT article that, having skimmed, seems reasonable to me.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/27/magazine/how-can-donald-t...

[0]: This comment is not intended to confer any positive feelings towards Trump or imply that he did anything other than make the swamp even swampier. It was only in reference to his rhetoric

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by jnbiche on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:54PM (#16740960)
> I suppose whether you think those two are authoritarian probably depends a lot on your own political leanings.

I think both the Trump and Bernie movements have some frightening populist characteristics. But between the two leaders, only Trump has been broadcasting blatant authoritarian messaging.

That's not to say that Bernie would never engage in any authoritarian action if he were elected, but he's not made overt any authoritarian tendencies like Trump has.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by denom on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:45PM (#16741229)
Perhaps a simpler definition of populism is to acquire power outside of traditional state institutions. What makes this a bit frightening is that those institutions cannot regulate the worse excesses of that leader.
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by wu-ikkyu on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:44PM (#16739094)
How is that different from a democracy that was founded in opposition to monarch or dictator like the USA?

From the wiki on Populism:

>Populism is most common in democratic nations and political scientist Cas Mudde wrote: "Many observers have noted that populism is inherent to representative democracy; after all, do populists not juxtapose 'the pure people' against 'the corrupt elite'?".[6]

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by notahacker on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:25PM (#16739501)
The populist rhetorical device of directing mass public hatred against a particular target is used at least as easily by dictators - aspirant or actual - as against them, particularly when it relies on open communication to flourish.

Sure, populist upheaval can lead to American Revolutions. But it can just as easily lead to pogroms, and one of those patterns is repeated far more often throughout history than the others.

[dead]
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by dang on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @04:01PM (#16748538)
We've already asked you to stop using HN for ideological battle. It's not what this site is for! Would you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended from now on?
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by ihsw2 on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:34PM (#16739017)
Empathy and self-control have been the internal enforcers of the civilizing process, a process of which many peoples across the world are constantly struggling with, and the nature of Facebook is such that those internal enforcers are broken down with such swiftness that our current situation is inevitable.

The mantra of "move fast and break things" has driven us off a cliff, where our moral backbone is what has been broken.

Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by tclancy on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:12PM (#16738799)
Wasn't that Twitter to the point the State Department contacted them about moving a planned service outage?
Re:UN: Facebook has turned into a beast in Myanmar by vikiomega9 on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:59PM (#16741295)
I think a lot of that praise in American media was an extension of neoconservatism that permeated the administrations around that time