Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by truculation on Friday March 30, 2018 @12:47PM
(#16717681)
Fascinating. Instead of banning money or fixing prices (did they try that in Russia?) we retain free markets but now with a new layer of government intervention. Not intervention by social spending or regulation but by buying and selling according to the dictats of an AI. And the utility function of this AI is set according to what exactly?
My guess is it would have to be according to our values, not to specific goals:
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by fossuser on Friday March 30, 2018 @01:26PM
(#16718019)
This is the goal alignment problem that MIRI, FHI, and some safety groups at Open AI are working on. It seems like a hard problem to get right (with bad consequences if not aligned super intelligence happens first).
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by UncleEntity on Friday March 30, 2018 @05:05PM
(#16719785)
> Not intervention by social spending or regulation but by buying and selling according to the dictats of an AI.
Which would still run up against The Economic Calculation Problem which has constrained all central planning proposals and (probably) always will.
Once they solve that then we can talk about an AI which can predict the outcomes of billions upon billions of individual decisions which are made by market actors to fulfill their wants and needs.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by rmateus on Friday March 30, 2018 @10:02AM
(#16716124)
Multicriteria value decision analysis theory and methods are able to provide the solution to model the need (utility).
For instance, in reinforcement learning the payoff (goal) function is always a given without any depth consideration about its construction. It can be modeled by using the methods referred previously.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by rmateus on Saturday March 31, 2018 @04:45PM
(#16725093)
Multicriteria optimization is distinct from multicriteria value decision analysis. The former does not model the value/utility of the criteria, while the latter does. If you do not model value/utility (what you need) then you cannot solve the underlying multicriteria problem.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by xapata on Friday March 30, 2018 @08:25PM
(#16720911)
No, unless I've mistaken the phrase, they're not the same. I'm thinking of the problem when competing criteria can't be satisfactorily combined as inputs to a function with a scalar output. This comes up in ethical paradoxes, for example.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by akshayB on Friday March 30, 2018 @11:15AM
(#16716748)
Companies make things that they can sell in a marketplace it is necessarily not what that place needs. For example social media companies just want to sell their social networks in any country with internet irrespective of that country have drinking water problem or humanitarian crisis.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by debt on Friday March 30, 2018 @03:04PM
(#16718874)
Peter Norvig’s book A modern approach to AI is pretty cool. I don’t know what they use now in 101 AI courses but I remember that book being very complete.
I still believe though that hard AI will only ever be possible if we ever make serious breakthroughs in the material sciences.
Re:You Can Always Get What You Want, But Not What You Need (...
by dikkechill on Saturday March 31, 2018 @12:01AM
(#16721651)
To differentiate between needs and (economic) wants, I found the "fundamental human needs" framework quite useful:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_human_needs
(as developed by Chilean Economist Manfred Max-Neef).
The sentiment is something I (and I suspect many other engineers) feel, but not able to express it nearly so simply and elegantly.
Before you sit down and start writing that code or creating that new algorithm, stop and think about what you really want to achieve.
My guess is it would have to be according to our values, not to specific goals:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tZBViI8ZaU0
Which would still run up against The Economic Calculation Problem which has constrained all central planning proposals and (probably) always will.
Once they solve that then we can talk about an AI which can predict the outcomes of billions upon billions of individual decisions which are made by market actors to fulfill their wants and needs.
As far as I can tell, the government is the least active actor in this area, so curious choice of picking it here.
I still believe though that hard AI will only ever be possible if we ever make serious breakthroughs in the material sciences.
Basically: Subsistence, Protection, Affection, Understanding, Participation, Leisure, Creation, Identity and Freedom.