While we have compulsory health insurance not dissimilar to the German system, most areas only have one or two providers (vs. 130 of Germany) whose prices have been going up like 30% every year. We still pay out of pocket for most medicine, dentistry, emergency (like ambulances), and psychological services.
Some utilities are ridiculously expensive. Like internet can be 80$ a month for basic 2 mbps.
A large number of people are employed as contractors these days (the gig economy), which adds a 15% tax (that the employer would pay for employees) for a social security service we will likely never see, so I'm not sure the tax burden is higher. Contractors also have to pay for all their own health insurance (and our cutoff for public assistance for health insurance is like 12k, not the 50k Euro like in Germany)
Which brings me to: we have to pay for our own retirement, even if not contractors most companies don't assist with that anymore, especially for entry level jobs.
I'm not complaining. I'm happy to have those speeds as I live in a very rural area (South/Midwest). I can stream netflix or youtube without hitches, almost all the time.
And I second @sokoloff—I've never heard of a plan that had an order of magnitude greater for upstream!
Now in SF, I order sushi twice per week. Go out at least 3-4 times per week and lots of times pay for drinks for friends etc, never walk when going out always rideshare. And it's not only about alcohol and food of course.
I could be saving way way more if not for this lifestyle. That's how it goes. Everyone who tells you otherwise are lying to you and worse themselves. Basic human nature. The moment you make more money, you want to take your girlfriend/boyfriend to a fancier restaurant. You want to buy the nicer phone. Except for rent prices which are insanely high, the regular cost of living is not that much higher than living in eastern europe. Actually funny enough when I first moved here, I was shocked at how cheap everything seemed - of course taking into consideration the high salaries. In many cases actually eastern europeans pay more for certain things because for some unknown reason 1 dollar turns to 1 euro, instead of 0.75 of a euro or whatever the price at the moment is. Our petty $350 salaries can sure take it!
Mate, people here have a favorite whisky!I now have a favorite whisky. And as any self-respecting adult it needs to be fancy, not the cheap stuff. Ardbeg, tastes smoky, like swalloing in dim campfire and most bars here will charge you $16 for a glass. There you have it, how people aren't saving money.
It adds up. But I also have a friend here who on a 120k engineer salary and saved 100k in 2 years. Only eating at work, living on a shared room with 3 more people in treasure island. Reimbursing bus fares to work etc. The other side of the coin. Almost everyday I say to myself that soon I will do the same, and sure enough every day I don't. Just like not going to the gym and forgetting to call mom again.
I'm not sure about housing though. There's a few crazy cities in the US, NY, SF, LA etc. But by and large, the median American pays a substantially lower square footage price than citizens of somewhat similarly rich European countries like the UK, Netherlands, France, Germany, as far as I'm aware. And we also have our outliers in London, Paris etc where the price-income ratio is off the charts. The US has far more land and is far less dense than Western-Europe, with land prices as a function of density (demand for land) I'd say Europeans have less real purchasing power on housing.
Now I spend ~$80 with Google Fi, but I could rely exclusively on wifi and reduce that to ~$20/30. Every other american company seems to want to extract >$80 per month from you.
That's not entirely true. In many cities, minimum wage is substantially higher ($12-$15/hr) than the Federal minimum ($7.25/hr)
> in big cities > So you have to have a car and car insurance
Not in big cities.
I'm saying this as someone who previously had a 1 hr 20 min commute via public transit just to go 16 miles, and that was with the relatively good public transit in the Portland metro area and me literally living a block away from main downtown transit hub.
Name five big cities where a average-wage worker can get by without a car and car insurance.
No demand, no program. Ride a bus in a large city, and you'll see a majority of bus pass users.
My wife and I were in Barcelona a few weeks ago to celebrate our honeymoon. Prior to going, I did some research on what life was like there. The max salary for most people in tech in the area is about €75,000 (~$USD 93.5k). This is considered a great wage over there. The rents within the city are similar to NYC (studios >€1000k, etc). Barna has a pretty good transit system, but living farther out requires a car. Also, employees get taxed HARD all over Europe and the cost of goods (groceries, entertainment, etc) aren't cheaper than their US counterparts.
The story is similar in London.
It just doesn't compute for me.
Basically, Europeans on average have much lower incomes than Americans, and they seem much more frugal.
That's still $11k coming out of your pocket for the privilege of living in California.
I don’t dispute that state taxation makes a difference. I dispute that it makes such a huge difference.
As for triple the salary in eastern Europe, well, housing and other big expenses are presumably lower. But so is the standard of living.
You have to compare people to those around them.
Plenty of people in Africa would think a $10k annual salary is exorbitant and unnecessary.
As an example, last I looked the GDP per capita in San Francisco is $48K, whereas in Miami it is $24K. That is a pretty massive difference, and leads to very different outcomes in a lot of areas.
The best way to think of the USA - and China BTW, which has an even worse demographic spread - is to compare it not to one country like England, or Croatia or the Czech Republic, but to the EU as a whole. Luxembourg is Washington DC, Switzerland is Connecticut, London is New York, Seattle is Berlin, Croatia is Alabama and New Orleans is Barcelona. Those are not exact comparisons, but just a framework for understanding how aggregate US results are so weird.
Because even healthcare, if you combine the population Conneticut and Massachusetts, it is the same as Sweden's with very similar outcomes. Alabama and Mississippi, on the other hand, aren't doing quite as well.
TL;DR, The average for the USA is really misleading, as the spread is much larger than it is in smaller (area and population) countries.
No, it doesn't. It's rent and healthcare.
Tax burden is higher here as well, and while the cost of housing is exorbitant many parts of the US, so it is in cities like Dublin, London and Paris, but without the salary adjustments you see in San Francisco, New York, etc.
This makes it difficult to understand why frugality is impossible for an American making triple the average salary of an average Czech or Croatian.