Very few of the big cities in the US have public transit that's even sufficient for most people to get to work, let alone to sustain the rest of a reasonable lifestyle.
I'm saying this as someone who previously had a 1 hr 20 min commute via public transit just to go 16 miles, and that was with the relatively good public transit in the Portland metro area and me literally living a block away from main downtown transit hub.
> Not in big cities.
Name five big cities where a average-wage worker can get by without a car and car insurance.
5 can probably be done. (assuming "average" is average for that city, not national average). NYC, DC, Seattle, SF, Boston, Chicago... Naming 10 is probably way harder.
Seattle can be tough at least. Really depends on a lot on where you live and where you work. Almost any commute can be done but it easily gets to 2h+ which is just ridiculous.
Seattle is the only one I have personal experience with and I've found it to be pretty good. Usually walking < 1 mile total is reasonable. If you live out in King county things are a little different of course. Are the other cities better than that?
Hence why I mentioned "average-wage" in GP; usually you can avoid owning a car only by living in housing that is out of reach for anyone making <$6k/month.
I don't understand the comment. Is Seattle not doable for <6k $/mo?
Most places in the US, housing near transit options is pretty expensive. Further out, where you get to housing being affordable, is nowhere near transit.
Yeah, that's fair but, from experience, the threshold in Seattle is much less than 6k
It's probably any of the five big cities with a public transit program.
No demand, no program. Ride a bus in a large city, and you'll see a majority of bus pass users.
Can you name one that doesn't?
LA. San Diego. Salt Lake City. Atlanta. Houston. Dallas. Miami.
If you are making $36,000 per year, you are not making minimum wage. People that make around this much, their salary doesn't vary drastically like a software engineer's does city to city.
I can think of maybe 2 or 3 cities where minimum wage is anywhere near that high. And at least one of them that's coming close, Los Angeles, you absolutely need a car. New York, maybe San Francisco or Portland, you could reliably get around without a car.
Re:Being frugal is for the rich
by mr_spothawk on Monday March 26, 2018 @04:14PM
(#16682120)
Phoenix is pretty big. You could very easily spend 2 hours getting halfway across it on a bus.
That's not entirely true. In many cities, minimum wage is substantially higher ($12-$15/hr) than the Federal minimum ($7.25/hr)
> in big cities > So you have to have a car and car insurance
Not in big cities.