News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by mankash666 on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:49PM (#16670400)
Google is as much to blame here as Facebook is. It shouldn't have allowed apps with "contacts" permission to scrape sms & call logs. I hope both of them are held accountable
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by stefan_ on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:53PM (#16670414)
If I run a program, I don't expect it to scrape my home folder just because technically my OS granted it permission to do so. And I don't think that is a distinction the law makes, either. Intent and explicit consent matter.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by AlexandrB on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:03AM (#16672003)
> If I run a program, I don't expect it to scrape my home folder just because technically my OS granted it permission to do so.

Back in the day, apps that did this were called spyware and would be forcibly removed by Antivirus/Anti-malware programs. It's incredible that Facebook gets a pass for equivalent behaviour.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by TheKarateKid on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:23PM (#16673230)
> Back in the day, apps that did this were called spyware

Right?! Remember when ad/spyware that tracked every site you visited were considered devilish and flagged by virus scanners? Now it's the norm. Crazy.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Too on Sunday March 25, 2018 @05:06AM (#16671403)
While i agree with your view here i think app developers have proven over and over again that this is no longer a reasonable expectation we can have as users. We need more and stricter sandboxes for everything.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by harry8 on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:55AM (#16672175)
We can wear bullet proof vests every time we leave the house too.

Put a few app developers in jail for what they do and render their businesses bankrupt and maybe we don't need to treat our phones as hostile to their owners?

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by gruez on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:51PM (#16670631)
Not a fair comparison because there's no sandbox for desktop apps.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by perl4ever on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:15AM (#16670724)
Not everything that's permitted is compulsory. I mean, suppose you frequent a store with a penny tray and you decide, since it's ok to take one penny, why not take all of them? And if you get away with that, why not start cleaning out tip jars? Maybe you will get arrested, but maybe not. I feel like computers are training people that everything you are technically permitted to do is worth trying. I'm not even sure what the rules should be, but rather I feel like losing a common sense of unwritten rules is losing part of what it means (or used to mean) to be human.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by gwbas1c on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:33AM (#16670916)
The app store is front and center on Mac. All apps are sandboxed by default. Steam is another sandbox. A browser is a sandbox.

The problem is that it's hard to write an interesting Mac desktop application that runs in a sandbox. The kind of complexities that require a full blown desktop application just don't fit in a sandbox. (As opposed to a game, mobile, or web app.) Whatever runs in a sandbox turns out to be just a prettier version of a web app, or a self-contained game.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by comex on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:24AM (#16671041)
Nitpick, but I'm pretty sure Steam doesn't actually sandbox the games you download through it.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by AlexandrB on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:07AM (#16672013)
Nope, not at all. In fact many games on Steam come with their own additional invasive DRM schemes that do all kinds of things you wouldn't expect.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Twisell on Sunday March 25, 2018 @04:25AM (#16671311)
I often use Pixelmator and Cyberduck sandboxed and downloaded from the AppStore.

I struggle to find out how they are not "interesting" or usable. But I get that it can be hard for developers integrate all constraints of sandboxing.

App Distribution on MacOS was always different (even since pre OSX) compared to the rest of UNIX world. The drag-and drop to deploy for instance must seem ridiculous for people used to install via apt-get command line. Yet it’s way more users friendly because it put the burden of complexity in developer hands instead of users’s.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by gwbas1c on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:49AM (#16672144)
When I watch Mac newcomers try and use drag-and-drop app deployment, I just shake my head at how awful it is.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by dllthomas on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:03AM (#16670854)
I wonder if there's a reasonable CFAA case here...
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by gruez on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:40PM (#16670586)
The permissions are more granular than that. There are specific permissions needed to read SMS and read call logs, but android/google play groups them into top level categories such as "SMS" and "Phone".
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Theodores on Sunday March 25, 2018 @08:27AM (#16671877)
I would like the option to write code that answers my phone or downloads call information or operates a switchboard etc. I don't have a current application but when faxes existed I might have wanted to automate things with an app of my own devising.

I am not a fan of operating systems that deliberately obfuscate things that could technically be done. If I was developing my mobile customer service app then I would like to develop it in such a way that it would not mysteriously fail due to some overly complicated access keys. Or to require a 'rooted' device.

I would not expect my app to be fit for the Google store though. Or any other online app store. Maybe rather than permissions it is the store and what is allowed in the store that is a problem.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ben_jones on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:21PM (#16670512)
Was it just too much work for the Android team to add more granular permissions? Did they not have enough time? Enough resources?
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by shsuudjdjjdjs on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:48PM (#16670616)
None of the above. It is a hard UI problem to present the plethora of different features that need access control to the user such that they can meaningfully engage with each one.

For example: which of the following permissions does the Facebook app currently get on Android?

    - access Bluetooth settings
    - access nfc settings
    - view network connections
I bet you don't know off the top of your head, and I'm certain that fewer than one in a hundred users do.

This is not because Android team is lazy. All of this information is already surfaced to those who care to look, right there in the play store app. There's a spectrum of options between removing capabilities, presenting them in more detail, and providing a UI that doesn't make people's eyes glaze over. There is a constant tension among these three poles, and no matter where you are, there will be some use case that isn't served well.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by tehwebguy on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:51AM (#16670826)
No, permissions were done in a substantially more granular way on iOS from the beginning of permissions. Contacts, photos, location, notifications all with their own permission request API to be fired at will.

Android started off with a blanket permission screen required to even install an app — all or nothing.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by adrianmonk on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:28PM (#16673255)
I don't think granular is the right word here. Android defines something like 150 permissions, so granularity is there.

The issue is (in old versions of Android) you cannot be selective about which ones you grant.

The relevance is that when it comes to transparency, the big dialog of all permissions can disclose a fair amount of detail to the user about exactly what they're being asked to allow.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by dannysu on Sunday March 25, 2018 @11:40AM (#16672647)
http://www.idownloadblog.com/2013/02/01/path-ftc-settlement/

I think Apple didn't always have that. There was the Path scandal and outcry that caused Apple to introduce better privacy options.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by untog on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:17PM (#16673539)
iOS isn't more granular, it just defers permission requests to the app rather than the app store. In proper practice that app then only asks for permissions when the user is performing an action that requires them, which at least helps the user to understand why they are being asked. Android has now shifted to this model too, but as always, old versions of Android persist.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by jakeogh on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:02AM (#16670676)
There is some truth to that, but it's not that hard of a problem. Start by making a dependency tree, and only displaying the top nodes. "Do you want to share anything with app X?" yes/no and go from there.

Often the "it's too complicated" excuse is really a cover for "we make out money off your data and fund the development of this software to harvest it".

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by caminante on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:14AM (#16670721)
No, "it's too complicated" also recoils on consumers. I don't think your proposal would change behaviors.

Mass market customers don't read contracts and readily give out SSNs, credit card info, and other personal identifiers.

As a law prof. at NYU said,

>“For the most part [having read the contract] doesn’t matter,” she said. “Things don’t usually go wrong — except when they do. And then it matters.”[0]

[0]https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/13/your-money/novel-length-c...

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by jakeogh on Sunday March 25, 2018 @07:26AM (#16671714)
Permissions are not long contracts, they fit in a single sentence. My super obvious suggestion further simplifies it. There's no reason a dep tree cant be made. The "people are too X" does not work.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by caminante on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:05PM (#16673120)
My point's intent was to argue that consumer behaviors (not just those of firms) also shape these outcomes.

Do you have any studies or sources that support a permissions dependency tree approach for mass market customers?

I like "just-in-time" permissions (i.e. This app wants to use your location. yes/no?) That way, you aren't faced with accepting or not using the service at all, at the outset. [0]

[0] https://news.engin.umich.edu/2017/10/nobody-reads-privacy-po...

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by jakeogh on Monday March 26, 2018 @05:32AM (#16677688)
RE studies: As far as I know it has never been tried. Dependency trees are common elsewhere in the software world.

This "just in time" stuff is awful, in it's simple form, the user only has to click incorrectly once. The obvious way is a dep tree. Start with:

"should any app be able to download your contact list?"

if no (global!!) -> "can I have one contact right now" and tag that information for the provider "I don't expect you to keep this" or "please keep this info and use it to market to me". Really, it's mostly just excuses, there is no reason to upload the data 99% of the time, only the local software "needs" it for a instant, and even then, that's because the OS stack is designed wrong. I don't want new law to mandate this stuff, I want users to demand it with existing contract law.

Making it "per app" instead of global settings with very deliberate and specific (one time unless instructed otherwise) exceptions is exactly what I would do if I wanted to design a system to maximize my user data snarf ability.

Android is new, nothing is "great" at first, I'm not expecting it to be right yet, but ignoring obvious fixes like this going forward is (hopefully) going to give it's forks more power.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by shsuudjdjjdjs on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:08AM (#16670701)
I'm confident that you would not consider it so easy if you had ever meaningfully engaged with this problem. The simple fact is no one has cracked the nut yet, and not for lack of trying. Either it it is hard, or everyone who has worked on mobile device capability systems is evil or incompetent. I think the former is more likely.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Twisell on Sunday March 25, 2018 @04:31AM (#16671325)
Ok but then I really don’t want to read any more crap article about why Apple is lagging behind because their approach to privacy is restraining them to harness the full power of machine learning bla-bla-bla
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by shsuudjdjjdjs on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:51PM (#16673041)
It is fine to want things. These articles are as well founded as those that complain about the way Android does permissions. In that, they inform us about the spectrum of possible preferences among users. But inevitably every user considers only their use case, not how fixing it might break other use cases.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by jakeogh on Sunday March 25, 2018 @07:28AM (#16671722)
Are you claiming that there is no dep tree to be made? That's trivially false if so. Feeding apps fake data (for example to make them work with no data perms) has been suggested too many times to count.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by lostlogin on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:18AM (#16670729)
Really? When the service is free it provides a a clue as to what may be happening. Not always true but a safe starting point.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by shsuudjdjjdjs on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:34AM (#16670781)
Did you mean to respond to some other comment? In this thread, we are talking about cell phone permission systems. We are not talking about a "service," and the system in question is not something one buys or gets for free on its own.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by jakeogh on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:38AM (#16670798)
If it's "free" and requires infrastructure you don't own that should be a big flashing clue.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Sylos on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:11AM (#16671012)
I'm sure, there's cases where they just didn't want to have too many prompts, as that would result in people not reading them either.

But in other cases, this is also just Google that we're talking about. There's for example a presentation [1] where a Google dev introduces this new permission system and afterwards someone from the audience asks, if it's also possible to block internet access with it.

And the Google dev responds in the most innocent of ways that it doesn't need to be possible, because clearly the rest of their permission system works so flawlessly that no critical information one could want to upload to the internet would be available to apps anyways.

I know, never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity, but it's not like the guy should be able to be this ignorant in the position that he's in. And Google does have reason to be malicious here. Without internet permission, their ads can't be displayed.

Especially the example in the video of the flashlight app is one where the permission system falls completely flat. In order to toggle the flashlight, you need to ask for full access to the camera, meaning you can take pictures as you like. And since you have internet, you can actually do something malicious with those pictures, too. Clearly, the user did not intend for their flashlight app to take pictures and much less so for it to upload them to the internet.

[1] Relevant question is at 18:07: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f17qe9vZ8RM

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by e12e on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:50PM (#16673379)
^this. As long as Google remains an advertising company with some incidental technology projects - they'll be hard pressed to ever fight internal culture/revenue enough to take meaningful steps towards privacy and security.

Just being able to write an app (code on the device) and deploy an ad (code on the Internet - possibility to run "code" like fonts, or trigger calls to site/unique.jpg) - would make preventing data exfiltration and/or tracking absurdly hard while continuing to cater to advertisers aka the paying customers.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by helthanatos on Saturday March 24, 2018 @11:55PM (#16670646)
The Android permission scheme is slowly becoming more granular. I'm not sure what the reason was from the beginning to have such generic permissions. When you saw large lists of permissions on apps before marshmallow, you had to accept them all, now it requests for each on first use but I'm still not a fan of apps that want everything.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:48AM (#16670821)
Android is a decade old. Our expectations of what apps would and wouldn't do, and would and wouldn't be capable of doing has changed. Back when the apps on my phone were in the range of being 400 KB to 600 KB, I don't think people even fathomed the complexity and power our devices are at right now, and their ability to secretly handle ever increasing amounts of our personal data without having a meaningful impact on device performance.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by e12e on Sunday March 25, 2018 @01:57PM (#16673419)
I never expected pine to upload my contact list (or email) to some third party server - or BitchX to steal my chat logs. Yet both programs could have done so.

The difference is that before Android, in the world of windows - we already had a culture of spyware bundled with freeware - as well as viruses/RATs - and plain malicious software - that made it plain that simply allowing random code to execute in a context where it could read data and/or sensors (gps,mic,camera etc) would be a disaster.

There were to workarounds: stewardship (the Linux distro model, like software in debian main etc) or sandboxing.

Android chose too little of each, which essentially amounted to a false sense of security. And here we are.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by AlexandrB on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:10AM (#16672024)
iOS is of similar age and managed not to fall on its face. This is a really bad excuse.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday March 25, 2018 @09:15AM (#16672038)
It's not meant to be an excuse, Android has not aged well, and Google has done a poor job putting security at the forefront of their platform. Apple's taken a lot of flack over the years for making developers jump through new hoops all the time and having such heavy restrictions on their platform, but its clear the users have benefitted in other ways.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by untog on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:19PM (#16673551)
iOS had it's own issue, where Path uploaded a user's entire contact list without needing to ask permission for it. That was a wakeup call for Apple, and it should have been for Google too.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by tanilama on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:08AM (#16670700)
I think permission to read the contact, is different than the permission to store it in your own server.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday March 25, 2018 @12:45AM (#16670814)
From a technical sense it's not. If an app can read data, and an app has Internet access, it can send that data to it's server, and there's nothing your OS can really do about it if it is letting the app run arbitrary code.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by tanilama on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:22AM (#16671033)
I am on the same boat here.

Technically it is NOT google's fault to open those access to Apps.

Just like credit card CVV, the right to grant you the access to it, prohibit you to store in your server. For personal information, I think social networks need to be held responsible to live up to the same standard.

By granting Facebook permission to read my contact, my understanding is that they should only use my contact to match against their DB and find those who are on FB. I don't think this require them to persist all my contact/conversation history in their own server.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ocdtrekkie on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:32PM (#16673643)
Bear in mind, if you give your credit card to a website, the only thing prohibiting them from storing it on their server is fear of getting their PCI DSS certification revoked if they get caught doing it. There's no technical limitation... and there should be.

That's why, of course, chips for physical purchase have moved to one-time codes, effectively, so that your credit card number can't be stored without permission. Ideally, someday our online purchases will work the same way.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ziikutv on Saturday March 24, 2018 @10:51PM (#16670403)
I agree but I'd generalize this to Android. It is an open source system after all.
Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by Sylos on Sunday March 25, 2018 @02:17AM (#16671023)
It is an open-source system, which is decided over purely by Google. They don't have to have any fear of being forked, so they don't have to take the open-source community's opinion into account at all.

The Custom ROMs that exist around it do not play into this. They cannot influence how shitty the ecosystem is, as that's entirely in the hand of Google.

Re:Facebook scraped call, text message data for years from A... by ziikutv on Sunday March 25, 2018 @07:21AM (#16671695)
Noted. Didn’t know that was the case. Fle some reason, I imagined that it being open source would have meant a lot of outside involvement.