Assuming that accidents are independent, we can model this as a Poisson point process. If the accident rate is 1 per 100M miles and Uber has driven 3M miles, the probability of there being zero accidents in that time is P{n=0} = ((λt)^n / n!) * e^(-λt), where λ=1/100M and t=3M. Doing the math, it seems that's 97.04%.
So, yes. It is possible that Uber's accident rate is 1 in 100 million. If so, this incident would fall in that remaining 3%. It's unlikely, but possible.
One thing we can say about the woman killed the other day by an autonomous Uber, is that unlike the other ~40,000 killed on America's roads over the past year, her's was not in vain.
Every day that we delay the widespread deployment of this technology, it's another 100 or so people dead. Of course, the public is unlikely to see it that way. They see one death as a tragedy, but 40,000 is just a statistic, business as usual, nothing to get excited about.
Uber is doing this for money, so is all the other companies even if there are some potential huge collateral benefit for the human race from that. It's definitely not the goals of the companies regardless of any PR talk. So when you gamble with people's life for money and fame you should go to jail for a long time executives or engineers alike.
The statistics are just being used to sustain corporate greed in my mind and we should not let them. Self driving cars has lots of potential to save life, so are other techs. Does't mean that all sense of responsibility and ethics goes away just because of the potential.
Such a thing would be entirely unthinkable in the pharmaceutical industry of today. So if this comparison suggests anything, it is to much more strictly regulate self-driving car development and testing!
The current procedures for clinical trials are the result of decades of experience, where mistakes (and yes, occasionally shortcuts driven by greed) did result in avoidable deaths of trial participants.
For an example of how the pharma industry deals with this 'safety first' versus 'stifling innovation' dilemma, read this article: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1526936/
The inevitable result of this crash is driverless vehicle testing will get regulated more like drug trials...
On the other hand, there are widely used, cheap, and efficient alternative to self-driving cars on the roads today: human drivers, public transport, carpools, etc.
If you want to make analogies, I think the self-driving car accident is more like if an elevator company accidentally crashed an experimental high-speed elevator in a shopping mall. I think it would be grossly negligent on the part of the company to test such an unproven device on the general public, especially if people’s lives are being put in a position of risk which they did not to worry about before.
Trading lives to save on R&D time would violate professional codes of ethics in literally any other industry.
If Uber needs data they could have driven manually. Obvously their obstacle tracking is bad.
This is the real trolly problem when it comes to the ethics of developing self driving cars.
Uber should be banned from doing AI research on public roads
Bayesian approach: To make the math really simple, let's assume a discrete prior on Uber's death rate. Say 33% that Uber's cars are much safer than humans (0.1 deaths per 100M miles), 33% that they are equally safe (1 death per 100M miles), and 33% that they are much more dangerous (10 deaths per 100M miles). After observing one death at 3 million miles, your posterior is should update to {safer: 1%, equal: 11%, more dangerous: 88%). This is a substantial shift in confidence.
Math: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=(1-10%2F100)%5E2*(10%2F...)
Frequentist approach: Let the null hypothesis be that Uber's self-driving cars have the same death rate as humans - 1 death per 100 million miles. The odds of Uber killing someone within 3 million miles is about 3%. Therefore, we can reject the null hypothesis with a p value of 0.03. One positive "data point" is statistically significant.
Statistically, one death after 3 million miles is not proof that Uber's death rate is higher than 1 in 100 million miles. But it is statistically significant, in both a frequentist and Bayesian framework. You have to get really, really unlucky to have a death at 3 million miles if your death rate is 1 per 100 million miles.
Bottom line: This collision isn't proof, but it's strong evidence. (To go along with all the evidence from crash rates, disengagement rates, engineers working at these companies, and the video of the crash itself.)
(I'm guestimating on some of those numbers, but the should be somewhere in the ballpark.)
They let a car on the road that couldn’t even stop at a red light ffs
https://www.theverge.com/2017/2/25/14737374/uber-self-drivin...
The fact that they were allowed to deploy in Arizona after this is really regrettable
And it’s totally unsurprising that Uber “got the first kill”
It only took two incidents to shut down the Concorde program.
Would it have been fair if Uber last week were to declare that they have a 0% probability of pedestrian deaths, since they'd never had one yet?
The goal of these statistics is to predict future outcomes. But with such a small data sample, you cannot fairly predict the future- just as in my lottery example.
I'm not defending Uber here- I'm defending statistics!
With more data, we may discover that Uber cars are 100X worse, not just 25X. Or we may discover they're better. But we don't have the statistical power to make that estimate when we've only seen the event happen once.
In this we agree.
Consider if there was a new lottery and you weren't sure what the odds of winning were. You play it three weeks in a row and the third time you win a million dollars. Conveniently, no one else tries the new lottery yet.
Does it follow then that the odds of winning a million dollars are 1 in 3? Or should you play it a few more times before you declare to all that one in three plays will make one a millionaire?