News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by rbanffy on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:56PM (#16652621)
This. A million times this.

There are no entry-level POWER machines, SPARC machines. There is no entry-level IBM i or Z. There isn't even a software emulator for i (and even for Z, where there is a very nice emulator, you can't legally run anything remotely current on non-IBM hardware).

You can get a cheap POWER or SPARC on Ebay, with a sharp price drop when the equipment is EOL'ed, but that's no way to entice people to build new stuff on a platform.

I love my PA-RISC, my RS/6000's and my SPARCstations, but, neat as they are, they aren't anything that would make me consider building for their modern descendants. And I won't pay more than a decent, proven, certainly useful Xeon workstation worth of money for a cool, but exotic-that-may-not-run-my-software-well, POWER9 performance equivalent.

If IBM wants me to pay Xeon Platinum prices for their production gear, they'd better allow me to pay Core i prices for development gear, or else I'll just keep deploying on Xeon, which is good enough.

Typed on a very comfortable and reasonably priced Core i7 laptop.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by walrus01 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#16652847)
Seconding what you just said, and another thing is that the cost barrier to entry to developing x86-64 software on a very current Linux platform is almost zero. If you are a curious 15 year old who wants to learn Linux stuff you can get an older Core 2 Duo desktop PC for free, or almost free ($20) from a number of recycling places and install the latest debian-testing AMD64 on it. Put it on your home LAN, ssh into it, and start doing whatever you want.

I know of companies that regularly throw away second generation core i5 dual and quad core systems with 8GB of RAM.

The same software you develop on your $20 headless desktop PC can be easily moved over onto a $15/month KVM virtual machine somewhere in hosting. Or onto a used $250 1U server that you can pay to colocate somewhere for $65-100/month with bandwidth. All x86-64 platform.

The massive, massive economies of scale for x86-64 platform stuff are going to be very hard to get people to move away from unless there is an amazingly compelling reason. The ability to cannibalize random recycled computers to make one working computer out of "free" parts is a big thing for the developing world.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by rbanffy on Thursday March 22, 2018 @06:01PM (#16653116)
A very important point is that you mostly don't need to buy a new computer. Chances are a lot of teens already own perfectly good x86 computers that can do a lot of things they want and be the machines they learn to develop software on.

IBM has to compete with free hardware.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by hinkley on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:12PM (#16653933)
IBM might be having trouble letting go of their old model. If you want their amazing hardware they’ll do everything for you. Which means on day one you have none of the expertise needed to reverse that decision.

If you come from a world where lock-in is normal then you may well build something that locks everybody out.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by shaklee3 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:27PM (#16654027)
You aren't their target market share. They are focusing solely on the HPC Market at this point. Their lowest in shape has 16 cores. Contrast that with a xeon at 6 cores. I think you were hoping that they have a desktop processor that you could play around with the actual architecture on. That would be nice, but they likely don't want to put all their eggs in too many baskets right now.
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by rleigh on Friday March 23, 2018 @04:34AM (#16656115)
At the same time, you need mindshare at the lower end to drive demand for the high end. I previously developed for POWER by getting an Apple Mac Mini. Very affordable, and while not a full POWER instruction set was sufficient to test and validate my code. Today, there is no equivalent, and I'm about to dispose of the Mini. I couldn't justify use of POWER today even though we have a datacentre stuffed full of machines for HPC, and could likely make use of it. We have zero experience with it, and no easy way to get any experience. Being able to buy a cheap low-end system for experimentation is important. If I wanted to do this for ARM, I could buy half a dozen cheap boards online this morning and have them delivered by Monday. But POWER is out of reach.
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by walrus01 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @08:57PM (#16654167)
Except for special US DoD things (like supercomputers that simulate nuclear weapons) for Sandia Labs and the like, the math also doesn't work out for HPC...

Let's say that a 44RU rack of 1U, narrow (half of 17.5" width), dual motherboard, single socket systems costs $N if it's built with Xeon or EPYC CPUs. As an example here the Supermicro barebones which are two long, narrow motherboards in 1RU with single sockets and front to rear wind tunnel airflow. Same rack of systems costs $N multiplied by 2.25 if built with power9, but only performs 1.25 times faster.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by shaklee3 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @10:50PM (#16654706)
I don't follow the logic. Where are you getting your pricing information from? Why do you think power is more expensive?
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by walrus01 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @11:02PM (#16654759)
the cheapest power8 server I have ever seen was probably 4x more expensive then the equivalent dual socket xeon. That info is a bit stale. But there is also a complete lack of good information online about actual dollar figures for power8 systems (a lot of "contact us for more info!"). The platform's pricing is aimed at the sort of CTO people who don't care about the cost of Oracle licensing. Not the sort of people who care about $/MIPS for HPC applications or cloud scale hypervisor platforms.

I would very much like to be proven wrong so if you have access to some specific "this hardware spec costs this much money and you can buy it now" info, that i can compare to barebones supermicros, please do share it.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by shaklee3 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @11:51PM (#16654938)
You're right in that the sticker price is much, much higher. I'm surprised you were even available to find one. IBM tends to like to keep things secret until you reach out to them, for better or for worse. I would like to see some public power 9 benchmarks to compare to xeons instead of just marketing speak as well.

But I will say that your comment about $/MIPS isn't accurate. There are many people, including Oakridge national labs, who are using it because of the higher performance and v100 integration. Intel is obviously not too keen on letting Nvidia succeed.

Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by walrus01 on Friday March 23, 2018 @12:23AM (#16655059)
somehow, compared to the vast amounts of money they spend on other things, I think pricing is way down the list of things that are important to organizations like LLNL, Argonne, Sandia, Idaho National Labs, PNNL, etc. Basically everything that uses HPC for DoD top secret projects.
Re:Power 9 May Dent X86 Servers: Alibaba, Google, Tencent Te... by kev009 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @11:17PM (#16654814)
Email supermicro and ask about pricing, they are trying to gauge interest currently.