News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:07PM (#16651044)
It's narrow in the sense that it only applies to sex trafficking. It's not narrow at all in terms of the relationship between your online service and sex trafficking. From your link:

"(Sec. 5) The bill amends the federal criminal code to define a phrase related to the prohibition on sex trafficking. Currently, it a crime to knowingly benefit from participation in a venture that engages in sex trafficking. This bill defines "participation in a venture" to mean knowingly assisting, supporting, or facilitating a sex trafficking violation."

It "facilitates" sex trafficking to be able to use gmail and Google Maps to conduct sex trafficking activities.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by jstarfish on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:23PM (#16651187)
You're leaving out "knowingly," which is an operative word there.

If Google puts out a product offering called "Gmail for Pimps" or a maps overlay called "Where My Bitches At?" then they might be complicit in something. Until then, they are afforded deniability.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by rayiner on Thursday March 22, 2018 @02:33PM (#16651304)
I'm not leaving out "knowingly." Google "knows" that its services are used to do all sorts of unsavory things. You have to assume that Gmail and Gchat have been used to arrange murders.

Your examples cross the line from "knowing" to "intent." They show not only knowledge that products are used for illegal activities, but intention to encourage and profit from that illegal activity. Releasing "Gmail for Pimps" would suggest specific intent to profit from prostitution, rather than just "knowing" that Gmail is being used for prostitution.

"Knowing" and "intent" are terms of art in criminal law, and "knowing" is well understood as being a lower standard than "intent." The law uses "knowing" on purpose.

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by slededit on Thursday March 22, 2018 @04:41PM (#16652498)
That is a much broader reading then is used elsewhere. In general specific knowledge is required.

> The word “knowingly” in law means consciously or with knowledge or complete understanding of the facts or circumstances.

https://definitions.uslegal.com/k/knowingly/

Re:Section 230: A Key Legal Shield for Facebook, Google Is A... by mrunkel on Friday March 23, 2018 @06:18AM (#16656547)
No, if someone else uses Google's tools to create a product offering called "Gmail for Pimps" Google is liable.