News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by Roritharr on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:01PM (#16639302)
This seems like a great way to burn down your house and potentially injure firefighters coming to your rescue. Seriously this is quite a few leagues above normal DIY territory. Proceed with caution.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:20PM (#16639550)
Exactly right. It will catch on fire, it will burn down the house. I expect the insurance would not cover it (just like it doesn't cover fires caused by storing gas or propane in your garage)

I got a crash course on battery charging subtleties when building battle bots and there are many ways this can so south quickly, not the least of which is a battery in the middle of the pack developing dendrites and deciding its time to burn. The only way to prevent that is to have temperature sensors on every battery and a good enough model of the heat convection between the internal battery and the surface to recognize the temperature rise of a battery on its way to failing. Even with modern "battery monitor" chips like the ones Maxim and others sell there are corners in charge rate/temperature/battery that can get away from the algorithm before it recognizes a battery failure.

The reasons this is "easy" with flooded lead/acid batteries is that, when they fail, the lead doesn't then turn into a torch at 500 - 600 degrees F. So you have a chance to fix failures and move on.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by fr0sty on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:31PM (#16639703)
> I expect the insurance would not cover it.

I see this blanket assertion in lots of comment threads, but never with a citation.

> (just like it doesn't cover fires caused by storing gas or propane in your garage)?

This is an assertion I have never seen before. It is extremely common to keep gas cans in the garage around here (IL, USA), where else would you keep them that is safer?

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:51PM (#16639937)
I have discussed it at length with the USAA insurance people, I expect there are policy documents on their web site. The exact discussion was, "If the source of the fire is tracked back to a leaking gas can or a propane tank we won't cover the loss, we recommend you store flammables in a shed away from your house."

My impression from them was they were very dubious about "off book" uses of things as well, which leads to my expectation that they would push back on covering a loss due to a "home made" battery wall. Could I sue them and get them to cover it? I don't know, perhaps. But, as with my propane tanks, I would keep this stuff out away from the house to limit my losses and avoid having to go there.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by Hello71 on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:44PM (#16639844)
I googled "insurance fire caused by gasoline in garage" and found https://cpsc.gov/content/consumers-warned-against-storing-ga... as the third result. "CPSC also warns consumers that private storage of more than a limited amount of gasoline (usually five gallons or less) is illegal in many areas, and subsequent fire damage may not be covered by insurance policies."

although IANAL, storing a large quantity of lithium ion batteries seems likely to be considered negligence, which is generally not covered under insurance.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:14PM (#16640867)
Here is a quote from my insurance policy (Erie Insurance):

> “We” do not pay for loss resulting directly or indirectly from...the discharge, dispersal, release or escape of any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant, pollutant or contaminant, including smoke, vapors, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals and waste

I checked another insurer (State Farm) and they had similar language:

> We do not insure, however, for loss...caused by...Discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of pollutants...Pollutants means any solid, liquid, gaseous or thermal irritant or contaminant, including smoke, vapor, soot, fumes, acids, alkalis, chemicals and waste

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by fr0sty on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:41PM (#16641115)
Keep reading the Erie policy. Look for phrases like:

"...into or upon the land, the atmosphere or any course of or body of water, whether above or below ground."

and

"but this exclusion does not apply if such discharge, dispersal, release or escape is sudden and accidental."

I'm pretty confident you will find them, or something similar.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @03:01PM (#16641264)
I looked, but I don't see anything like that. The exclusions for smoke and water damage do not apply to "sudden and accidental" losses but the pollution one does. And it does not limit it to contamination of the environment.

My Erie policy was emailed to me, but here is a State Farm policy (not the one I quoted above) that has a similar exclusion:

http://www.opic.texas.gov/images/TDI_Approved_Policy_Forms/S...

That said, from googling I gather that there has been a lot of litigation over what counts as a "pollutant," including specifically whether gasoline counts. So I don't think that the presence of this clause means that an insurance company will always try to exclude any losses involving gasoline. I just think maybe they would have an argument if they wanted to.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by fr0sty on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @03:27PM (#16641463)
Look at page 21 of that document.

"This (pollution) exclusion does not apply to bodily injury or property damage:

... (3) caused by common household chemicals used to maintain the residence premises."

Additionally, and perhaps even more importantly, this exclusion is in the "Personal Liability" section of the policy. The coverage/exclusions for the "Dwelling" are on pages 8-12.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @03:39PM (#16641564)
Ah, interesting, I didn't read that to include gasoline but I see how one could argue that it does. The Erie policy has no such language.

In any case, thanks for the responses. My gut reaction is to agree with you that a lot of these "homeowners insurance will deny your claim if you do X!" warnings are based on third-hand knowledge or misinformation. I don't have any special knowledge though. (Do you?)

Edit: oops, you're right of course that I was reading the wrong part of the State Farm document! I swear I am not reading the Erie one so carelessly though.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by dclowd9901 on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:17PM (#16640909)
> I see this blanket assertion in lots of comment threads, but never with a citation.

Imagine a company whose only product is one that if anyone uses, they lose profit. It doesn't take a huge leap of imagination to believe insurance companies will blame literally anything to deny coverage on a house fire.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by fr0sty on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:45PM (#16641147)
And imagine if you had a house fire and had your coverage denied. Would you be at all shy of posting those details on a public forum? I'm not saying that denials like this can't/haven't happened, just that I've never seen a first-hand account of such an occurrence (it's always somebody's cousin's co-worker's son).
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by lostapathy on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:25PM (#16640971)
> (just like it doesn't cover fires caused by storing gas or propane in your garage)

What about the gas in your car or lawnmower?

Where do you store your camping stove?

The insurance texts posted downthread don't actually seem that "damning" to me. They talk about chemicals etc in a blanket sense. If insurance companies were worried about the gas can for your lawn mower, they would come right out and say it.

It's not uncommon for cities and homes associations to prohibit sheds anyway. A gas can in the garage seems a lot less volatile than one sitting in the sun that looks like it's ready to burst.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:30PM (#16641026)
> The insurance texts posted downthread don't actually seem that "damning" to me. They talk about chemicals etc in a blanket sense. If insurance companies were worried about the gas can for your lawn mower, they would come right out and say it.

Why do you think that? I believe the purpose of the exclusions isn't to warn you about what bad things not to do, but rather to allow them to get out of covering certain losses. So broader is better (for them).

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by CPLX on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:56PM (#16639997)
The idea the homeowners insurance doesn't cover the homeowner being negligent or stupid seems to betray a misunderstanding of what homeowners insurance is generally used for, namely protecting the mortgage lender from a catastrophic loss of the property's value.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:33PM (#16640454)
In this case, since I don't have a mortgage, it is really covering my losses. Should my house burn down I don't want to have to go out and pay to rebuild it. I'm willing to take the actions the insurance company requires in order to keep their actuaries happy.

For anyone who isn't aware, California has seen a number of large scale disasters over the last couple of years which have destroyed many homes. From the fires in Santa Rosa to mudslides in Santa Barbara. And I have a number of friends and acquaintances who have been having painful discussions with their insurance companies about what they will and won't cover. I am fortunate that I have not suffered a loss. Seeing that pain though led me to call up and have a long, recorded, and detailed discussion with my insurance company about how they decide what to cover and on what basis they feel entitled to deny a claim. As with people who have actually lost their homes I was surprised at the number of things that they would use as a reason for not paying a claim.

One consistent theme was "unusual hazards that the insurance company was not made aware of." This ranges from people who have turned their garage into a place to do car repairs (adding lifts etc) to people who brew beer under the sink in the kitchen.

On the basis of that conversation, and the assumption that my insurance company was 'typical', I don't expect the battery fire to be covered. :-)

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:22PM (#16640958)
Did you take notes on these conversations? I'm very curious :)
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:27PM (#16641000)
In this particular case I recorded it :-) (with the permission of all involved) so that in the event there was some discrepancy about who said what I could refer to the recording.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:34PM (#16641063)
Any other specific examples you care to share of things that you were surprised to find would not be covered?
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @05:22PM (#16642549)
Not really, there was an interesting digression into the question of using/installing "industrial equipment" (I've always wanted a CNC machine center for my garage.) We have an "industrial" washer and dryer pair (but that was ok). No sense turning this battery example into an insurance thread.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by hundt on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @05:45PM (#16642712)
> No sense turning this battery example into an insurance thread.

aww

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by marshray on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @09:31PM (#16644648)
There's a difference between being negligent (leaving the stove on) and performing unlicensed DIY electrical modifications that were not approved by code inspectors and involve storing huge amounts of energy.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by gist on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:11PM (#16640186)
Exactly. Insurance will generally cover anything that it doesn't specifically exclude in the insurance documents. If you are walking with a can of paint and drop it and destroy your carpet most homeowners policies will pay to replace the carpet. If you leave the water on in the tub (by accident) and flood your house the policy will most likely pay for it. However it won't cover floods from the outside. But it will cover water that comes in from the roof or through the windows (subject to any exclusion for hurricane potentially).

Likewise if you decide to put together an array of lithium batteries in your bedroom most homeowners policies should cover that. After all those batteries already are in products in the house (as opposed to gasoline which would only exist in a lawn mower in small quantities in the garage).

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:14PM (#16640877)
What is most likely to kill you in most fires is the smoke and that is definitely true about Lithium battery fires.

This what makes them so deadly on a plane: you cannot get away.

Assuming that your smoke detector reacts properly to that kind of smoke, you should put one near your battery array.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by maxerickson on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:00PM (#16640063)
In many cases it will only burn down the dedicated battery shed.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by VectorLock on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:09PM (#16639402)
Mixed batteries of unknown provenance/capacity without balancing isn't something I'd want in my basement personally.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by pmorici on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:21PM (#16639563)
If you watch the video it isn't quite what the headline suggests. The guy is collecting 18650 cells from old laptop batteries and using them with his own BMS to build a new battery. Not exactly mixing and matching rando used batteries.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by jpm_sd on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:25PM (#16639608)
"collecting 18650 cells from old laptop batteries" is literally "mixing and matching rando used batteries". well, cells anyway.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ben_bai on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @06:07PM (#16642878)
Except that the dude is measuring every individual cell (remaining capacity, resistance, ...) and then builds his power packs from the good cells. Just look at his channel, he has lots of videos about the process and multiple thousand cells to choose from.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by pmorici on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:40PM (#16639806)
The dude in the video is using what appears to be the same type of cell.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ropeadopepope on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:45PM (#16639871)
It's still mixing and matching. Different cells that have been used in different ways have different resistances. That causes each cell to charge and discharge at slightly different rates. Over time, you'll wind up overcharging one of those cells in relation to the others and burn your house down.

http://www.concordmonitor.com/electrical-bike-starts-fire-in...

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by dlhavema on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:00PM (#16640055)
most of these I have seen have the charge protection tabs on the top. are the laptop batteries different?

most of my experience is from buying fresh cells to use as caving headlamp batteries back in the day.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by dragontamer on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:06PM (#16640116)
> most of these I have seen have the charge protection tabs on the top.

That depends on the cell.

Some cells have charge protection. Others don't. The 18650 cell is standardized only in size-and-shape. The actual protection, chemicals, and other specifications are completely different from cell to cell.

Heck, some 18650s have 3.2V nominal voltage, while others have 3.7V.

IIRC, charge protection causes a voltage drop. So some applications prefer to use unprotected cells (with the overall device implementing charge protection elsewhere). For example, Laptops probably have ONE charge-protection circuit somewhere in their construction, rather than 6-charge protection circuits (each cell). This simple fix will cause 1/6th the voltage drop compared to 6x individual charge protection circuits.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by wlesieutre on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:42PM (#16640541)
The amount of current a battery can deliver also varies. Flashlight forums where people sometimes want the maximum power output will point you to a couple of specific 18650 parts and a similarly small number of sources where you can be reasonably sure they aren't counterfeits.

(Some) manufacturers provide specs for their batteries, but most of them are coming from no-name factories in China with no reputation at stake, so there's either nothing published or it's exaggerated.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by dragontamer on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:45PM (#16639877)
Li-Ion 18650 cells have different specifications.

Just because something is in the shape of the 18650 doesn't mean that the chemicals inside of them are the same. Tesla's 18650s allegedly don't have Cobalt in them for example. Panasonic / Tesla have been working on "special chemical sauce" to make the cells work better for car purposes.

Even WITHIN a company, there are different specifications. Samsung's ICR18650-22F has different specs than Samsung's ICR18650-32A.

Lithium is a potent chemical that is EXPLOSIVE when mishandled. Lithium Fires cannot be put out by a class A, class B, or class C fire extinguisher. Lithium Fires CANNOT be put out by suffocation (they are self-sustaining and do not require oxygen). And sure, the cells are "Lithium-Ion" and not "pure lithium" (Li-Ion is a bit safer), but the potency of the core element here demands caution.

Energy storage works because you're storing energy. And if that energy decides to "stop being stored", you basically got a major, explosive fire on your hands.

--------------

For hobby works (especially since I'm not in high-performance hobbies like Battlebots or RC Cars), I prefer the safety of NiMH cells. They're $2 each, sold by Duracell / Energizer / Panasonic / Eneloop.

The "failure" case of NiMH is that the battery vents a little bit of hydrogen gas (okay, also an explosive risk... but its not a lot of hydrogen). So basically, the cells destroy themselves if you abuse them, but otherwise vent relatively safely.

Furthermore, NiMH cells can be overcharged for days and remain fine. They're a lot more durable than Lithium Ion. In fact, a lot of NiMH chargers don't even have timers on them: a common technique with NiMH is to just keep them overcharging.

NiMH is heavier but otherwise nearly as energy dense as Lithium Ion.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by karlkatzke on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:55PM (#16641234)
Lithium Ion batteries do not contain any lithium metal. They are considered Class B fires. Do not use a Class D extinguisher on them. Water is an acceptable way to extinguish a Li-Ion battery. Most battery factories use water to extinguish Lithium Ion battery fires.

Lithium-METAL batteries on the other hand require a Class D extinguisher. They are not Lithium Ion batteries. They are single use devices and can NOT safely be recharged.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by jpm_sd on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:07PM (#16639376)
yep. incredibly dangerous. UL would not be impressed. [I have worked in lithium-ion battery design and testing for >10yr]
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by ropeadopepope on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:43PM (#16639831)
Do you mind if I pick your brain about something? How feasible is it to homebrew a BMS for a Lithium-Cobalt battery pack that's relatively certain not to burn your house down? I know not going with a BMS at all is a huge nono. Lots of people in the e-bike community have found out the hard way how difficult it is to manage a battery pack without one.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by jpm_sd on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @01:00PM (#16640067)
Cobalt cells always have an alarmingly non-zero chance of burning your house down, no matter how good your BMS is. Designing a BMS is a task for an experienced electrical & firmware engineer[ing team].
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by nikodunk on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:14PM (#16639490)
Caution, yes. But most things in hardware come with varying degrees of risk. If you make a chair it could collapse. Clothes? Toxins. Electric car? Explosive.

Is the upside of "living in the future and building what's missing" not worth it though if you're cautious with the risk?

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by btian on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:19PM (#16639542)
There is a risk/reward trade-off.

A lot of people build kit airplanes in their garage, but usually get the fuel system done by professionals.

It's not a everything or nothing game. You can still have fun and stay relatively safe.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by matte_black on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:18PM (#16639527)
It is absolutely not worth it. There’s nothing futuristic about this DIY project.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by amluto on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:18PM (#16639536)
Unknown toxins in clothing is one thing. Building a device attached to your electrical wiring that likely violates the electrical code and puts firefighters as risk is something else entirely.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by vvanders on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:47PM (#16639890)
Not just firefighters but linemen as well.

If those things don't disconnect when the power goes out and have a physical lockout for switch over to battery power they can easily kill someone working on the line.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by bluGill on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:31PM (#16641035)
Fortunately for linemen this risk isn't quite as high as it seems. If you are feeding power back power to the grid when it should be off your neighbors are likely to use enough power as to blow your local circuit breakers.

Do not use the above as an excuse to not have proper backfeed prevention on your system. It is a last resort that might save a life, but there is always the possibility that the isolated section is small enough that you can supply your neighbors without blowing any breakers.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by vvanders on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @03:27PM (#16641459)
That's assuming that your mains breaker is actually functioning, usually not too many of them get tested at 100-300A since the per-circuit ones trip first.

Last time I read up on backfeeding one of the common refrains was that flipping the main breaker on many homes still left one leg hot back to the transformer. Totally out of spec but common enough to be called out. Hence why a transfer switch is legally required if you're going to run your house from a generator/etc.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by bluGill on Thursday March 22, 2018 @11:35AM (#16649500)
It isn't just the mains breaker. It is all the other breakers on your system. Your generators/inverter probably has a breaker someplace as well.

I don't know how common the one hot leg thing is. I know that can buy a lockout device which is just a metal device allowing either my main breaker or one other breaker to be on: thus turning my entire panel into a lockout. That implies the one hot leg thing isn't common but I honestly don't know.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by Dylan16807 on Thursday March 22, 2018 @12:16AM (#16645678)
> likely violates the electrical code

I don't think that's likely at all.

This isn't plugging a generator into your house when the power's out. This is a system that's connected 24/7. That's difficult to do, requiring careful synchronization or isolation. Getting it wrong is probably harder than getting it right.

Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by PaulHoule on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:47PM (#16639891)
If Tesla assumes liability for a PowerWall disaster than the $3500 price is a bargain.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by 2474 on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:26PM (#16639623)
Yes, obviously do not try this unless you have tremendous electrical engineering knowledge. However, I do give kudos in finding a DIY solution to reuse what would likely just become waste in some landfill.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:54PM (#16641223)
I would hope most of the lithium in old 18650s is recycled? But maybe that's me being overly optimistic.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by simple00 on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:45PM (#16639868)
Don't even think about building something like that yourself in your home. If one of the cells gets damaged it can set of a chain reaction which will burn down everything around it. A fire like this is quite hard to extinguish, similar to the teslas that burn down sometimes ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYKTTCNUV3o ). Using lithium iron phosphate batteries might be a safer alternative.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by JshWright on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @06:13PM (#16642921)
As a firefighter, this is absolutely terrifying. We are not expecting this sort of hazard in a "routine" house fire.
Re:Using old laptop batteries to build homemade powerwalls by aaroninsf on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @12:07PM (#16639378)
My thought exactly.

Paging /r/osha