Maybe some people don’t want to live in dense urban areas, maybe they don’t want to ride on a rail, maybe they want privacy. But looking out the window, I can say American society has soundly rejected the rail as the ultimate solution.
Short of understanding your perspective as a longing personal desire for trains, your conclusion is so far removed from reality that it’s nonsense.
You can't say people reject something they don't even know is a possibility.
There would be considerable US pushback against such a system, sadly.
“Soundly”? If you mean in the way a child “soundly” rejects vegetables, maybe. But, the American public has never had this conversation. Capitalism and it’s ensuing cultural affects had it for them.
Every sci-fi movie of the last 50 years has solved that problem: you don't use trains; you put the cars on the rails (by grouping them together into roller-coaster-looking setups.)
> maybe they don’t want to ride on a rail
Same here: cars on rails can, in most conceptions, signal to the rail system to switch them onto an offramp that dumps them back onto a road.
Basically, here, "rails" are serving as safer replacements for highways. Every road that isn't a highway would still be a road. You're just enabling people to, effectively, "have their car take the train", rather than having to leave their car at the train's parking lot.
I guess the obvious problem is that it would require simultaneously modding both private vehicles and public infrastructure at impossible scale.
It seems like such an obvious design end but implementation would require communism :/.
It seems like a much better plan is to separate drivers from other people more rigorously, and maybe mandate people drive the last-mile themselves (with AI help, obviously).
Similarly for long haul trucking applications - could the far left lane/carpool lane be safely dedicated to autonomous trucks during the hours of midnight-3AM with some bright blinking signs paid for by the autonomous trucking industry trade group?
There will still be the last-mile problem. Even if the "rail" is just cheap paint, you'll almost definitely never have 100% of roads painted, and paint wears over time or gets buried under snow etc.
Eventually we're looking for ways to add "more 9s" to the reliability and safety. A non-rail rail could add a bunch of 9s to well-trafficked routes.
As someone who lived in West LA for years and saw the new line come in, I'll stop you right there. Cities like LA, Mexico-City, San Jose, etc. are not well designed and trying to re-invent them is going to take one hell of an earthquake.
I used to ride a recumbent to UCLA now and then because I had a death wish, and it shocked me that it took 25 minutes and yet people spent 60 minutes in traffic in their cars every day just to get across the 405.
You're right, though, those cities are mostly lost causes, more for the attitudes present in them than the infrastructure. Doesn't mean we can't try to make any new ones better though.
Riding a recumbent to UCLA from 16th is hardcore. Everyone I knew that rode in west LA got hit at least once, if not more.
My brother lived off Geary for a few years and went to a few public meetings on the proposed subway line they want to put under it. He was interested in the idea, as the N-Judah is a methadone clinic (last he was there a few years ago, caveats apply). He never saw such NIMYism and such tight resistance by the property owners on Geary to any improvements whatsoever.
You don't just ease regulations or really do anything 'big' in any city. Palms must be greased, and if you do not it is a horrific process that takes at least a decade.
I'm not saying that you are wrong about the free market. However, my brother thought that the most fantastic thing about the new Star Trek movies (esp. the new Wrath of Khan) was not the warp-drive, nor the aliens, but the very tall building in SF. Even in 400 years, there is no way the planning boards would allow such things.
If there is anything to be nostalgic about the past over, its how civil engineering projects of such scale were a lot more feasible when the complexity of doing them was so much lower.
I invite anyone who buys into this sweeping generalization to walk a half mile in Las Vegas, NV; Tempe, AZ; Houston, TX; New Orleans, LA; or Tampa, FL in July or August.
Walking half a mile in 35 C (95 F) isn't an actual problem unless you have a medical condition or you are morbidly obese. For those very rare 40+ C (105+ F) days, throw an official midday siesta, or just shut everything down like for snow days.
Again with the hand waving as if this was a solved problem. Trust me - if you actually try to walk half a mile on a 90+ degree, high humidity day you will regret it. The issue isn't just infirmity - i.e. those prone to heat stroke or overweight, but one of comfort. If you actually try tooling around in Houston (for example) you'll end up soaked in sweat. It'll be worse if you're dressed for the office in long sleeves and slacks.
That's when you'll discover that more than the public need to adapt to public transportation uber alles. Can I use a shopping trolley for groceries? Sure. Can I cycle to work? No doubt. But what if your employer doesn't have showers available? Mine doesn't. I can't show up drenched in sweat looking like a wet rat and stinking all day of sweat. And that's exactly what'll happen if I ride the few miles I have to work. Even if I take a change of clothes to work I still have no place to shower and neither does anyone else unless they are health club members. There are many externalities you're just hand waving away. As someone who lives in this climate I assure you I'd love to see light rail everywhere but it just won't replace the last mile for people without drastic societal changes.
There's also the fact that bus and rail frequency needs to dramatically increase to entice riders and also accommodate them when they do come. Will people choose a 45 minute bus ride over a 15 minute drive? Particularly when on average you'll spend 7.5-10 minutes baking in the sun or lightly shaded by an un-airconditioned bus stop? Not unless forced to, no.
I mean, I'd love to see you medevac a gravely wounded person from the middle of Arctic tundra to a hospital 120 miles away on your feet.. except I wouldn't, because we have helicopters for a reason. We don't assume you should have to use a helicopter to get groceries though.
Self driving cars can't come quickly enough.
Cycling is great, I hope to get along in life without a car, but cars are still great to have as an option.
Unfortunately there are features of most US cities (lack of public interest, obesity, disability, low density, long commutes, weather) that block our adoption from approaching yours.
We should require that every traffic participant gets a sensor, and connect all in a (local) network, instead of only relying on machine learning and its vulnerability to the unpredictable situations where accidents occur. Pure autonomous self driving won’t be the final answer here.
Please correct me if I’m not up to date here, but to my last knowledge self driving car machine learning lacks the most important data, that of dangerous situations. I’m surprised that Uber considered it ready for roll out.
The reason that fatalities are 10x higher in Asia is that people drive (and walk!) like lunatics and vehicle fatalities are just shrugged off.
Just be more orderly is basically what I am saying. Also eat more sauerkraut - it's healthy!
Having driven about 2000KM on the Autobahn as a tourist the lane etiquette on the Autobahn is the best I’ve ever seen, and I’ve driven through the U.S. (both East and West coast) and much of Europe. It’s no surprise to me that the Germans can drive on de-restricted roads and have the one of the lowest number of deaths (HIGHWAYS ONLY) in the world.
Every car has plenty of communication and localization systems today. Nearly every pedestrian carries an electronic device with potential for exact localization. It makes no sense to not use that data, and solely rely on still-not-perfect computer vision. The optimal system will necessarily be a combination of both.
As for standardisation, maybe realizing what an enormous number of fatal and many more forever life-altering accidents we currently consider normal will finally get people off their backsides. I wish somebody would start a media project revealing how insane the current situation is..
The beauty of cars vs rails is that cars can go more than just a set in stone angle or path defined by a rail. Cars can go in and out of parking lots and dirt roads. Rails would be more automated, yes, but not as versatile.
And as far as dirt roads go, if the self driving cars can't make it through well defined, paved roads what are the odds they are going to accurately navigate some dirt road?
Autonomous cars aren't a viable tech until the roads are reengineered with rails built in. It's just way too big of a technical problem to solve with computers alone.
Right now the death rate of autonomous cars is far higher than human drivers and it is never going to catch up given that it hasn't advanced technologically recently.
If our rail network was as potholed and badly maintained as our roads, people would die in train accidents every day.
Rails are great for intensive, carefully manicured routes. They are not a substitute for roads.
Then there are the cases of engineers who are distracted and what not, but I'd imagine we're talking autonomous so that (hopefully) wouldn't be an issue.
According to the US Department of Transportation, there are about 5,800 train-car crashes each year in the United States, most of which occur at railroad crossings. These accidents cause 600 deaths and injure about 2,300.
Ridesharing algorithms will 100% solve the problem of underutilised mass transit. Self driving isnt necessary.
Imagine shuttles that hold 10 people using uber pool algorithms and funded by the city.
People will be able to make their request and a nearby shuttle will pick all the people up in that area. The shuttles could do ad hoc transfers with other shuttles so people wouldnt even have to be going to the same area.
The algorithm would minimize the average ride time for everyone.
The #1 issue with mass transit is lack of convenience. Rideshare algorithms will eliminate that lack of convenience.
How will that help? The reason that the trains in London and Singapore don't kill people is not that they are on rails, it's because they're underground.
You need to put the trains below ground, or well above!
But there are a couple of really big, really massive problems. We have trillions in existing infrastructure and trillions more in existing property that's been developed over the course of decades. A lot of that development has come with unintended consequences. Just look at Houston after Hurricane Harvey and how their development and zoning practices took the insane rains Harvey deposited and magnified their negative consequences.[0] Decades of short-sighted decision-making took a hurricane and made it worse. Some changes will likely be made, but they won't solve nor likely keep up with a problem that's only going to get worse. That'll happen because the alternative, demolishing huge portions of the sprawling concrete city, isn't economically viable. The city can't be moved.
It's baggage. And there's so much more. Tens of trillions of dollars worth. Then there are existing roads, bridges, and other infrastructure connecting all of it. Designed for cars, and much of it legacy infrastructure that doesn't take into account modern infrastructure design principles. Add cities and towns, some of which are (charitably) in less-than-optimal positions. Towns, strip malls, and other structures that wouldn't exist if it weren't for suburban sprawl. Baggage. And then there's the people. People with ideas on what their lives ought to be like and where they want to live. There's a town, Centralia, Pennsylvania, that is literally on top of a massive underground fire that's been burning for over half a century. There was a massive relocation effort with federal and state funds. The town has no services, its zip code was discontinued in 2002, and it's still burning with all of the potential health risks that involves. There are still five residents there today, who have fought every attempt to relocate them. They will continue to live there until they die, at which point their homes will finally be taken and demolished through eminent domain.[1] If we can't bulldoze a town like that, we sure as hell can't take a bulldozer to normal ones.
Baggage. What it means is that we can't simply replace everything. It can only be done piecemeal, which means new infrastructure must take into account the need to accommodate everything that was developed under the old. High speed rail can be built out in the United States, and I genuinely hope that it is. But it literally can't replace the car in its entirety.
Self driving car research is--compared to the cost of major infrastructure replacement, let alone an alternative that simply isn't feasible--practically a rounding error. It doesn't hurt us, because the option was never a binary choice: self-driving cars OR rail. Self-driving cars give us the ability to deal within existing legacy constraints as they're slowly adapted, modified, and/or replaced. They also offer some long-term possibilities that will allow us to make radical changes in urban design. And yes, those changes are ones can accommodate rail, pedestrian-friendly city design, and other options that can drastically improve quality of life.
0. https://www.npr.org/2017/11/09/563016223/exploring-why-hurri...
1. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/pa-residents-living-above-min...
Cities only spread out over the past century. You start building rail again and it will get drawn back in. But the State has to fund that mode of transportation first.
We should just really build rails. Self driving cars are dumping billions of dollars onto a problem better solved by rails. Several cities already have self driving trains including London, Singapore and Kuala Lumpar, and they transport millions of people every day without incident:
http://penguindreams.org/blog/self-driving-cars-will-not-sol...
Self driving car research is asinine. It won't even being to solve the transport problem in America and it's round-peg/square-hole tech. It has the cool factor but there are existing tech that are insanely more useful for a fraction of the cost. American hate public transportation (thanks GM) that we'll never see real/good transport implemented in America.