I guess we'll find out how competent they are at this, but I think they did a surprisingly good job with the previous Tesla investigation: https://dms.ntsb.gov/pubdms/search/hitlist.cfm?docketID=5998...
On the other hand, I'd wonder if increasing NTSB scope this much would drastically decrease the average quality of NTSB's work. Scaling ain't easy.
Bonus: Job creation to replace the jobs lost to automation
I don't think self-driving cars and their sensor data, even if they rely on the operator to explain what the car “remembers”, fundamentally shift the landscape.
For instance, take a look at:
https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Pages/HW...
"The Tesla was equipped with multiple electronic systems capable of recording and transmitting vehicle performance data. NTSB investigators will continue to collect and analyze these data, and use it along with other information collected during the investigation in evaluating the crash events."
I mean, how is this different then all of the other accidents that occur every day? Yes a self-driving car is involved, but do people really think autonomous cars aren't going to be involved in fatal accidents?
Of course they are...but I've always thought that autonomous vehicles only have to be like 10% safer for them to make tons of sense to replace human drivers.
We want to know what happened, how it happened, how we could have prevented it, how likely it is to happen again, what assumptions or overlooked details lie at the heart of this.
The required level of expertise, effort and precision here are higher than in a regular traffic accident. Moreover, the required skill-set, knowledge base, and willingness to work in a new area here make this an exceptional case.
Finally, the outcome of this will be much more than liability in a single case. This could set the precedent for an entire field of industry. This could be the moment we find out self-driving cars are nearly a pipe-dream, or it could be the moment we kill self-driving cars at the cost of millions of preventable traffic accidents. This investigation just might determine a lot, again, that makes it exceptional.
Agree, Kumail Nanjiani (comedian) has a great rant on twitter about exactly this, ethical implications of tech-
> As a cast member on a show about tech, our job entails visiting tech companies/conferences etc. We meet ppl eager to show off new tech. Often we'll see tech that is scary. I don't mean weapons etc. I mean altering video, tech that violates privacy, stuff w obv ethical issues. And we'll bring up our concerns to them. We are realizing that ZERO consideration seems to be given to the ethical implications of tech. They don't even have a pat rehearsed answer. They are shocked at being asked. Which means nobody is asking those questions. "We're not making it for that reason but the way ppl choose to use it isn't our fault. Safeguard will develop." But tech is moving so fast. That there is no way humanity or laws can keep up. We don't even know how to deal with open death threats online. Only "Can we do this?" Never "should we do this? We've seen that same blasé attitude in how Twitter or Facebook deal w abuse/fake news. Tech has the capacity to destroy us. We see the negative effect of social media. & no ethical considerations are going into dev of tech.You can't put this stuff back in the box. Once it's out there, it's out there. And there are no guardians. It's terrifying. The end. https://twitter.com/kumailn/status/925828976882282496?lang=e...
It is scary, big tech orgs have no incentive or motivation to even consider ethical implications, whats worse is the American consumer has shown repeatedly that you're OK to do really shady stuff and as long as it means a lower price product/service for the consumer. We're in a kind of dark age of tech regulation and he's right it is terrifying.
Though that would of course depend on how insurance even looks for SDCs. Maybe big companies like Uber will self-insure.
The latter needs to be addressed by government. The former can be addressed by concerned parties using their political connections to get existing law aggressively enforced.
We need law enforcement to be able to keep pace with advances in technology and let's face it, they're not going to have the money to employ data analysts with the required skills. Do we need a national body for this? Is there any hope of a Republican government spending the required money to do so? (no)