Citation please. If you're talking about the Jane Akre/Steve Wilson lawsuit, that's factually inaccurate.
Anyway, there's more than just "bulls vs bears" going on here.
In any case, Elon Musk's 20,000 Model 3 manufactured per month target for late 2017 is incredibly late (See: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/881757617416056832). A lot of Tesla bulls don't seem to care however and continue to throw money at the company.
Tesla isn't even at 2000 cars a month, and we're well into 2018. A lot of people are interested in "why" this is happening. Yes, short-sellers are interested, but I'm sure normal investors are wondering why Musk isn't even hitting 10% of his target months later.
The article suggests that the QA group is finding flaws in the manufacturing process. So... yeah. That makes sense for why the Model 3 is late with very, very low production numbers. There's been a lot of speculation in different groups for the failure, but ultimately, the core is that Tesla is not making enough Model 3.
This seems like a pretty big/dangerous jump to make with little-to-no evidence.
>> In any case, Elon Musk's 20,000 Model 3 manufactured per month target for late 2017 is incredibly late (See: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/881757617416056832). A lot of Tesla bulls don't seem to care however and continue to throw money at the company.
I really hate that Musk publicly underestimates the amount of work and deadlines in this process. It's especially annoying for me because I've worked for people who publicly underestimate and it put way more ridiculous work on me and my coworkers.
That said, I also hate this "fraud-boy" FUD. I think Tesla could eventually pull this off. The ramp will obviously be slower than what Musk expects. I, like many bears, take what Elon says with a grain of salt. But cars are rolling off the production line. At this point, the Model 3 is now the best-selling EV in the US. (https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/). Tesla has proven itself with the Model S. People in general love the cars. Tesla will get there, and I think that's why bulls are holding.
Sorry for the lack of evidence.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2016/05/19/united-...
https://www.mercurynews.com/2017/02/09/tesla-worker-long-hou...
But its no small secret that pro-union forces are also in this whole mess. I've got no skin in the game, but its clear that the UAW union wants to unionize Tesla's workers.
The UAW rallying pro-union forces of the Tesla workforce is just... how politics works in the USA. Its going to happen.
I'm overall a Tesla Bear (but I have no real money on this bet, its just my unfathomed opinion). But when I read Tesla news stories, they're either complaints about the workforce (which I generally judge to be from pro-Union forces), or complaints about Tesla's financials (which I judge to be from Financial bears).
That's all I'm saying: keep an eye out for the union pieces. They may or may not be "correct", but there's certainly an agenda that is being pushed here.
https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/
Current rate of 700 cars/week * ~4 weeks/month = ~2800 cars/month.
I'm just wondering how that's a good thing, it sure doesn't feel like it to me. It honestly sounds like me explaining to my family how I'm pulling my shit together. Sure, I haven't quit drinking or found a real career yet, but I went to the grocery store last week, and that's pretty good, right?
I'm exaggerating, but citing numbers that are perhaps factual but not much better than the hyperbole doesn't a convincing argument make.
Link please?
It is a bit hard to google about because a lot of the people who choose to write about it are partisan, but you can get a feel for the mess in the Snopes article†.
As with lots of law, part of it turns on technical definitions. The Appeals Court (not Supreme) found that the FCC policy against falsification did not meet the legal definition of "law, rule, or regulation" in a particular section of relevant law. Remember, three of those four quoted words probably don't mean what you think they do unless you are a legal scholar. It's like having a variable in a program named "loop_count". Maybe it is a count of the looping, maybe not, unless you read all the referencing code.
The wikipedia article‡ is currently ok too, but who knows by the time you read it.
I think OP is referring to "NEW YORK TIMES CO. v. SULLIVAN" where the Supreme Court placed the bar of something being libel as the accused having 'actual malice' which is in itself is somewhat slipperly defined as having knowledge that they were lying, or recklessly not investigating what they were publishing.
I certainly don't think that qualifies as a decision that "the news media can lie". In fact, to the extent you can prove the news media was lying in a report about a public figure (that is, the news media published something they knew to be false), that's explicitly covered. That's the opposite of what OP claimed.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/fox-skews/
http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/10/...
Of course, you could say the converse thing about standard investments, but in the former case you risk otherwise viable ventures being sunk by profit-seeking bad faith actors. In the latter case, maybe some naive and irresponsible investors will lose their money. The latter seems much more acceptable to me than the former.
The issue here is spreading sentiment in bad faith. If someone is doing it, they are affecting the market and enterprises in it, in a bad way. The good guys make less (and go out of business sometimes), and the bad guys make more money and get more attention, stealing it from the ones who truly deserve it.
The downside is not that some naive investors lose money. The downside is that a better project will not get the money it really needs, and instead that money will go to a worse project with better false marketing - thus slowing down the overall progress.
Whether this happens while going long or short positions - doesn't make much difference.
a) I'm not convinced that it's as difficult/expensive to spread FUD as it is to spread whatever the opposite of FUD is.
b) I'm not convinced that different classes of investors respond in the same ways to FUD and whatever the opposite of FUD is.
c) I'm not convinced that different classes of investors have the same access to tools that allow them to "buy long" and "sell short". This may be on the way to changing, but currently even e.g. Robinhood does not support short selling.
I say "not convinced" because I honestly don't think I have the answer to this, but if the answers to the above questions go a certain way that I think is fairly plausible, it seems that the net effects would include a disproportionate burden on disruptive/innovative ventures that are especially vulnerable to FUD, and an increase in wealth inequality as capital flows to more sophisticated investors. Neither of those things are great.
Tesla wants people to believe in them in order to continue selling cars to customers (who probably wouldn't buy if they thought the company was going bankrupt) and stock/bonds already issued to investors.
Short sellers want to give people doubt to cause a decrease in stock price in order to benefit from their short position.
Both parties are probably acting in good faith - Tesla wants people to see how good they are and short sellers want people to see how risky they are. But as a result the news is crowded and it's generally hard to know the truth.
Just remember, in the US the Supreme Court has ruled that it's legal for news publications to lie to their readers/viewers.