News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by jccooper on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:47PM (#16613156)
Because he believed that population would be limited only by resources, and that fertility rate was nearly invariant. These have both proved to be wrong. The popular imagination of the Mathusian prediction of inevitable mass starvation (which is not really that mis-characterized) was also wrong. So classifying him as wrong seems fair.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by ScottBurson on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:30PM (#16613431)
And yet, the specter of a possible Malthusian catastrophe may have helped motivate us to prevent it. I don't really call that being wrong.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by bryanlarsen on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:40PM (#16614906)
The specter of a Malthusian catastrophe was what motivated Adolf Hitler.

The factors that ended up defusing the Malthusian catastrophe were not influenced by Malthus at all. We did not go about educating women because of Malthus.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by amvalo on Sunday March 18, 2018 @09:37PM (#16615621)
Good Godwin.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by ionised on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:18AM (#16617572)
Simply mentioning Hitler or the Nazis is not a reason to invoke Godwin's law.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by amvalo on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:09PM (#16622004)
Godwin's law simply states that Nazis will eventually be mentioned (with probability approaching 1).

Also, he's completely wrong. Hitler's reasoning was not to avoid a malthusian catastrophe. Pretty surprised people here bought that.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by philwelch on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:54PM (#16624591)
The goal of the Nazis was to conquer eastern Europe, remove most of the existing population, and resettle it with German colonists. The rationale was to feed and support a growing population, which is an idea at least reminiscent of Malthus.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by amvalo on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @04:53AM (#16636467)
The rationale was that their own ethnic group deserved to prosper at the expense of others. The idea that germany might be in danger of running out of food via population growth was not present. If by "reminiscent" you mean "has something to do with population" then sure, it's reminiscent.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by Finnucane on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:47PM (#16613534)
Population remains limited by resources. How could it not be? We've been adept over the years at finding new resources or extending old ones (the expansion of ranching and farming in the Americas in the 19th century, which greatly increased the global food supply, or the invention of artificial fertilizer, for instance), but it is a bit of hubris to say that this is a solved problem for all time.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by Animats on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:18AM (#16616309)
Population remains limited by resources.

No, it's not, and that's what's so surprising. As nations become wealthier, the birth rate goes down, not up. And it goes down by a lot; more than 50%. All the way down below replacement rate.

The US passed "peak baby" in 2007. Outside of Africa, all the major world regions are past "peak baby".[1] Population seems likely to level off around 2050.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by thaumasiotes on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:23AM (#16616320)
> it goes down by a lot; more than 50%. All the way down below replacement rate.

Some quick systems-level analysis shows that this state of affairs cannot possibly be stable. Societies reproducing at below replacement rate are quickly replaced by societies reproducing above replacement rate. What will happen then?

Counting on societies to hold their birth rate down that far is fundamentally at odds with the theory of evolution. It's not a good basis for predictions of the future.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by dragonwriter on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:45AM (#16616380)
> Societies reproducing at below replacement rate are quickly replaced by societies reproducing above replacement rate.

“Societies” are about memes, not genes, and humans are powerful imitators of things that visibly are associated with success.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by thaumasiotes on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:52AM (#16616399)
You could model a "society" after early modern France, following these stylized facts:

- "Society" is divided into two cultural subgroups, Catholic and Protestant.

- Protestants reproduce below the replacement rate.

- Catholics reproduce well above the replacement rate.

- Protestants nevertheless persist in the population, because the children of Catholics are relabeled Protestant at very high rates.

However, for this to work, note that the reproduction rate of all France, including the Catholics and the Protestants, must be above replacement.

(I will note that I have no opinion on whether, in the real France, Protestants actually reproduced below replacement or just below the level of Catholics. The usual question you see accompanying these facts is "how could there be a significant number of Protestants in France?", not "how could there be people in France at all?")

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by philwelch on Monday March 19, 2018 @08:02PM (#16624648)
It's basically a race: will infertile memes infect fertile cultures before fertile cultures outbreed infertile cultures?

It's too early to call a winner. If you want to see some early hints, you might want to focus on populations that have very high fertility but are otherwise well-integrated into the prosperous, developed cultures that are experiencing low fertility overall. Mormons, for instance.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by burfog on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:03AM (#16616426)
Fine, but the future still belongs to those who show up. Evolution need not be about DNA. Memes (such as religion) will do the job just fine. Those who think "success" involves low reproduction are taking the evolutionary off-ramp to extinction. Those who do otherwise are selected for. They have the correct memes, or genes, or whatever -- the mechanism doesn't matter.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by jxramos on Monday March 19, 2018 @02:25AM (#16616478)
> "the mechanism doesn't matter"

Makes me think about this old article in ForeignPolicy I read. I could interpret his provocative statements about the success of patriarchy as a sort of "correct meme" to borrow your terminology. Interesting thought. http://foreignpolicy.com/2009/10/20/the-return-of-patriarchy...

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by Angostura on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:12AM (#16617540)
Except of course that the meme that is "currently showing up" is that lower human population is not a bad thing".
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by Animats on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:34AM (#16616354)
Societies reproducing at below replacement rate are quickly replaced by societies reproducing above replacement rate. What will happen then?

By then, the robots will be ready to take over.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by thousandautumns on Monday March 19, 2018 @08:22AM (#16617810)
> Societies reproducing at below replacement rate are quickly replaced by societies reproducing above replacement rate.

Yes, and it is already something that is setting of early warning signals around the world. Countries like Japan and Sweden are looking at major catastrophes in the coming decades if they can't get their populations to increase their birthrates. Its a large part of why Sweden has some of the best benefits for new parents on the planet.

Additionally, some see the collapse of stores like Toys R Us as the first wave of economic effects resulting from the declining birth rate in the US (note that Toys R Us also owns Babies R Us). Obviously, there are lots of factors at play, and retail in general is doomed, but a greatly reduced market for babies and children's products is indicative of a potentially greatly reduced market of everything else in the coming decades.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by DerekL on Monday March 19, 2018 @11:23PM (#16625784)
> Additionally, some see the collapse of stores like Toys R Us as the first wave of economic effects resulting from the declining birth rate in the US (note that Toys R Us also owns Babies R Us).

Toys R Us's collapse was mostly caused by a leveraged buyout in 2005.

http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-toys-r-us-leveraged-bu...

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by wootwootwoot on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:45AM (#16616379)
As countries develop both their birth rates and death rates decrease, but below replacement rate is a pretty strong statement. Population growth like this is modeled in the Demographic Transition Model and consists of 5 stages. Most developed nations fall in the fourth stage, with stable birth and death rates. The 5th stage is often debated, but a pretty good example would be Japan - a country with an aging population and low birth rates (learned about this in school several years ago though, not too sure how up to date)
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by blattimwind on Monday March 19, 2018 @03:29AM (#16616648)
In Germany there is not a single(!) district with above-replacement rate. Only certain demographics (migration background) have (much) higher rates.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by dsacco on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:38AM (#16616362)
> Counting on societies to hold their birth rate down that far is fundamentally at odds with the theory of evolution.

Why?

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by thaumasiotes on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:40AM (#16616368)
Because anything reproducing at below replacement rate goes extinct. If you e.g. look around at any given point, and take a sample -- by any method -- of living things that come to your attention, none of those things will have gone extinct.

It's the same reason there are no societies which abstain entirely from giving birth. There have been a few, over the course of history, but they disappear for the incredibly obvious reason. At a steady state, such societies don't exist because they can't exist.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by Angostura on Monday March 19, 2018 @07:15AM (#16617561)
It sounds to me as if you are simply taking the Malthusian fallacy and reversing it to make another fallacy. Certainly, a population that continues indefinitely below replacement rate will go extinct. That's not terribly likely though.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by thaumasiotes on Monday March 19, 2018 @12:40PM (#16619848)
What did I write that you're responding to? It looks like you're agreeing with everything I've said.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by rz2k on Sunday March 18, 2018 @03:23PM (#16613735)
It is a ceiling, but there are so many signals prior to hitting that ceiling that the simplification of the Malthusian growth model does not seem to have any utility.

Take for example US population density west of the Mississippi. No one needs to explicitly die of thirst. If water is the limiting factor, the cost of water is invisibly incorporated into nearly every cost people experience. If there were limitless water, the influence of other constraints would simply rearrange.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by danbruc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @04:00PM (#16613957)
After reading the comments here it probably boils down on what you focus. If you see the entire work pointing out the unsustainability of exponential population growth that will come to an halt either by positive or preventive checks, then you will probably not call him wrong. If you focus on his view that people will probably not be able to get the fertility rate down to sustainable levels and that a Malthusian catastrophe is therefore probably inevitable, then you will most likely call him wrong. But as I said before, I didn't read much of his work and therefore I might have a misconception about what points he actually stressed the most.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by mikeash on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:54PM (#16613579)
Population is not only limited by resources. There are many places where humans reproduce at a rate well below what resources can support.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by njarboe on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:23AM (#16616321)
Exponential growth must always come to an end, but if your biggest resource is people than more people can overcome other resource limitations by invention and culture.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by danbruc on Sunday March 18, 2018 @01:55PM (#16613211)
Well, he got wrong how the fertility rate would evolve, but that does not invalidate the model he developed. And he would probably have been pretty spot on with his predictions if the fertility rate had not drastically decreased.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by igravious on Monday March 19, 2018 @01:54AM (#16616400)
> And he would probably have been pretty spot on with his predictions if the fertility rate had not drastically decreased.

If I went around saying, "well, I would have been right if that one part of my theory hadn't become invalidated by events on the ground" people would think me impossible to reason with.

Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by rsynnott on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:43AM (#16618261)
In fairness, it would have been very hard for him to predict the decrease in fertility; it relies on both technological (birth control) and social (womens’ rights, pensions systems, and various others) innovations that would not have been reasonably predictable at the time.
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused by jobigoud on Monday March 19, 2018 @05:14AM (#16617046)
Not if your theory became a meme that influenced people's behavior.

Consider if we were to somehow diffuse the climate change bomb thanks to policies put in place based on current models. Our collective behavior would influence the outcome, but it doesn't invalidate the predictions.