Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused
by ScottBurson on Sunday March 18, 2018 @02:30PM
(#16613431)
And yet, the specter of a possible Malthusian catastrophe may have helped motivate us to prevent it. I don't really call that being wrong.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Population Bomb Has Been Defused
by bryanlarsen on Sunday March 18, 2018 @06:40PM
(#16614906)
The specter of a Malthusian catastrophe was what motivated Adolf Hitler.
The factors that ended up defusing the Malthusian catastrophe were not influenced by Malthus at all. We did not go about educating women because of Malthus.
Good Godwin.
Simply mentioning Hitler or the Nazis is not a reason to invoke Godwin's law.
Godwin's law simply states that Nazis will eventually be mentioned (with probability approaching 1).
Also, he's completely wrong. Hitler's reasoning was not to avoid a malthusian catastrophe. Pretty surprised people here bought that.
The goal of the Nazis was to conquer eastern Europe, remove most of the existing population, and resettle it with German colonists. The rationale was to feed and support a growing population, which is an idea at least reminiscent of Malthus.
The rationale was that their own ethnic group deserved to prosper at the expense of others. The idea that germany might be in danger of running out of food via population growth was not present. If by "reminiscent" you mean "has something to do with population" then sure, it's reminiscent.