News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by legostormtroopr on Thursday March 15, 2018 @07:37AM (#16591898)
GitHub has had no problems implementing censorship on their platform if it’s using their own values (see: WebM for Retards), so why should we care if they are now forced to censor using an external parties values?

I was concerned when GitHub started censoring repositories that didn’t meet their code of conduct, but was told it was for the greater good. Now the issue is coming back to bite them it seems.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by matthewmacleod on Thursday March 15, 2018 @07:53AM (#16591986)
Every company, every person is entitled to decide what content they are willing to support. You are free to disagree with decisions that company makes, and take your business elsewhere. That is obviously, qualitatively different from an argument about proposed legislation being bad, that it's hard to see how one could draw a comparison between them in good faith.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:56AM (#16593359)
> Every company, every person is entitled to decide what content they are willing to support. You are free to disagree with decisions that company makes, and take your business elsewhere.

Including Christian bakers? I don't really disagree with your free market approach, but that doesn't seem to be the way things stand.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by ekianjo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @07:48AM (#16591949)
Your comment is misguided. When private actors behave badly, you can opt out and go for competiting services. When the state mandates something your options run out. It is a pure attack on Freedom.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by guitarbill on Thursday March 15, 2018 @12:37PM (#16594324)
> When private actors behave badly, you can opt out and go for competiting services.

Except when they're a quasi-monopoly, then people find it more difficult to opt out. Hence anti-trust laws, and more recently, GDPR.

> It is a pure attack on Freedom.

By definition, all laws are exactly that. The question is never "does this law restrict my freedom?" but always "on balance, am I happy with the way this law restricts my/others freedom, and what might be the (un)intended consequences?".

So while it's a dumb proposal, it's hardly more stifling to creativity than 70+ years of draconian copyright protection.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by lerpa on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:55PM (#16595051)
You're still free to open a competing service, and can leverage the fact that you are better than the other guys as free advertisement basically.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by dingo_bat on Thursday March 15, 2018 @07:54AM (#16591998)
When private actors that have a monopoly behave badly you can go to another but you will have a severely degraded experience. For example reddit, YouTube, Facebook, etc. There is no alternative if they block you, you just have to accept that you're no longer allowed to participate in a certain activity.

GitHub is also quite like this.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by yock on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:02AM (#16592424)
Alternatives exist, what you're complaining about is that they're not popular. You aren't entitled to viable alternatives. If a private business acts in a way contrary to your beliefs, your only option is to stop using them. Having an alternative private business to choose is nice, but never guaranteed.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by dingo_bat on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:23AM (#16592577)
Can you tell me what's the alternative for Youtube? Or github? The alternative should be a real alternative, not a useless replica. For example, I should be able to watch latest movie trailers, music videos, tech reviews, etc. on the youtube alternative. And I should be able to report issues to Microsoft's VS code project.

This is not just about popularity. On the internet, winner takes all. The monopoly is extreme in every type of website/service. If you can't use Youtube, you effectively cannot watch videos on the web. If you are banned by github, you cannot participate in the global open source community.

There are 2 solutions:

1. Break the monopolies.

2. Force them to respect my rights, similar to the government.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by ekianjo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:04AM (#16592920)
Git is a decentralized version system there is absolutely no reason to have to use Github to work on any open source project.

Youtube is no monopoly. You have hundreds of sites offering video streaming services and you can broadcast your own as well using other services not affiliated to youtube. The fact that almost everyone uses Youtube does not make it a monopoly.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by yock on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:52PM (#16601948)
> Break the monopolies

Can you explain what makes Youtube and Github monopolies when both have competitors in the market?

> Force them to respect my rights, similar to the government.

What rights do you think you have that they are violating?

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by xg15 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:29AM (#16593677)
> When private actors behave badly, you can opt out and go for competiting services.

> You aren't entitled to viable alternatives.

????

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by adventured on Thursday March 15, 2018 @02:55PM (#16595558)
There's an extraordinary difference between you being entitled to a company being forced to exist to serve whatever arbitrary need or approach you wish, and there being an open market such that a competitor can set up shop.

If you were entitled to alternatives, that means the tax payer has to reasonably fund every possible alternative that could exist, or at a minimum a vast array of them, and most likely at perpetual losses. It'd be extraordinarily dumb and would become an epic cost for the government and would breed corruption (failed businesses, bleeding vast red ink, perpetually subsidized no matter what they do).

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by xg15 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @03:52PM (#16596014)
True in the general case - however, it gets strange when that argument is used to defend monopolies, i.e. markets that, for whatever reason, are not open.

E.g., I personally don't see why it's bad when an elected government passes legislation but totally fine when Apple uniterally updates the App Store ToS or Google excludes certain things from Search. In both cases, participants of the respective markets won't have any choice than to comply.

I believe YouTube is comparable. Yes, there are alternatives. However, YouTube's popularity is important for content producers. If you make your own video content and are banned from YouTube, you'll likely have a significantly harder time to be discovered.

I agree with you that this woudn't really be an issue for GitHub, since there is neither a market nor any lock-in effects or monopoly.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by bzbarsky on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:57PM (#16596845)
There are absolutely lock-in effects.

You want to participate in web standards groups? You have to use github to do so in any sort of effective fashion.

Same thing for various open-source projects.

The _owner_ of a project has a bit more say in things, though I've heard some people claim that in order to attract contributors a project must be on GitHub nowadays, because many people will fail (or refuse) to participate in any way other than GitHub pull requests.

So I agree with you about Apple and YouTube; I just think GitHub is closer to them than you think it is...

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by yock on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:49PM (#16601913)
When you cherry pick quotes from the source it sounds contradictory. What I meant, and what I feel was clear when taken in context, is that alternatives exist in this particular case. However if you do not think those alternatives are viable then that's just too bad. You aren't entitled to viable alternatives, or alternatives that fit your definition of viable.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by zaarn on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:55AM (#16592840)
GitHub has a networking effect with other open source projects, same as Facebook or Google.

When Google decides you're not gonna show up in the search results, as much as 90% of your traffic could be gone. A business can (and have) go belly up for not showing up in page 1 of the search results.

IMO if a service crosses a certain threshold of networking and marketshare they should be regarded as a public utility rather than a private business. The other option is to give such corporations an incredibly amount of power over what the population thinks, sees or, in github's case, codes.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by ekianjo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:51PM (#16598008)
Nobody is forcing you to use such services no matter how large their market share is. This is not the same as public utility where there is only one choice.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by zaarn on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:31AM (#16599176)
Nobody is forcing you to use water from the faucet, the river is just outside town. Nobody is forcing you to use the electric grid, generator + gasoline is an option. Etc.

Even for public utility you have a choice. It's not a good choice, which is what matters.

Facebook and Google have definitely reached a state where not being part of their business (by being on Page 1 of the Results or having a Facebook Page) will actively harm your business. If either denies you service they also deny a lot of customers access to your service just like you'd get people denied service to a business when that business isn't connected to the power grid.

And if you think that isn't true I urge you to talk to a PR department of a bigger corporation or a startup. Placement on Google and Facebook is very very important.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by dsego on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:36AM (#16593185)
You are also always free to leave a country and live somewhere else. There are plenty of countries in the world. Isn't that the same argument?
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by aeorgnoieang on Thursday March 15, 2018 @12:08PM (#16594063)
But almost no one is actually free to move to another country.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by bzbarsky on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:36PM (#16594877)
If you replace "country" with "city" or "province", then pretty much everyone is in fact free to leave, legally. Yet we still consider it bad when such governments censor things.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by lawn on Thursday March 15, 2018 @01:56PM (#16595070)
In practice though you need a job and a new house. You might be legally free to leave but in reality you're not able to.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by bzbarsky on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:53PM (#16596824)
Right; my point was that "there are severe practical consequences for leaving" is exactly the situation with something like github.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by nybble41 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @06:14PM (#16596960)
The difference is that you are not entitled to receive service from GitHub. You are entitled to keep your own private property and to continue to interact voluntarily your current friends, family, and neighbors (and anyone else willing to deal with you). However, both of these liberties will be infringed by most governments if you attempt to remove yourself from their jurisdiction.
Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by bzbarsky on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:29PM (#16598380)
> you are not entitled to receive service from GitHub

Are you "entitled" to a job in your field? Plenty of employers now require you to work on GitHub.

> both of these liberties will be infringed by most governments if you attempt to remove yourself from their jurisdiction

What? If I attempt to move out of a city, the city government is not going to arrest me, in most countries. (There are some exceptions like China, but even there it's not the town government that does the arresing if someone tries to move.)

Seriously, not interacting with GitHub is a larger imposition for many people than not living in some particular city.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by nybble41 on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:26AM (#16601299)
> Are you "entitled" to a job in your field?

No.

> If I attempt to move out of a city, the city government is not going to arrest me, in most countries.

I was obviously referring to national governments—the original subject of this thread—and disavowing citizenship. Individual cities (usually) don't have the same power, if only because of their smaller size. However, just try opting out of city services (and taxes) while retaining all your private property, particularly land located within the city's borders. The city's influence may be less, but the principle remains the same.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by bzbarsky on Wednesday March 21, 2018 @02:44AM (#16636038)
> No.

Universal declaration of human rights article 23 may disagree, fwiw. Assuming you accept that declaration at all, of course. But the point is that there is, shall we say, a wide spectrum of views on this topic.

> I was obviously referring to national governments

That wasn't obvious at all, since you were commenting in a subthread that was specifically about how city governments are subject to many of the same restrictions even though leaving cities is "easy" (certainly comparable to leaving github).

> However, just try opting out of city services (and taxes) while retaining all your private property

The context here, just to remind you, is whether "just don't interact with entity X" is a reasonable response to complaints about entity X doing certain things like censorship. It's a well-established principle at least in the US that a city government cannot infringe your free speech rights. It's likewise a well-established principle that a corporation effectively can. This is largely due to accidents of history and somewhat due to differences in enforcement mechanisms (in that a city government could try to get you jailed with more success than a corporation).

But the "if you don't like it, just don't deal with them" response doesn't address any of that, and is in fact particularly weak because for many people it is _easier_ to not deal with a particular city government (i.e. move to a different city) than to not deal with GitHub.

Re:EU wants to require platforms to filter uploaded content,... by jwilk on Thursday March 15, 2018 @07:45AM (#16591938)