News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:46AM (#16568446)
I think Steve's underestimating the power of Google's control over OEMs here. Every OEM wants to get rid of Google's hold over them, but how do they do it without putting their entire corporation at risk? Google has already shown they'll ban your entire company from Google Apps access if you try to produce a single Android device without Google Apps.

So any company who wants to exclude Google puts their entire mobile product line at risk on this play. It'd be hard to see anything coming of this unless multiple manufacturers can agree to make the jump together, creating a platform large enough that even Google has to support it for their own market share needs (which means, this group must include Samsung, who's hedged their bets on this sort of thing but seems too scared to make the jump). And even then, this only remains an option as long as the Pixel remains niche. If the Pixel gains an iPhone-like market share amongst the broader range of Android devices, Google can mostly tell other manufacturers to screw off.

His notions on cross-platform frameworks making a non-Android platform viable are spot on though. Not only through things like React Native, but PWAs, which Google is pretty bullish on itself, despite the fact that it may make Windows Mobile a viable idea again.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by lern_too_spel on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:10PM (#16569080)
You overestimate how hard it is. Amazon did it, and the entire country of China did it out of necessity. As Amazon's ecosystem gains steam, there will be enough third party replacements for Google's apps that it will be easier for others to switch too.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by product50 on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:15PM (#16569124)
When are you seeing Amazon's Android ecosystem is gaining system? All they are doing is building their own apps on top of their implementation of Android. The rest of the apps are just being ported over from normal Android.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by wlesieutre on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:35PM (#16569309)
Amazon's phone might have flopped, but they've eaten the Android tablet market. Google tried to make a "pure" android tablet with the Nexus 7, Nexus 10, and Pixel C. The 7 was the only one of those with any success, and it's long gone. Tablets are either iPads, Surfaces, or Kindles now.

I don't know what Android tablet would be in next place after the Kindle. If you count big phones with styluses, probably the Galaxy Note. I know the Samsung Galaxy Tab line exists but I've literally never seen one.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by sbov on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:47PM (#16569429)
I think at least part of the death of the Nexus 7 is because Google seemed to have no interest in refreshing it. I was looking to upgrade mine a while back and the only thing available was the same old tablet.

Google has a weird relationship with consumer devices. They release stuff, then seemingly completely abandon it for years. I don't know what exactly their goal is with some of these devices, but if e.g. Microsoft did the same thing with the XBox, they would never be where they are now.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by dragonwriter on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:34PM (#16569771)
> Google has a weird relationship with consumer devices. They release stuff, then seemingly completely abandon it for years.

I always get the impression that Google doesn't want to be in the consumer hardware market, they want to be making software and online services supporting consumer hardware. They participate in the hardware market to drive the market in the direction they want it to go, but really want third-party hardware partners to do the heavy lifting on consumer hardware.

> I don't know what exactly their goal is with some of these devices, but if e.g. Microsoft did the same thing with the XBox, they would never be where they are now.

Their goal seems to be to become what Microsoft was with the PC market, only in more markets and with a bit more active hand in steering the hardware markets.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by zeveb on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:47PM (#16570884)
> I think at least part of the death of the Nexus 7 is because Google seemed to have no interest in refreshing it.

Yup. It was the right size (can fit in a pant or suit pocket!), it did everything one could want, and it worked just fine. Of course Google killed it.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by chaostheory on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:12PM (#16570128)
> They release stuff, then seemingly completely abandon it for years.

It's not just with devices. The most obvious place this happens is with IM services. Whether it's intentional or not, maintenance of existing products seems to be frowned upon within Google since promotions are mainly based on releasing new products.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by jjrh on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:21PM (#16569668)
> I don't know what exactly their goal is with some of these devices,

I always assumed google's hardware stuff was basically a reference implementation. When traditional manufacturers 'get it' google steps aside.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:38PM (#16569818)
This was definitely meant to be the case in the Nexus era, but the Pixels are heavily marketed widely to consumers, and are given features that are withheld from OEMs for a while. Especially with their push to branded accessories like the Pixel Buds and the like, I'm pretty sure the Pixel line is supposed to be their iPhone, a mainstream, consumer-friendly brand.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by pjmlp on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @04:53AM (#16574618)
With their update policy their are certainly not iPhone consumer-friendly like.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by dragonwriter on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:14PM (#16569622)
> Amazon's phone might have flopped, but they've eaten the Android tablet market.

What? Kindle Fire initially did really well, and Amazon was briefly no. 1 in Android-ish tablets and no. 2 in tablets behind Apple, but they’ve lost marketshare and others (mostly Samsung) have gained, largely on the back of the official flavor, rather than AOSP-derived versions like Amazon's, of Android.

> Tablets are either iPads, Surfaces, or Kindles now.

This would be closer to true (and in order of sales from most to least) if you said “Galaxy” in place of Surface.

> I don't know what Android tablet would be in next place after the Kindle.

Samsung sells more, in total;Amazon may have the highest selling individual model of tablet powered by an Android or Android-derived OS, but they don't sell the most devices.

> I know the Samsung Galaxy Tab line exists but I've literally never seen one.

I've literally never seen a Kindle Fire, and I saw three Galaxy tablets before I left my house this morning. But that's just anecdote, the more relevant thing is marketshare reports, and while different reports have the figures differently (and often breaks out only by vendor and not OS, and makers like Samsung have more than one tablet OS since convertibles are usually counted), but consistently across reports Amazon is significantly behind Samsung in tablets, e.g.:

https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/06/apple-continues-to-dominan...

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by wlesieutre on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:40PM (#16569836)
>the more relevant thing is marketshare reports

Looking at that IDC report, you'll note that Samsung is at -6.4% year over year for 2017. Amazon is at +30.0%.

If you look just at Q4, Amazon was in second place behind Apple (with Samsung in third), at +50.3% year over year compared to Samsung's -13.0%.

Those numbers do not indicate to me that Samsung is doing well in Android tablets. Granted the Samsung tablets are much more expensive than a Kindle Fire, so you'd expect it to be low, but the year over year downward trend is not impressive.

https://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=prUS43549518

EDIT - also note that the Galaxy Tab S3 (I think this is the current version?) is still shipping Android 7. Apparently Android 8 support is in development, but "it's going to be a while."

https://www.sammobile.com/news/galaxy-s7-galaxy-a5-galaxy-ta...

Bummer about Google's official tablets, they were better about software updates. The Pixel C (released at the end of 2015) got android 8 but will not get 9. Still, that was pretty good by Android standards.

Re: Surfaces, I'm probably overestimating these because I see them in professional use. They're pretty expensive to get much consumer traction.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by product50 on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:55PM (#16570430)
Also, you can look at Tablet Marketshare here: https://www.statista.com/statistics/276635/market-share-held...

Granted Amazon is big but Android tablet marketshare as a whole (exclusing Amazon) is much bigger. I would use data to back your assertions vs. what I am observing (as that is subject to echo chamber and confirmation bias risks).

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by amorphid on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:32PM (#16569754)
A few weeks ago, I wanted an Android tablet to play games. I shopped around for low end tablets, the the options all looked like the same tablets that were on the market 3 or 4 years ago. Many ran Androird 4.x,or 5.x. Didn't Android 5.x come out in 2014?

I ended up buying one of these: https://www.simbans.com/tangotab.html. So far it's OK.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by georgeecollins on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:56PM (#16569490)
I think the challenge for Google is that they have a release culture more than a product line culture. So some group in the org is really proud of releasing, Android Wear, Pixel C, AR Kit, Chromecast, Daydream, etc. They get the kudos for doing it and move on to releasing something else. So Google has products that are sometimes really compelling. But they don't execute a road map for them and they languish.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by product50 on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:53PM (#16570415)
Yes - Amazon has done well in tablet space but that isn't because of Android.

Most of the things that sell Amazon Fire are its really cheap price (it is probably a loss leader), seamless Amazon's Kindle and Content integrations (such as Prime as well as FreeTime). However, there are no Google Apps on it - no maps, no gmail, no Youtube etc. It is a really hamstrung experience if you have used their product.

Android is much much bigger than Amazon tablet and to say Amazon is eating away at Android is a disingenuous statement.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by pjmlp on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:40PM (#16570798)
> Amazon's phone might have flopped, but they've eaten the Android tablet market

That is very country specific, I hardly see any Kindle that isn't a plain e-book reader around here.

What I see on my train travels is people using iPads or Windows 10 tablets with detachable keyboards.

Anecdote data, take it as you wish.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by sounds on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:32PM (#16569275)
Well, it's gaining "steam," not "system," but I see it here:

https://www.npd.com/wps/portal/npd/us/blog/2018/with-homepod...

  day one pre-orders of HomePod were higher than all other
  smart speaker first day pre-orders, except Amazon’s Echo Dot
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by peatmoss on Monday March 12, 2018 @03:43PM (#16570828)
Thought exercise: Would Amazon be / have been better off maintaining their own not-quite-compatible version of Android? Or would they have been better off cloning and commoditizing Apple’s development ecosystem?

Higher up-front cost than a cheap fork of Android, for sure... But how much? Especially if they could manage to make a native development ecosystem that was plausibly competitive to Apple’s, but allowing for easily targeting Apple’s devices as well, I could see this strategy being a better way to stave off competition from third and fourth players.

There’s prior art on cloning Apple / NeXT APIs and whatnot. Surely a company with the heaft of Amazon could do at least as well as the small open source efforts.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by s73v3r_ on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:23PM (#16569684)
Not many of them. Things like Maps, for example. Unless you're targeting one of those Chinese devices without Google Services, you're going to use Google Maps, because that's what almost everyone has on their phone. You're not going to spend the resources basically doing the same thing twice with another Maps provider.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by patmcguire on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:33PM (#16569288)
Best candidate is some Chinese OEM or tech titan like WeChat that has already done all the insane work it would take to replace the things Google holds hostage. Wouldn't necessarily be more open if it's WeChat, though.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by bluGill on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:19AM (#16568698)
Of course if google actually tries that there is an anti-trust lawsuit awaiting them, which will probably force google to spin off android. (this may require a change in US presidents but that happens all the time)
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ttflee on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:06PM (#16569050)
> any company who wants to exclude Google puts their entire mobile product line at risk on this play

With the exception of China Inc. No place for Google so far.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:45PM (#16569410)
True, but that's solely because Google chose not to do business there. They left that opportunity open to other companies, which is why it's the only place competition really exists.

That being said, while a Chinese manufacturer could try to branch out into the international market, that hasn't been working out for them so far. Huawei and Xiaomi have both pushed in that direction, but beyond limited success to begin with, now government entities are discouraging Chinese brands due to perceived cybersecurity risks. Whether those risks are overblown or not, it has severely hampered these companies' ability to branch out to the international consumer.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by Oletros on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:52PM (#16569467)
And even they put Google services in their global ROM's. At least Xiaomi does
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by jbob2000 on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:56AM (#16568521)
To your point - software is king. Any two-bit electronics company can ship a phone, but it's a useless paper weight if it doesn't run the right software.

iPhone is generally behind the curve when it comes to hardware specs, but nobody cares about that because iOS is such a strong platform.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:58AM (#16568542)
And the "right" software is often controlled by one company. If you read a lot of reviews of Windows Phones, most reviewers seemed to more or less come to the same conclusion: That Windows was a faster, smoother OS, but that they had trouble going about their daily lives with it because it didn't have Gmail and the other five or six Google Apps they relied on.

As long as the market share of any newcomer is low enough, Google can leave them out in the cold for app support (or intentionally interfere by blocking YouTube access, similar to what they did with Windows Mobile, and now Amazon's Echo and Fire platforms), and they'll die off for that reason alone.

Whether it's an Android fork or a new OS like Tizen or some new Windows flavor, it won't beat Google unless it has the market share to force Google to support it with apps. And it's hard to get that market share without Google's support.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by RestlessMind on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:09AM (#16568634)
> (or intentionally interfere by blocking YouTube access, similar to what they did with Windows Mobile, and now Amazon's Echo and Fire platforms),

Nice spin there! Youtube was blocked on Windows Mobile because Microsoft blatantly blocked all the ads in violation of policy. If Microsoft was in the right here, we would have seen a lot more aggressive posturing from them instead of silent retreat.

And for Amazon, it was a reaction to Amazon's decision not to sell Chromecast (and Nest devices). Amazon's excuse is that Google changed Chromecast APIs, which smells weak when you see other supported apps on Chromecast from Netflix, HBO, ESPN etc.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by saurik on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:05PM (#16569045)
If you look at the totality of the evidence, even in that one story (where Microsoft then built the app to Google's specifications, with ads, and then Google waited until they released it before blocking it again), the story looks so bad against Google that even some of the reasonable press was starting to notice and report the issue as Google toying with Microsoft.

Here is a link to an overly-well-sourced comment I wrote on this:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14835776

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by sangnoir on Monday March 12, 2018 @02:40PM (#16570332)
At this time, Microsoft were also threatening Android vendors with a confidential list of patents (to prevent Android work-arounds) - MS leveraged these patents into a Windows Mobile deal "settlement" with Samsung. For a long while, Microsoft made more money from Android (patent license fees) than from WinMo.

Why would anyone expect Google to handle Microsoft with kid-gloves in this bout of corporate-combat when Microsoft was playing to win? You don't bring a knife to a gunfight.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:30AM (#16568775)
You are definitely applying your own spin, to be sure. ;) Microsoft tried repeatedly to work with the YouTube team to comply with Google's ToS, but it was a moving target, Google kept changing their requirements until it was largely impossible to comply.

The Amazon/Google spat goes back a lot further than that, which I've talked about a bit in other comments here.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by s73v3r_ on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:25PM (#16569701)
"or intentionally interfere by blocking YouTube access, similar to what they did with Windows Mobile"

They killed the Microsoft YouTube client because it didn't play by the rules regarding showing ads or downloading videos.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by culot on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:12AM (#16568653)
Windows Mobile/Phone actually was less capable than Android on similar hardware. That Windows Phone had superior resource management was a myth. Even on high-end hardware Windows Phone struggles to handle things that even a lower-end Android device can handle.

I don't know if Windows Mobile was ever faster or smoother, but for certain it was not in the last few years.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:32AM (#16568792)
As someone who's spent years using both, I can definitely disagree. Even a budget Windows Mobile was far less sluggish than my high end Motorola flagship phones.

In fact, I had a phone with Microsoft's Android Bridge beta, and while people were complaining how slow the Android apps were on it... I realized that it was more or less just the normal performance Android apps ran at.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by jacksmith21006 on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @06:49PM (#16589063)
This is the ultimate in revision. Windows phone was incredibly laggy on similar hardware to Android.

I assume it was related to the inefficiency of the Windows kernel compared to Linux.

http://blog.zorinaq.com/i-contribute-to-the-windows-kernel-w... "I Contribute to the Windows Kernel. We Are Slower Than Other ...

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by panopticon on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:53PM (#16569476)
> I had a phone with Microsoft's Android Bridge beta, and while people were complaining how slow the Android apps were on it... I realized that it was more or less just the normal performance Android apps ran at.

Seems a little disingenuous to pin performance against a half-implemented ASOP API running on an environment without all of the JVM bytecode tuning Google has put into ART/Dalvik.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ocdtrekkie on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:09PM (#16569590)
I wasn't. I carried Android phones as my primary devices for over six years. I was comparing that experience, to my experiences with the Android Bridge.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by kerberos84 on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:59AM (#16568990)
I don't know if you ever used a decent windows phone. But I can tell you that my Lumia 1020 was way more stable, smoother and user friendly than my Samsung Note 5.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by pjmlp on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:34PM (#16569296)
The Lumia devices I have here are the living proof that isn't a myth.

I have never seen an 150 € Android devices that were as fast as they are.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by jacksmith21006 on Wednesday March 14, 2018 @06:46PM (#16589041)
What? MS blocked ads and facilitated stealing from YouTubers. Do you honestly support this type of behavior?
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by hantusk on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:16AM (#16568674)
That iPhone is behind the curve on hardware specs is not really true. Their CPU+GPU is faster than anything else on the market.

And in terms of other hardware (RAM, camera, sensors) I would still say it's arguable

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by coldtea on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:24PM (#16569210)
Actually the iPhone is only "behind the curve" in adopting new form factors. Regarding CPU and GPU power, camera quality, and new sensors and stuff, the iPhone has always been the machine to beat.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by iainmerrick on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:18AM (#16568684)
iPhone is generally behind the curve when it comes to hardware specs

Really? In all the benchmarks I've seen, the latest iPhones handily beat the latest Android phones. (And old iPhones remain usable longer than old Android phones.)

Assuming the software doesn't get in the way, benchmarks are all about hardware, not software.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by mattnewton on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:21AM (#16568712)
The numbers on the box may be lower (number of cores, ram size), but I agree, benchmarks usually show iPhone very competitive or in the lead.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by kerberos84 on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:05PM (#16569047)
Given that those benchmarks running on operating systems, the software(OS) matters. >And old iPhones remain usable longer than old Android phones. It depends which Android phone you are comparing with. If you compare with a flagship, it should be head-to-head. But i think that is because of stability/efficiency of iOS over android.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by iainmerrick on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:51PM (#16569459)
Given that those benchmarks running on operating systems, the software(OS) matters.

No, if the OS significantly slows down a benchmark, it's a bad OS. Both Android and iOS are fine in this respect. (It's a bit fuzzier for graphics tests, I admit, where driver quality comes into play.)

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by jjrh on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:26PM (#16569709)
> But i think that is because of stability/efficiency of iOS over android.

From what I understand iOS is pretty picky about background processes. Limit what can run in the background (and for how long) with android and you will probably get similar results.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by iainmerrick on Monday March 12, 2018 @01:58PM (#16570010)
I don't understand why you are all talking about software and the OS. My point was that for basic benchmarks testing things like CPU speed and storage speed -- the hardware -- iPhones tend to be ahead of Android phones.

A quick google search gives me results like this: https://www.tomsguide.com/us/galaxy-s9-benchmarks,review-519... "Galaxy S9 Is Fastest Android Ever, But iPhone X Is Faster"

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by wand3r on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:24AM (#16568733)
I couldnt immeadiately find a graph or data but potentially parent was talking about price v performance. The computer offerings historically have been behind the curve but I thought the iPhone performance was strong compared to the field. I would be happy to change my opinion with new information but I agree with you.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by zellyn on Monday March 12, 2018 @12:01PM (#16569006)
If by "generally behind the curve when it comes to hardware specs" you mean a generation and a half _ahead_, then yes.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by lev99 on Monday March 12, 2018 @10:57AM (#16568536)
iOS also seems to perform better with similar specs than Android.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by pkage on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:11AM (#16568645)
Perks of not running everything in the JVM. Even though it's really fast at this point, it's still going to have more overhead than running apps natively.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by vbezhenar on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @02:37AM (#16574210)
Does it matter when half of the apps are based on Cordova or React Native, running everything in the JavaScript VM and majority of the games are based on Unity running exactly the same C++ and C# code everywhere. It's not like some calendar app will have major performance gains with native code.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by lev99 on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:18AM (#16568686)
Compiled code is faster than bytecode is faster than interpreters.

It's not always true, but it's a good rule of thumb.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by candiodari on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:55PM (#16573797)
It's long established that Java's problem is not the JVM or bytecode but it's memory model.

Java's bytecode execution speed in the JVM is good enough that it's on part with C, easily beating any language with even a slightly inefficient compiler, like Go or Haskell.

Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by ptx on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @06:15AM (#16574903)
Are you referring to the lack of value types? Or is there some more fundamental problem?
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by candiodari on Tuesday March 13, 2018 @06:51AM (#16575084)
That's a decent part of it, but also the fact that in Java:

  class A {
    B b;
  }
"b" will be a pointer, as opposed to "b" being contained within instances of class A.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by enitihas on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:55AM (#16568965)
Android does not run anything on the JVM AFAIK.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by gruez on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:18AM (#16568683)
this. android phones only seem "better" because they have a buttload of cores (10 in some cases) with weak single threaded performance.
Re:Who will steal Android from Google? by tboyd47 on Monday March 12, 2018 @11:14AM (#16568663)
This is Nintendo's same strategy, I believe.