News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by freddie_mercury on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:13PM (#16526361)
Musk already owns tons of Tesla story and should be motivated by that. There's absolutely no evidence that additional equity would motivate him more. On the contrary, there is plenty of evidence on the diminishing marginal utility of wealth.

Like much CEO pay, Musk's pay package is more about status than about motivating him.

Or is someone really going to try to make the case that he's kinda half-assing it right now?

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by dsacco on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:12PM (#16526595)
> There's absolutely no evidence that additional equity would motivate him more.

Yes there is. Presumably, if Musk proposed a compensation package, it’s because he wants that compensation, and if the compensation is tied to uncertain milestones, he’ll be motivated to get the thing he wants by trying to achieve those milestones. It’s not as though someone proposed this to Musk and he said, “yeah sure, whatever.”

> Like much CEO pay, Musk's pay package is more about status than about motivating him.

Status can be very motivating. Obviously no one is in it for the “marginal utility of wealth” at the level of wealth Musk has, but the ability to pay for basic needs strikes me as a pretty one-dimensional way to view the way money can be motivating.

Extremely wealthy people still clearly pursue more wealth, so it’s pretty straightforwardly motivating in some sense.

> Or is someone really going to try to make the case that he's kinda half-assing it right now?

It’s not really a matter of “half-assing”, it’s a matter of further aligning someone’s goals with the organization they’re leading. Your implication here seems to be that someone can’t do a better job than they’re doing unless they’re slacking.

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by lend000 on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:18PM (#16526383)
> On the contrary, there is plenty of evidence on the diminishing marginal utility of wealth.

For the average person, but who are you to decide? He clearly already spends his money productively by largely self-funding ambitious projects, and I suspect that he would be pursuing even more if he had infinite resources.

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by cagenut on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:14PM (#16526600)
I'm a shareholder and I just voted against for basically this reason. I don't think the difference between owning 20 billion in equity and owning 25 billion in equity (or whatever) will mater to musk at all. he's fine. and he's going to try to finish what he started either way.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by wirelessest on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:37PM (#16526688)
But the cost to his ego for not meeting a milestone which receives even more publicity because of the big price tag is a big motivator (or at least one could argue)

So even if the utility of the funds isn't consequential, a package like this might be one if the few ways to further incentivize a CEO like Musk.

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by IntronExon on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:53PM (#16526735)
If he’s not incentivized by all of the high ideals he claims, plus $20 billion, then he’s broken.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by Roverlord on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @06:24AM (#16528159)
Maybe some people are infinitely incentivizable, because they can always figure out a way to do something useful with the money.

Bill Gates for instance, although his model seems to be give it all away to good causes he believes can accomplish good. Elon still seems to believe more in his own capabilities to accomplish worthwhile things with it.

I expect he too has a little txt file somewhere on his desktop, with various amounts as milestones to unlock the next project.

Maybe at $22 billion he can afford to start asteroid mining and in orbit construction or something that would top his current accomplishments.

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by IntronExon on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @03:18PM (#16531745)
Asteroid mining and orbital construction would require trillions in investment, and years of focused work by a number of institutions. As far as I can tell, Musk uses that rhetoric for PR, and it works. So far an electric car company and rockets suited for LEO don’t add up to grand space adventures.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by mulmen on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:40PM (#16526700)
Permit me to rewrite history a bit for the sake of example. If you were a Paypal shareholder and Musk was CEO would you have supported this compensation package? Would you have supported it even if you didn't know SpaceX or Tesla were his ambitions?
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by toomuchtodo on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:49PM (#16526727)
Also a shareholder. Voted for. If Elon wants to die on Mars and needs personal wealth to get him there, as long as he delivers on his Tesla milestones, I've got no problem with it.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by tehlike on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:29PM (#16526659)
HE can fund his future ambitions with the additional equity.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by ericb on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:20PM (#16526389)
He's not half-assing it, but he has Mars goals which are likely to distract him at some point. He is serious about his Mars efforts. At a certain point it makes sense for him to leave to focus on that, unless staying at Tesla also helps him hit his Mars goal by 10xing the resources he can dedicate to the effort.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by kilroy123 on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:25PM (#16526408)
He said he wants all this money just so he can fund colonizing Mars.

So I'm guessing he'd take that money and just privately fund SpaceX, like Jeff Bozos is doing with blue origin.

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:01PM (#16526550)
> I'm guessing he'd take that money and just privately fund SpaceX

If his goal is to colonize Mars and you want him to sell cars, a good way to do that is to say "sell cars for 10 years and we'll give you enough capital to do in the following 10 what you couldn't do in 20 from today."

Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by FireBeyond on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:12PM (#16526590)
Right, not so much half-assing as diluted, distracted in too many different ways.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by amorphid on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:37PM (#16526457)
It feels good to get rewarded for a job well done. Just sayin'.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by psyc on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:55PM (#16526743)
I don't think it makes sense to apply this kind of 'evidence' to a specific individual.
Re:Tesla's $2.6B Musk Award Too Costly, Glass Lewis Says by cptaj on Monday March 05, 2018 @10:35PM (#16526682)
For personal use, sure. But remember he wants to fund Mars missions.