Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by gargravarr on Monday March 05, 2018 @08:20AM
(#16520825)
I still use a point-and-shoot (I don't really like the highly-advanced camera on my Galaxy S5 because the interface is poor).
GPS is difficult, because navigation is so much better when you pull up-to-date maps from the internet - old standalone sat nav units go out of date very quickly, as do printed maps. But at the same time, I don't want the companies behind it to have free rein of my location data to spam me with adverts.
The rest of the sensors aren't that useful - the light sensor is a nice convenience to dim the screen, but Apple introduced the concept over 10 years ago and most laptop manufacturers still handle brightness manually, so swiping the control panel down on a phone and sliding for brightness isn't a big deal. The rotation sensor annoys me, especially if I pick up a device while I'm lying in bed, so I have the screen orientation locked. Other sensors like the health-based heart rate sensor on my S5 are neat, but totally optional.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by detaro on Monday March 05, 2018 @08:31AM
(#16520894)
That'd be my option as well, but more as a workaround for a device that I really wanted otherwise but didn't have GPS for some reason and not as "that's the setup I want". If I were to carry a GPS tracker anyways sometimes (e.g. when I don't have a phone with me), then it might be different.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @08:34AM
(#16528707)
Nope.
I use the camera all the freaking time. As in, more than I use the phone function. For me, it is one of the more handy functions of the phone. I no longer keep a camera on me at all times.
GPS? Yeah, I kind of rely on it from time to time to find places I've never been before. In addition, I have a very poor sense of direction, made worse by moving to a northern latitude and from a fairly flat place to a mountainous one. I also use it when on vacation.
Things like rotation sensors I would rather have with me. I could probably live without some because I don't realize they are there or how they help.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by nikajon_es on Monday March 05, 2018 @12:12PM
(#16522499)
without-camera: maybe
without-GPS: yes
without-sensors: (without knowing exactly what "sensors" are) I think yes. But I may be using a "sensor" that I don't know about
The camera is nice for quick snapshots of moments, and when someone else's camera has died, it's nice to be able to take over. But all-in-all I don't use the camera that much.
GPS: having turn-by-turn directions is nice, but I can read a map and its nice to understand where you're going before just relying on something telling you to "turn left now"...
There are a ton of sensors in phones now-a-days, so I'm not sure which ones are in use to provide some features that I may really like. Therefore, I'd have to see on this one. My initial reaction is that I don't really use many of them, but this may be a false assumption.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by fiftyacorn on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:56AM
(#16521405)
I considered dumbing down my phone recently after my last one broke. Opted for a cheap android as i wanted a podcast player, and a camera to photograph kids
One thing i want is a cover for my camera lenses - i hate that cases dont have this by default. Also i could live without the front camera
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by cimmanom on Monday March 05, 2018 @11:43AM
(#16522260)
Nope, those are the two features of my phone that I actually want to use (camera and mapping) because they're useful to have on hand but not time sinks. I would love to buy one that didn't support web browsing or games, though!
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by 5555624 on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:35AM
(#16521275)
It depends largely on the price. Although I occasionally use the camera, I tend to use my dedicated camera more. I have the location turned off. Since my phone is getting old, I've thought of reverting to a dumb phone, so I might.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by superasn on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @07:56PM
(#16533544)
Definitely not but I would certainly buy a phone that isn't running background processes all the time or doesn't have to be connected or pinging the internet all the time.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by bsvalley on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:47AM
(#16521348)
The 2 apps I use the most on my mobile phone are the Camera app and Google Map. In today’s and age I would not spend money on a Startac Motorola or a Nokia phone.
Re:Ask HN: Will you buy a smartphone without camera, GPS and...
by MaryTurner on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @04:13AM
(#16527775)
mmmh it's pretty hard to responde. Sensors?? Yes i could live without, camera ..mmmhhh may be (it better to have 10 good photo than 10000000 of low quality, in terms of frame photo). ..in the gps ..no i could live without even if sometimes it's very useful even only to plot a run or a walking
GPS is difficult, because navigation is so much better when you pull up-to-date maps from the internet - old standalone sat nav units go out of date very quickly, as do printed maps. But at the same time, I don't want the companies behind it to have free rein of my location data to spam me with adverts.
The rest of the sensors aren't that useful - the light sensor is a nice convenience to dim the screen, but Apple introduced the concept over 10 years ago and most laptop manufacturers still handle brightness manually, so swiping the control panel down on a phone and sliding for brightness isn't a big deal. The rotation sensor annoys me, especially if I pick up a device while I'm lying in bed, so I have the screen orientation locked. Other sensors like the health-based heart rate sensor on my S5 are neat, but totally optional.
In short, yes, no (mostly) and yes.
How about dedicated GPS receiver connected with bluetooth? I used to carry one, it worked well.
I use the camera all the freaking time. As in, more than I use the phone function. For me, it is one of the more handy functions of the phone. I no longer keep a camera on me at all times.
GPS? Yeah, I kind of rely on it from time to time to find places I've never been before. In addition, I have a very poor sense of direction, made worse by moving to a northern latitude and from a fairly flat place to a mountainous one. I also use it when on vacation.
Things like rotation sensors I would rather have with me. I could probably live without some because I don't realize they are there or how they help.
The camera is nice for quick snapshots of moments, and when someone else's camera has died, it's nice to be able to take over. But all-in-all I don't use the camera that much. GPS: having turn-by-turn directions is nice, but I can read a map and its nice to understand where you're going before just relying on something telling you to "turn left now"...
There are a ton of sensors in phones now-a-days, so I'm not sure which ones are in use to provide some features that I may really like. Therefore, I'd have to see on this one. My initial reaction is that I don't really use many of them, but this may be a false assumption.
One thing i want is a cover for my camera lenses - i hate that cases dont have this by default. Also i could live without the front camera
why no GPS?
Have a point and shoot for decent pictures, my current phone's camera is pants.
Handy as maps are I wonder what privacy I'm giving up using them.
I don't use sensors.
I've actually considered recently getting a dumb phone.
Could a hardware button disabling all sensors be an option?
Certainly