News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by hliyan on Sunday March 04, 2018 @10:14AM (#16514925)
A different article puts the energy costs at: "140 pounds ($185) per megawatt-hour on top of the current wholesale power price in the UK, which is about 49 pounds ($65) per megawatt-hour"

Some way to go before it becomes competitive...

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by lumisota on Sunday March 04, 2018 @10:36AM (#16515017)
Those aren't the costs of generating the energy. They receive ~£140/MWh in government subsidies, and ~£49/MWh for wholesale supply.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by chiefalchemist on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:49PM (#16515598)
Fair enough but...

1) What does Big Oil's subsidies (including special tax breaks) look like?

2) Depending on where you stand on the cause of climate change, I think it could be argued that aiding renewables isn't a subsidy in the traditional sense, as much as inventment in hopes of mitigating future expenses due to climate change.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by emiliobumachar on Sunday March 04, 2018 @02:56PM (#16516306)
Fair enough, but again...

I'm in favor of subsidies for clean energy, but I'm also in favor of calling a spade a spade.

Pretty much every subsidy nowadays has some "for the public good" narrative, some more believable than others. I don't think having a better such narrative than average makes it not a "subsidy in the traditional sense".

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by chiefalchemist on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:33PM (#16517476)
Fair enough, but again...

2) Depending on where you stand on the cause of climate change, I think it could be argued that aiding renewables isn't a subsidy in the traditional sense, as much as inventment in hopes of mitigating future expenses due to climate change.

I don't want to assume, so I have to ask: Do you understand the difference between an expense and an investment?

To clarify, it's not narrative if $X today aims to save $X x Y and Z lives tomorrow, to say nothing of the social and sociopolitical disruption. That's still a subsidy? I don't agree; at all.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by todd8 on Monday March 05, 2018 @07:17AM (#16520498)
According the University of Texas Energy Institute[1], the federal financial support in the USA for generation of energy is estimated to be (2019 numbers):

    Oil & Gas   $0.95/MWh
    Coal        $1.07/MWh
    Nuclear     $1.74/MWh

    Wind       $15.15/MWh
    Solar      $42.51/MWh
    Other RE   $22.85/MWh
A lot goes into the calculation of these numbers, for more detail see the referenced white paper.

[1] /Federal Financial Support for Electricity Generation Technologies/, https://energy.utexas.edu/sites/default/files/UTAustin_FCe_S...

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by jhayward on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:51AM (#16521374)
Unfortunately these numbers omit the 3 trillion dollars spent in war in the middle east and Afghanistan, none of which would have occurred were it not for US military and covert efforts to secure oil resources in that area. Just adding in the cost of running the US 5th fleet would arguably be a good start.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by vuln on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:24PM (#16515479)
So the consumer is paying twice? Through taxes and then again when they actually purchase the power? Wow...
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by hunta2097 on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:32PM (#16515523)
British taxpayer here. I'm completely fine with it. Makes me wonder what we could do had we invested that bailout in innovation rather than City of London banking.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by chiefalchemist on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:40PM (#16515563)
If it keeps you from going to war (for oil) and/ or being manipulated in other way (e.g., by Big Oil) then it's money well spent.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by DEADBEEF on Tuesday March 06, 2018 @03:54AM (#16527713)
Just an aside, but much of the bailout money was recovered when the shares the UK acquired were subsequently sold on once the banks had restabilised.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by pjc50 on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:57PM (#16515633)
If we kept going with coal, the government might have to pay the costs of dealing with Somerset, Norfolk etc being underwater instead ...
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by tonyedgecombe on Monday March 05, 2018 @01:42AM (#16519207)
The shift away from coal to gas started a long time ago and was driven by costs more than anything else.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by FreeFull on Sunday March 04, 2018 @08:42PM (#16518083)
That's going to happen either way, as long as other countries with coal. There are other problems with coal though that make it really not worth using either way.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by PoachedSausage on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:35PM (#16517207)
Not to even mention a taller Thames Barrier.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by tomcam on Sunday March 04, 2018 @04:33PM (#16516898)
Yes. Welcome to the world of corporate welfare.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by chiefalchemist on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:38PM (#16515554)
Yes. But certainly a far better return than an excesssive over "investment" in the MIC and its ilk.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by Gys on Sunday March 04, 2018 @10:35AM (#16515013)
12 more years ;-)

> By 2030, Statoil says, it hopes to bring the cost of floating offshore wind down to €40-60 per MWh ($50-74 per MWh).

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 04, 2018 @10:47AM (#16515068)
You should look at how inaccurate the EIA predicted renewable generation costs would decline (they predicted decades longer). Solar and battery manufacturing costs have been dropping ~80% every decade.

Even if the cost decline curve starts to flatten, the fate of fossil and nuclear generators is sealed.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by CydeWeys on Sunday March 04, 2018 @11:35AM (#16515282)
Wind power is big on-site construction though, which doesn't decrease much in cost over time (if at all). Yes, there'll be some economies in scale if we're making ten times as many turbine blades in the future versus now, but that won't come close to the orders of magnitude improvements we've seen in cost efficiency in photovoltaic cells over the past decades.

To use a simple example outside of renewables, it's now more expensive than ever before in US history to complete a large infrastructure project (say, a new bridge across the Hudson River), but you can buy a $40 Raspberry Pi that has more processing capacity than all the billions of dollars worth of computers that existed in the 60s.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by cjalmeida on Sunday March 04, 2018 @01:29PM (#16515796)
Floating offshore wind has it's own manufacturing dynamics. For instance, you can build the whole structure in a shipyard and toll it, unlike onshore.

Floating towers are definitely a revolution in wind farm building.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 04, 2018 @01:50PM (#16515907)
Also very importantly, this can keep shipyards busy building continuously, which is superior to the usual shipbuilding boom/bust cycles.

(I found several citations around boom/bust cycles, but mostly paywalled [WSJ, Economist]; Google if you're interested)

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by jopsen on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:19PM (#16517120)
Any reason to believe wind farminh won't follow the same economic mood swings?
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by usrusr on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:57PM (#16517318)
Wind generators would be very price elastic: if an idle shipyard makes a desperate offer, the whole profitability threshold shifts and the energy market is impossible to completely saturate (worst case you'd have so much energy that it would be economical to synthesize hydrocarbons from thin air, to pump them into the ground for CO2 credits).

Also, look at it from the other side: the actors (states) who might be interested in propping up shipyards have very little direct use for generic shipping. Even less if there is a shipping glut (which would typically be just the time when the shipyard would need the propping-up). Conventionally, the only realistic thing a state could do to keep the shipyards in business would be to order some warships. With floating wind, this would change, instead of getting something destructive that will keep costing money once it's there you could get something productive.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by CydeWeys on Sunday March 04, 2018 @03:19PM (#16516451)
What's the cost reduction of doing this? Wind blades, turbines, and towers are already built in factories; the only difference here appears to be that you don't need to do as much site prep or assembly on site? I'm sure it saves some money but I'd be surprised if it saves even half.
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by alphydan on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:04PM (#16517047)
That's not the critical factor. The critical factor is sea depth and wind speed.

1. Wind Power ~ v^3 (the power produced is proportional to the wind speed cubed. So a site with 8m/s average speed makes twice as much money as one with 6m/s!

2. Often, that sweet offshore-spot is too deep (in that the cost of monopiles [1] is prohibitive).

So the key decision is: If I can make it go just a little deeper, I can make 2x or 3x as much money. Thus floating turbines can unlock more revenue (but the cost variation is not so important).

[1] http://www.4coffshore.com/windfarms/monopiles-support-struct...

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by CydeWeys on Monday March 05, 2018 @02:19PM (#16523579)
How much more is it possible to get in the way of gains by moving even further offshore? Or does it top out at 8 m/s average speed?
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by alphydan on Wednesday March 07, 2018 @08:51PM (#16541640)
I gave 6m/s and 8m/s as realistic numbers to show the dramatic increase with a little bit more speed. Further offshore you can have average annual speeds over 10m/s (This time, a roughly x4.5 increase in revenue compared to 6m/s) [0].

The large turbines typically operate up to 25m/s and then shut down for safety. Really large offshore turbines operate ideally at an average of 11m/s [1]. You can also see some real data here [2].

However, what investors (or farm operators) really care about it LCOE. Levelized cost of Energy over the lifetime of the machine. It's that $50/MWh and considers the revenue (roughly proportional to v^3) and all the costs. After that it's an optimization game:

- Too far = costly maintenance, costly installation, longer cables, rougher seas - Too close = not enough wind (but "cheap" installation)

(Plus many other important factors: risk, incentives, NIMBY, access to capital, wind turbulence, etc, etc)

[0] https://goo.gl/images/NFny2a [1] http://www.homepages.ucl.ac.uk/~uceseug/Fluids2/Wind_Turbine... [2] http://www.wind-power-program.com/large_turbines.htm

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by nicoburns on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:15PM (#16515438)
I think cost per mwh has been improving for wind not by reducing infrustructure construction costs, but by increasing the amount of power a given installation generates. If the generator/turbine is twice as efficient then the cost is halved...
Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by toomuchtodo on Sunday March 04, 2018 @12:22PM (#16515473)
This is correct. Turbine hub altitude and per turbine output continues to climb.

https://i.imgur.com/7H0Jgdm.png

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by jhayward on Monday March 05, 2018 @09:55AM (#16521396)
> Wind power is big on-site construction though, which doesn't decrease much in cost over time (if at all)

False. Every industry has what's known as the learning curve. It is this curve which is responsible for e.g., the 90% drop in cost of solar panels since 2000.

Wind turbine manufacture, blade manufacture, mooring, installation, maintenance, management, all are following a significant industrial learning curve and there is every reason to expect it to continue to behave like other industries.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by jopsen on Sunday March 04, 2018 @05:18PM (#16517117)
Lots of the components in wind turbines are custom made, CNC milled, etc. with more scale and focus on cost optimizations they can get far.

As for the bridge: the concrete business doesn't see a lot of innovation.

Still if corrected for inflation and aiming for similar durability, it wouldn't surprise me if today's engineering can build cheaper bridges. After all, we've learned a thing or two about suspension bridges over the years.

Re:Scotland’s floating wind farm is showing how powerful off... by walshemj on Sunday March 04, 2018 @06:46PM (#16517560)
And hell of a lot more for offshore