News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by michael_nielsen on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @10:59AM (#1649565)
I've known many police officers who care deeply about guilt or innocence.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by andreyf on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @01:48PM (#1650231)
Well, surely there exist some police officers/detectives/etc who see their personal career as more important than the ideals of their profession. It would also seem reasonable that, on average, these officers are better at advancing to powerful positions than those who care about ideals.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by woodall on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @02:28PM (#1650369)
It would also seem reasonable that, on average, these officers are better at advancing to powerful positions than those who care about ideals.

It does not seem reasonable because you have cited no statics or data. It would seem reasonable to assume, that on average, ants are all red. You can't just say something and it become true.

Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by dstorrs on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @06:41PM (#1651118)
I think you're confused by the word "reasonable." GP post is using it in the sense of "a plausible hypothesis", which it is -- it is plausible that people who care about their careers to the exclusion of all else (e.g., ideals) will advance farther and faster. Whether it is correct is a separate issue -- that is where the statistics and data come in.

Actually, "on average, all ants are red" is a good counterexample for plausibility -- talking about a universal truth that applies "on average" is not logical even at a casual glance, therefore it is not reasonable.

Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by dagw on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @03:00AM (#1652095)
The problem is that the opposite hypothesis is also plausible, and without no data about why one is likely to be more "reasonable", the statement doesn't really say anything.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by andreyf on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @06:29PM (#1654548)
Agreed. I think that's the common ground between marcusbooster's sentiment and michael_nielsen's experience with individual officers.

To expound just a little, I think it's likely that there both exist police departments where careerists do well, and others where responsible officers do. I think we can also all agree that we ought to encourage a legal structure where officers can't advance their careers by falsifying evidence/extracting confessions from innocents/etc.

Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by joe_the_user on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @05:21PM (#1650907)
In the article itself, the officers in question did care deeply about guilt and innocence. They were simply wrong about it.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by Natsu on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @04:17PM (#1650746)
It's weird, because all the cops I hear about are bad cops (the only exception being some during 9-11).

But all the cops I've met offline have been decent and professional, even when they were giving me a ticket or warning. Granted, it probably helps that I've never been in serious trouble, nor have I been suspected of anything bad.

Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by nollidge on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @04:25PM (#1650770)
Shouldn't be surprising. How often are you going to hear about the mundane but good works of 99% of police officers vs. the one bad apple?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negativity_bias

Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday August 31, 2010 @05:39PM (#1650956)
> But all the cops I've met offline have been decent and professional, even when they were giving me a ticket or warning.

Tickets and warnings are no big deal. Let me know how you feel about them if you're ever arrested.