Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf...
by dagw on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @03:00AM
(#1652095)
The problem is that the opposite hypothesis is also plausible, and without no data about why one is likely to be more "reasonable", the statement doesn't really say anything.
Re:Reasonable Doubt: Innocence Project Co-Founder Peter Neuf...
by andreyf on Wednesday September 01, 2010 @06:29PM
(#1654548)
Agreed. I think that's the common ground between marcusbooster's sentiment and michael_nielsen's experience with individual officers.
To expound just a little, I think it's likely that there both exist police departments where careerists do well, and others where responsible officers do. I think we can also all agree that we ought to encourage a legal structure where officers can't advance their careers by falsifying evidence/extracting confessions from innocents/etc.
Actually, "on average, all ants are red" is a good counterexample for plausibility -- talking about a universal truth that applies "on average" is not logical even at a casual glance, therefore it is not reasonable.