That makes me wonder whether this person would be an equal in the endeavor or would he always be a second. A cofounder should be someone that covers your weaknesses and can support you during the trying times, because very few startups don't have those times. You should be wary of a dynamic where one person is more of a mentor to the other.
>What would you think if your first dev hire was really more comfortable being a manager, but was "willing" to develop software for the time being?
Well put.... it's making me think twice...
How many other people will have sales experience, commitment etc to a new product that has not even launched? Is there someone better than a person you trust (to be smart, competent, honest etc)?
That being said, it's all pointless if they don't have drive. And the one-two punch of hesitation of doing sales combined with initially only wanting to work a couple days a week tells me that this individual is definitely not ready to commit. I think that can be a trap especially with more experienced people - it's easy for the startup to be something speculative that they take a wait and see approach with than something that is their sole professional focus.
- Unwillingness / hesitation to do sales - In an early stage startup, and especially as a co-founder, you need to be willing to do what needs to be done, even if it's outside of your comfort zone. As the technical co-founder, you're still going to be involved in the business, and probably even selling yourself. People who are more interested in managing or high-level strategy than getting their hands dirty is a big red flag in my opinion. What would you think if your first dev hire was really more comfortable being a manager, but was "willing" to develop software for the time being?
- Commitment level - if he's working a couple of days a week for an indefinite period of time, that's an indicator that he really doesn't have "skin in the game". If you want to go forward, I would consider something like bringing him on as a consultant, and making him a co-founder if and when he's fully ready to commit.