- Unwillingness / hesitation to do sales - In an early stage startup, and especially as a co-founder, you need to be willing to do what needs to be done, even if it's outside of your comfort zone. As the technical co-founder, you're still going to be involved in the business, and probably even selling yourself. People who are more interested in managing or high-level strategy than getting their hands dirty is a big red flag in my opinion. What would you think if your first dev hire was really more comfortable being a manager, but was "willing" to develop software for the time being?
- Commitment level - if he's working a couple of days a week for an indefinite period of time, that's an indicator that he really doesn't have "skin in the game". If you want to go forward, I would consider something like bringing him on as a consultant, and making him a co-founder if and when he's fully ready to commit.
That makes me wonder whether this person would be an equal in the endeavor or would he always be a second. A cofounder should be someone that covers your weaknesses and can support you during the trying times, because very few startups don't have those times. You should be wary of a dynamic where one person is more of a mentor to the other.
>What would you think if your first dev hire was really more comfortable being a manager, but was "willing" to develop software for the time being?
Well put.... it's making me think twice...
How many other people will have sales experience, commitment etc to a new product that has not even launched? Is there someone better than a person you trust (to be smart, competent, honest etc)?
That being said, it's all pointless if they don't have drive. And the one-two punch of hesitation of doing sales combined with initially only wanting to work a couple days a week tells me that this individual is definitely not ready to commit. I think that can be a trap especially with more experienced people - it's easy for the startup to be something speculative that they take a wait and see approach with than something that is their sole professional focus.
If you have MVP but no customers, funding, or employees, 98% of risk is still ahead. There are important, identity defining questions about the business ahead, from how you position yourself against competition when marketing, to your recruiting process, to a multi-stage financing strategy. From experience, it can REALLY help to have a co-founder who is motivated at the "I'll make this business succeed" level to discuss those things and to implement them.
Is this that guy? It's smart to complement yourself with sales experience, but is he someone you want to have holistic business conversations with? If so, give him the co-founder title. If not, look for that person... going alone as a solo founder will be much harder if you are more of a builder than a seller.
Equity is a different story. Put both of you on a vesting schedule. Start your own vesting earlier, so that on day 1 you have 100% of vested equity. Make the _rate_ of vesting roughly match the [responsibility split / contribution to value / endurance of risk] going forward. If the positions are roughly CEO / COO or CEO / CRO, his rate could be 25-50% of yours (corresponding to a 15-35% of fully diluted grant).