Contempt is sometimes warranted. If the descriptions in the article are accurate (from the spitting to the running over with a car), contempt is absolutely the appropriate response and the kind of temporal relativism that denies that is wrong.
Re:Opposite of modern
by humanrebar on Thursday March 01, 2018 @06:49AM
(#16491254)
Scorn for spitting at strangers is warranted. Outrage at unpunished murder is appropriate.
Extrapolating those feelings to an entire people group is wrong. It's still possible to value people for the content of their character while tolerating their loafers and the style of hat they wear.
Yes and no. Individuals are of course responsible for their own actions. But individuals who choose to form a community that very deliberately lives in a particular way and sets itself apart from the rest of society, that choice is a reflection of their character - indeed it's a decision I expect they would say they wanted to be judged by. And at that point it's fair to judge them on the overall societal consequences of their chosen way of living, positive and negative.
Re:Opposite of modern
by celticninja on Thursday March 01, 2018 @07:16AM
(#16491389)
Nobody's hat ever intended me harm because I chose to wear a different hat.
Re:Opposite of modern
by humanrebar on Thursday March 01, 2018 @08:35AM
(#16491796)
Yep. And we can't blame Jacob for the sins of Benjamin just because they wear the same hat.
Re:Opposite of modern
by celticninja on Friday March 02, 2018 @08:27AM
(#16501176)
Correct, but whatever hat you wear if it talks to you and tells you to do stuff you should probably ignore it and seek medical advice.
Re:Opposite of modern
by codingdave on Thursday March 01, 2018 @06:44AM
(#16491235)
It may be warranted, but it is not productive. If you really want change, you need to understand the reasons behind people's culture and actions, and have an open dialogue about those reasons.
Re:Opposite of modern
by humanrebar on Thursday March 01, 2018 @06:52AM
(#16491262)
Agreed. If we think conversation and reason do not solve problems, we have, to some degree given up on democracy based on universal suffrage.
If we think we can't reason with people, we start thinking elections are illegitimate. After all, if people are that unreasonable and easily to manipulate, elections are only about who is lucky and has better psychological tricks on their side.
As with any other bad thing people do, our response should include compassion and understanding - but it should also include clear condemnation. Sometimes telling people bluntly that their culture and actions are wrong and unacceptable in this day and age is the productive line, e.g. the Pitcairn sexual assault trial was seen as cultural imperialism at the time, but from interviews now one gets the impression it ultimately resulted in a substantial positive change.
Re:Opposite of modern
by annabellish on Thursday March 01, 2018 @07:35AM
(#16491453)
You can, and often must, understand the reasons behind people's actions while still condemning them - but you should condemn the actions, not the people.
Re:Opposite of modern
by AllegedAlec on Thursday March 01, 2018 @08:28AM
(#16491732)
Why? If people make condemnable actions, they become condemnable themselves.
Which is preferable to you. That those people be punished appropriately for their actions but continue to believe that they were justified; or that those people are genuinely persuaded they were wrong, repudiate their former beliefs and actions and work to undo the damage.
Personally I believe in both, where criminality is concerned. Appropriate sanctions and rehabilitation are the ideal. For non-criminal prejudice and discrimination, I think the latter is perfectly acceptable.
Only if you hold the same content for equally-backward Christian, Muslim, Hindu, etc fundamentalists.
Of course.
Re:Opposite of modern
by MichaelMoser123 on Thursday March 01, 2018 @11:33PM
(#16499045)
all the Hasidim are to be blamed for this as a group? (Some other guy will tell you that all the Jews are to be blamed as well) I think blaming a group as a whole had a name - bigotry.
As CS Lewis would call it, chronological snobbery:
> Barfield never made me an Anthroposophist, but his counterattacks destroyed forever two elements in my own thought. In the first place he made short work of what I have called my “chronological snobbery,” the uncritical acceptance of the intellectual climate common to our own age and the assumption that whatever has gone out of date is on that account discredited. You must find why it went out of date. Was it ever refuted (and if so by whom, where, and how conclusively) or did it merely die away as fashions do? If the latter, this tells us nothing about its truth or falsehood. From seeing this, one passes to the realization that our own age is also “a period,” and certainly has, like all periods, its own characteristic illusions. They are likeliest to lurk in those widespread assumptions which are so ingrained in the age that no one dares to attack or feels it necessary to defend them.