[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_famine_of_1932%E2%80%93...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kazakhstan_famine_of_1932%E2%8...
Between 15% and 42% of the entire Kazakh population died in this same fell swoop. Essentially, grain silos that the (Ukranian, Russian, Kazakh, [insert peasant population and Republic]) peasants had reserved to feed themselves during a year that had poor crop yields had been previously taken by force to feed people in cities. When the very harsh winter of '32-33 came, that meant death of starvation for all these peasants, of all these nationalities. The breadbaskets of USSR (Ukraine and Kazakhstan) had a particularly high concentration of peasants, and therefore, particularly high death rate.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Duranty https://www.nytco.com/new-york-times-statement-about-1932-pu...
"Overall, Marxism is a tiny minority faith. Just 3% of professors accept the label. The share rises to 5% in the humanities. The shocker, though, is that as recently as 2006, about 18% of social scientists self-identified as Marxists"
http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2015/03/the_prevalence_1...
> Conservatives always complain that liberals “deny human nature”
> But here I have to give conservatives their due. As far as I can tell, Marx literally, so strongly as to be unstrawmannable, believed there was no such thing as human nature and everything was completely malleable.
So, it is possible Marx's economic prescription came out of his social diagnosis
Marx predicted an uprising in England from Factory Workers, not in agricultural Russia and it was a big source of head scratching for Marxists at the time. The Bolshevik Revolution was at odds with Marxist theory. (Which doesn't mean he was wrong with his description of capitalism at the time)
At least read the wikipedia ( https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Marxism ) page before attempting to disparage a theory with strawmans.
The other obvious rejoinder to the parent comment is that if Stalinism is "Marxism in practice", than in equal measure the wholesale genocidal slaughter of millions of Native Americans, Koreans, Vietnamese, Latin Americans, Iraqis etc. carried out by the United States can be said to be capitalism in practice, not to mention the century plus of horrific atrocities committed by the capitalist nations of Western Europe and East Asia (of course, many Marxists would say that this is exactly right).
Marx had a different definition of freedom than is understood by liberals and democratic leftists. He used phrases like "dictatorship of the proletariat" unironically.
Basically it's the autobiography of Malcolm Muggeridge, who grew up in a socialist background, becomes a journalist and goes over to Stalin's USSR to report on the amazing new progress being made, only to realize just how false all the reports are -- and what's more, how unwilling his target audience would be to hear it:
[quotes from the review]
>although it is clear to him that the Soviet economy is struggling, every dispatch they are given to send home declares that things are better than ever, that the Workers’ Paradise is even more paradisiacal than previously believed, that the evidence is in and Stalinism is the winner. It doesn’t matter what he makes of this, because anything he writes which deviates from the script is rejected by the censors, who ban him from sending it home. He is reduced to sending secret messages at the bottoms of people’s suitcases, only to find to his horror that even when they successfully reach the Guardian offices back in Britain, his bosses have no interest in publishing them because they offend the prejudices of its progressive readership.
[...]
>His final break with the rest of the enlightened progressive world comes when he decides to do something that perhaps no other journalist in the entire Soviet Union had dared – to go off the reservation, so to speak, leave Moscow undercover, and see if he can actually get into the regions where rumors say some kind of famine might be happening. The plan goes without a hitch, he passes himself off as a generic middle-class Soviet, and he ends up in Ukraine right in the middle of Stalin’s Great Famine. He describes the scene – famished skeletons begging for crumbs, secret police herding entire towns into railway cars never to be seen again. At great risk to himself, he smuggles notes about the genocide out of the country, only to be met – once again – with total lack of interest. Guardian readers don’t look at the newspapers to hear bad things about the Soviet Union! Guardian readers want to hear about how the Glorious Future is already on its way! He is quickly sidelined in favor of the true stars of Soviet journalism, people like Walter Duranty, the New York Times‘s Russia correspondent, who wrote story after story about how prosperous and happy and well-fed the Soviets were under Stalin, and who later won the Pulitzer Prize for his troubles.
[0] http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/08/11/book-review-chronicles-...
For sheer horror of life in worker's paradise, I think Varlam Shalamov's [0] Kolyma stories are much better written.
Thanks for the link; I'll look it up.
You're welcome. Haven't really checked if translations of Shalamov into English are any good, but originals are. Not something you would read for pleasure though.
It's also shocking, though, how unaware we are of atrocities committed by Western powers. It is difficult, for example, to understate the culpability of the British Empire, and its economic system in Ireland's Great Famine.
Much like the Holodomor, it was an engineered famine - there was no shortage of food - it was just not very evenly distributed. The free market, and British colonial policy proved itself to be highly effective at providing a solution to the "Irish Question"[1] - which involved killing a quarter of Ireland's population.
Utter contempt for human life is a function of power, not of economic system.
Just like how the Soviet Union had a communist economy, how it had enough food to feed everyone, ergo, people blame Communism for the famine.
That is a non-sequitur. What makes you think “the free market” caused the famine?
The problem was that exporting food to England was more profitable then selling food domestically. The reason that the Irish poor ate potatoes was not because they were forbidden from other food, but because that was all they could afford.
The invisible hand of the market, and the very visible hand of Parliament was content to see a million people starve to death.
Note that one of the causes of the Holodomor was the Soviet Union exporting food during the famine. History repeats itself.
I posit that painting both anti-communists and communists as ideologues and rejecting both arguments is a false equivalence since communism is an extreme.
To provide another example it's similar to saying "Anti-Nazis and Nazis are both ideologues, neither of their arguments should be listened to. "
I didn't claim you were a mod, I said you were effecting the tone of a mod ("Please don't..."), which you were.
> [I'm] wishing that the article posted didn’t trigger so many people’s so many people’s pro/anti-communism kneejerk.
At the time I replied to you, you and gnarbarian made up half the comments here, yet neither you were discussing the article. Your own posts were simply about the Holocaust, Holodomor, Mao, Hitler, etc.
The entire thread from gnarbarian's original post on should be nuked.
0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor