News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by clarkmoody on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:06PM (#16467425)
I also believe in Bitcoin, but there may be a case against legitimacy at this point in the game: future changes to the protocol might become subject to state scrutiny.

Scenario:

(a) Regulators approve Bitcoin for use in banking, let's say

(b) Some change is proposed to the Bitcoin protocol, improving privacy

(c) Regulated firms are not able to do proper KYC/AML stuff if the upgrade activates

(d) Firms and regulators (and maybe legislators) push back against the upgrade

Now you have core protocol changes subjected to the scrutiny of the broader political process, which would be a total nightmare and may permanently stop development of the protocol.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by mihaifm on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:06PM (#16468496)
Ultimately I think that's one the big issues with crypto. Even though most altcoins boast decentralization, their development is only controlled by a few people who have commit rights to the git repository. When someone disagrees with them, it usually ends up in forking a new currency. Perhaps someone with more experience in the crypto space can shed some light on this...is there a way to truly decentralize development as well?
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by cdiddy2 on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:31PM (#16469155)
The only coin really trying to tackle this governance problem is Cardano in my opinion. Charles Hoskinson does a great job explaining their goals with this.

https://youtu.be/Ja9D0kpksxw?t=33m39s

https://youtu.be/cfD6efJ7KHA?t=9m56s

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by Forbo on Monday February 26, 2018 @09:37PM (#16470708)
Both Decred and Gridcoin have governance voting built in.
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by xur17 on Tuesday February 27, 2018 @01:47AM (#16471546)
And Tezos.
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday February 26, 2018 @01:33PM (#16467701)
> core protocol changes subjected to the scrutiny of the broader political process, which would be a total nightmare and may permanently stop development of the protocol.

It could be argued this would be a good thing.

As it stands, if someone nabs your crypto you have no means of recourse, this is a bad thing.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by tobltobs on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:02PM (#16467959)
How do you want to solve this problem without giving up decentralization?
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday February 26, 2018 @05:58PM (#16469745)
I don't.

I'm pro-centralisation in the sense that it comes with regulatory protections that are a net good for the average person, in my opinion.

If decentralisation comes with the risks that cryptocurrencies presently present, I'm not really interested.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by clarkmoody on Monday February 26, 2018 @08:11PM (#16470393)
The most important aspect of cryptocurrency is censorship-resistance, accomplished through decentralization.

Reading your comment, I don't know why you would be interested in cryptocurrency at all.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by vkou on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:32PM (#16468229)
The answer is that you can't, but that's not an answer liked by the people who:

1. Are optimistic about bitcoin.

2. Want to see it be useful for something besides speculation.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by SilasX on Monday February 26, 2018 @02:53PM (#16468379)
You have the same recourse that you would if someone took your physical cash, which Bitcoin seeks to mimic properties of. Do you make the same arguments against physical cash, or is there some other substantive difference, are you singling out Bitcoin?
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by JumpCrisscross on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:14PM (#16468570)
> You have the same recourse that you would if someone took your physical cash

People don't speculate in physical cash. Also, cash being physical constrains the speed at which it can move. It also makes things like cameras useful.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by SilasX on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:25PM (#16468658)
I don't see the relevance of those points to the distinctions being made on this thread?
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by JumpCrisscross on Monday February 26, 2018 @03:47PM (#16468828)
The amount of time the average person holds cash is small. It is held for transactional purposes. Investments, on the other hand, are held for long periods and not necessarily closely watched. (Most people also have more in investments than petty cash.) TL; DR The risks associated with cash are acceptable for a transactional medium; less so for an investment (hence the decline of bearer bonds in common use).
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by SilasX on Monday February 26, 2018 @04:32PM (#16469164)
Yes, I understand the difference between the uses of cash and investments. To repeat, I was asking you to relate it to the earlier discussion. To summarize, it went like this:

A: Regulator influence on Bitcoin would be good, as it makes theft easier to reverse.

B: But how would you do that while keeping the decentralization?

C: You can't. But no one likes to hear that if they're optimistic about Bitcoin and think it can be use outside of speculation.

Me: Cash has the same theft-irreversibility issue, with the same tradeoff against centralization. What's the difference?

I was asking how your comment was relevant to that exchange, not for a second way to restate what you already said. I was confused because your followup comment did not have any clear relationship to that exchange, about the tradeoffs between utility, reversibility, and decentralization. To quote your comment, with remarks about the relevance:

>People don't speculate in physical cash.

How is it relevant that people don't speculate in physical cash? The fact that people don't speculation in physical cash doesn't mean people only speculate in Bitcoin.[1]

>Also, cash being physical constrains the speed at which it can move.

How is it relevant that cash has this constraint? That would be a point in favor of bitcoin in the context of the above discussion, and would lower the burden for proving utility.

>It also makes things like cameras useful.

I don't see the relevance of this either.

So, again, I'm asking how your comment relates to the discussion that just happened. It seemed like you were just dropping in to make a general "why bitcoin is bad" argument, which is why I asked how the comment was relevant. I still don't see it. Can I assume there was no relationship, and you just saw it as an opportunity to say why bitcoin compares favorably to cash?

[1] The comment only works if you assume Bitcoin is only used for speculation, which would be assuming your conclusion.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday February 26, 2018 @05:54PM (#16469719)
> B: But how would you do that while keeping the decentralization?

Nobody (in the general sense) actually cares about decentralization; it serves no utility in and of itself. People only care about the ability to easily transact regardless of borders.

> Me: Cash has the same theft-irreversibility issue

I'd argue this isn't entirely correct. A cash holder can insure against theft of cash kept on premises, and in transit to a deposit facility; professional services can be hired to transport cash. As far as I'm aware these protections don't exist for cryptocurrency

> The comment only works if you assume Bitcoin is only used for speculation

At this stage it appears to me that is it's only (major?) legitimate use. Other uses probably include money laundering, and the exchange of value between parties involved in illegal activities, or for the purposes of evading regulations.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by SilasX on Monday February 26, 2018 @06:04PM (#16469794)
Your first and third points are refuted by Wikileaks: it's legal to contribute to them, but centralization made it possible for the US government to apply financial chokeholds to US banks that it made it impossible for Americans to do so electronically. So yes, if you care about using a currency to "transfer value to legal recipients who are far away", then you would care about centralization and its ability to prevent that capability.

>A cash holder can insure against theft of cash kept on premises, and in transit to a deposit facility; professional services can be hired to transport cash. As far as I'm aware these protections don't exist for cryptocurrency

You're referring to an optional add-on to cash that is not inherent to it. The act of holding cash does not automatically get you the protection of someone replacing it when you're mugged, and neither does Bitcoin have automatic replacement.

There do exist services that will thusly insure cash. But there's no inherent reason why it can't be provided for bitcoin too, it's just that the market isn't bit and mature enough for people to have sought it out (though Coinbase claims to have it).

In any case, the whole issue of "insurance in transit" is kind of obviated for an electronic currency too, at least with respect to physical theft.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by cgmg on Wednesday February 28, 2018 @12:35AM (#16480921)
> Nobody (in the general sense) actually cares about decentralization; it serves no utility in and of itself.

What evidence do you have to support this ridiculous claim? The vast amount of interest in cryptocurrencies seems to indicate otherwise, not to mention the use of all kinds of decentralized cryptographic protocols.

Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by s73v3r_ on Monday February 26, 2018 @05:11PM (#16469443)
Someone taking my physical cash means they have to actually come to me, or come to my home which has security cameras.
Re:Goldman-Backed Circle Buys Digital Exchange Poloniex by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday February 26, 2018 @05:59PM (#16469752)
Or your business, which would probably (should?) have insurance against cash theft; time-delay safes; and professional cash transport services.