News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm a Coors man by fragmede on Monday August 30, 2010 @10:42AM (#1646299)
Yes of course Guinness sticks out. Guinness is the only Irish dry stout in the list which is a different product entirely, once you're discussing beer. To non-beer drinkers they are all lumped into the 'beer' category, but that's unfortunate point to illustrate because that cool new web startup? In the same hyperopic view, they're all websites, and Hipmunk is the same as Wikipedia is the same as Techcrunch and you need an advertising budget the size of Google or Microsoft's to build stand-alone brand awareness
Re:I'm a Coors man by dmix on Monday August 30, 2010 @10:48AM (#1646323)
The point of the experiment was to demonstrated how the brand affected how the different beers stood out.

The fact that Guinness stood out was just there to show that without a brand you need to be significantly different (in this case, different tasting) in order to stand out.

Re:I'm a Coors man by bmelton on Monday August 30, 2010 @11:17AM (#1646415)
But Guinness isn't all that unique... for a Stout. It's unique compared to the other beers listed, just as if the comparison were done with Wikipedia, Dictionary.com, TechCrunch and Youtube. There are obvious differences in scope and purpose between the first three, but mainly, they're websites with mostly text, whereas Youtube is a website with mostly video. In a 'website' comparison, YouTube would be the standout, but if you did a more specific comparison between Break, YouTube, Vimeo and RedTube, you might find that RedTube is the standout, and YouTube fares on average with the others.
Re:I'm a Coors man by zokier on Monday August 30, 2010 @12:06PM (#1646573)
Yes, of course Guinness sticks out. But that is predictable, so it kinda gives some kind of scale. When people know the brand, they rate Colt 45 and Guinness approximately to the same distance from Budweiser. And that is the point of the article imho.