Re:Why 3.5M Americans in their prime years aren’t working
by dang on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:35PM
(#16454863)
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment is one that teaches us something."
Re:Why 3.5M Americans in their prime years aren’t working
by NumberSix on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:28PM
(#16454811)
Asteroid is discovered in deep space heading for Earth. Astronomers watch the asteroid approach Earth. Asteroid hits New York City. Millions die. Astronomers and media report:
"Asteroid from deep space kills millions. Asteroid causes death of millions."
No experiment is possible. Causation is clear.
Re:Why 3.5M Americans in their prime years aren’t working
by curuinor on Saturday February 24, 2018 @02:30PM
(#16454826)
I'm sorry to be seeming to make a straw man, but do you actually in sober thought think that economics is as well-understood as physics?
Re:Why 3.5M Americans in their prime years aren’t working
by craftyguy on Saturday February 24, 2018 @03:13PM
(#16455114)
Did you just post a rebutal to your original comment calling for 'experiments'? If economics is as mysterious as you say, how can you design experiments that produce verifiable and reproducible results?
Re:Why 3.5M Americans in their prime years aren’t working
by curuinor on Saturday February 24, 2018 @03:53PM
(#16455343)
Physics has had a lot of predictive power: economics hasn't. "Asteroids are incredibly powerful" is a physical statement, and a physical statement of causation that you can only make because physics is better-understood.
With exceptions, physical statements have predictive power. With exceptions, economic statements don't. So that's why I say that causality in economics is not generally understood.
You can have natural experiments, but I don't see any. Did they try kidnapping Congress and forcing them to do a total embargo on China? Seems a no.