News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by kuon on Thursday February 22, 2018 @01:44PM (#16440136)
Realistically, what is the feasibility of a space catapult? I mean, the speed at ground level to be able to reach orbit must be insanely high, no? This high speed in a thick atmosphere would cause all kind of heating problem on the catapult itself and the "rocket". I wonder what would be the actual numbers.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:26PM (#16442084)
Launch from near the equator, high in the mountains? Chimborazo, Ecuador? At 6000 feet, its half the air pressure of sea level, and 1/4 the atmosphere to travel through. And accessible. A good start?

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Chimborazo/@-1.4685873,-79...

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by jsmthrowaway on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:34PM (#16442161)
Going to space is not entirely about being high. It's about going sideways, fast.

And if, at 6,000 feet, air pressure were half that of sea level, nobody would live in Denver and most Tibetans would be dead. Half is more like 6,000 meters.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by notahacker on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:46PM (#16442271)
Chimborazo is >6000m above sea level tbf and not 6000ft as the OP suggested. It's actually the furthest point from the Earth's centre (the earth's shape gives it a boost over mountains which are higher above sea level but further from the equator)

For related reasons, its difficult-to-reach, low oxygen, snow-covered summit is not ideally suited for building and maintaining a space launch site.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by 205guy on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:44PM (#16442704)
I came to mention this as well. I wish more people would look at all the factors before saying "X elevation and Y latitude is what we need, therefore this place fits the bill." Given the active volcanoes and weather in Ecuador, you'd be lucky to find a road and suitable launch complex site over 4000m.

And then there is this whole science and tech imperialism. Maybe Ecuadorans don't want roads and launch complexes cut out of their high mountains. Hawaii is going through this issue right now with new telescopes on Mauna Kea, and Ecuador has a strong indigenous rights movement, including the party in power at times.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:56PM (#16442344)
"Not ideal" may overlap with 'tremendously cheap' if the SpinLaunch 10-100x cost factor is true. So a few oxygen masks may be worth the trouble. And a highway goes within a few miles of the peak right now.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by notahacker on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:57PM (#16442784)
I've been on that highway. Trouble is you're still a few thousand metres of relatively technical climbing or a helicopter ride away from the top. I mean, people can work in some pretty inhospitable conditions if the cost advantages are real, and the payloads you've got to get up there have to be relatively comfortable with being moved to get fired into space anyway, but it's hard to imagine anything on a Cape Carnaveral scale happening there even if Ecuador decides the dollars from supporting space programmes are worth more than the scenery and symbolism
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by wallace_f on Friday February 23, 2018 @02:48AM (#16444859)
I came across the idea of launches from Ecuador while reading about spaeflight. IIRC, I assumed 3,000m launch (assumed a suitable site near Quito exists), and calculated a disappointing, less-than 10% increase in payload, assuming a BFR as the launch vehicle. However, for a kinetic energy launcher, or small rocket like the new record-settinf Japanese SS-520, that improvement would be a lot larger (and more importantly, the logistics a lot easier!).

The thing is, with rocket size increasing, payload increases cubically while air resistance is squared. So for the really big rockets, altitude is not as big of a factor as being near the equator.

If I am not wrong, propulsive landing on drone ships uses another roughly 10% fuel (depends on launch trajectory, etc).

As fossil fuels are non-renewable, and Hydrogen expensive, I am very sure (and even hope to be correct) that in the future we will see launches from high-altitude equatorial regions, using booster-capture technologies and perhaps even terestial-power-assisted launches. Those things may reduce the fuel-cost of escape velocity by 30+%, and when we're sending enough stuff into orbit that this is too advantageous to ignore, we will do it.

But for now, the best way to go is to get really good at building bigger rockets.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by neaanopri on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:43PM (#16442232)
Atmospheric density decreases exponentially with height.

Total impulse required to blow through drag forces is a nasty nasty power law.

It wouldn't be that difficult to make a linear rail launcher in a vacuum, or on the moon. Air resistance really is the whole problem.

If you can put the launcher above the atmosphere, it's 100% worth the effort.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by jsmthrowaway on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:47PM (#16442275)
> Atmospheric density decreases exponentially with height.

I'm aware. That's the math I did in my comment, solving for 0.5 atm.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by ceejayoz on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:48PM (#16442291)
The comment you're replying to mixed up meters and feet. The mountain is 6,000 meters, not 6,000 feet.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:51PM (#16442308)
Right; sorry
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by ceejayoz on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:41PM (#16442223)
Getting high quickly is important, which is why launch vehicles go up first, then do a gravity turn in thinner air, reducing drag and aerodynamic pressures on the vehicle. It's hard to go horizontally fast when you're fighting thick atmosphere.

Air density at the top of Everest is 1/3 of sea level, and because of the Earth's shape, Chimborazo's 20,000 feet (6,000 meters) is actually further from the Earth's center than Everest, so half pressure sounds pretty reasonable: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=942816...

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by 205guy on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:37PM (#16442653)
What you're forgetting is that the same mechanics that make Chimborazo the furthest from the earth's center (the oblate spheroid shape due to spin) also applies to the atmosphere (though probably to a different degree). So over Chimborazo, the atmosphere is also thicker, I'd imagine (could be more, could be less). I haven't looked at the actual measurements, but you might want to before you compare different latitudes. Also, see my other comment for non-engineering difficulties.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:51PM (#16442753)
Ok the troposphere is 4 miles up at the poles, and 12 miles up at the equator. So 6000m (about 3.6 miles) is not even half of 12. Still, its half-pressure. But you have 8 miles to go to get out of it. So maybe somewhere halfway? Seattle? There the troposphere is 6 miles up; Mt Rainier is 2 miles high. Maybe a better deal?
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:52PM (#16442314)
Near the equator you have the earth's rotation going for you. Launch to the east, and start out at 1000mph. A good start indeed!
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by dtparr on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:18PM (#16442504)
I mean, sort of. That's less than 6% of the dv you need to get to LEO. If this thing can only add another 3k mph we're still at less than a quarter of the dv needed to get to space today. It might make a reasonable 'first stage' if they can work though the tech needed to get to that 3k without destroying the payload, but it doesn't sounds like it's capable of anything resembling a complete 'launch system' for things wanting to go to space.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:25PM (#16442554)
They give only 'hypersonic speeds' as a metric. That's 4000-8000mph approximately. So not there yet. But don't knock a free 1000mph! Launching to the west means you have to add 1000mph to be standing still, orbit-wise.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by dtparr on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:56PM (#16442777)
The article specifically says:

>All that momentum is then harnessed to catapult a payload into space at speeds one source said could be around 3,000 miles per hour.

So that's what I was working off of. Admittedly, it's unclear who that source is. And 8k is still less than half of LEO.

And right, I'm familiar with orbital mechanics and would never turn down free dv, but you get ~90% of that even out of somewhere as far off the equator as CCAFS. The bigger benefit would be if you're looking to launch into a low inclination (equatorial) orbit you can avoid the dv required for the plane change, but that would work just as well out of CSG.

The altitude itself would be the only advantage I could see over somewhere like CSG.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by ridgeguy on Friday February 23, 2018 @01:27AM (#16444625)
Actual numbers, haven't tried to calculate.

But the heat load due to atmospheric friction would be immense and immediate.

The US built an antiballistic missile system that included a missile called Sprint [1]. It accelerated at 100G and developed temperatures of over 3000°C less than 5 seconds after launch. A video here [2].

It's a formidible engineering challenge to make a vehicle and payload that will survive such a difficult flight regime with commercially attractive economics. At this point, I don't understand SpinLaunch's advantage over earlier projectile systems (Gerald Bull) or current launchers like SpaceX. This will be interesting to follow.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msXtgTVMcuA

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by olliej on Friday February 23, 2018 @03:52AM (#16445073)
Worst case scenario the missile blows up on launch leveling the surroundings before the enemy missiles arrive, thus stealing the sense of achievement from them ;)
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by tensor_rank_0 on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:53PM (#16442318)
if we assume our desired orbit to be at an altitude of 320 kilometers and our orbital velocity to be 7 kilometers per second; and we assume that air resistance decreases as a proportion of the cube of velocity inside the troposphere, proportional to the square of velocity inside the stratosphere, proportional to velocity inside the mesosphere, and discount air resistance above the mesosphere, we can begin to set up a differential equation to solve the problem.

I'll be back, if anyone wants to follow along at home, post your answers when you are ready.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by rmcpherson on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:21PM (#16442049)
Not to mention the acceleration needed to achieve orbital velocity with a catapult. Seems like insanely high forces on the payload. I’d love to see how they solve this.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by pesmhey on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:28PM (#16442112)
It’s a centrifuge, so the acceleration could be low enough to not cause damage to the payload.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by ecpottinger on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:34PM (#16442166)
No it is not. Calculate the outward force of a centrifuge with 300 foot radius with a speed of 3000 MPH at the edge and you get a force of 2000G!

Check your own numbers at: http://www.calctool.org/CALC/phys/newtonian/centrifugal

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by mhandley on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:56PM (#16442341)
Yes, the centripetal acceleration only starts to get reasonable (ie less than 10g) with a 20km radius centrifuge. The only practical way to do that would be an evacuated circular tunnel equipped with a maglev. Maybe that's their solution?
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by justinpombrio on Thursday February 22, 2018 @08:17PM (#16443333)
> Yes, the centripetal acceleration only starts to get reasonable (ie less than 10g)

That's reasonable _for humans_. No one's going to launch a human by this thing, though, I hope.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by oh_sigh on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:07PM (#16442416)
That's starting to sound like a hyperloop now
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by abakker on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:30PM (#16442609)
Please let him be playing the long game.

Hyperloop, magnets, battery arrays, solar, boring company, etc sounds pretty cool.

Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by TipVFL on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:23PM (#16442536)
It would be pretty cool if Musk was using Hyperloop as a proving ground for technologies to build Hyperlaunch.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by maxxxxx on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:44PM (#16442247)
At around 50km radius you get 3g. That would be a pretty big centrifuge! Humans will probably never use this but maybe some types of satellites can handle the load.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by aventrix on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:07PM (#16442421)
Nevermind that 3,000 MPH is entirely too slow.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:32PM (#16442154)
Simply spinning is acceleration. Every been on a fast playground merry-go-round?
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by pesmhey on Thursday February 22, 2018 @05:41PM (#16442221)
Yeah, you’re right! Wonder how they handle it then.
Re:Space catapult startup SpinLaunch comes out of stealth by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 22, 2018 @06:01PM (#16442377)
You could embed the electronics in a resin - acceleration of a solid block would have fewer shear stresses inside the block.