News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by trophycase on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:31PM (#16431177)
I wonder how much of this stagnation can be attributed to fewer people performing "real work"... that is producing something that actually adds value. Just thinking of the sheer number of people and resources used in advertising, movie CGI, useless chat apps, etc. that are basically a net negative to real economic output, it makes me think that maybe these people are the ones getting paid with the productivity gains of those who produce real output.

Not trying to put anyone down here, it's just I can't see a lot of economic benefit in a team of 10 engineers modeling the hair of the next Assassin's Creed character... and where do you think this money comes from?

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by socalnate1 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:35PM (#16431728)
"Not trying to put anyone down here, it's just I can't see a lot of economic benefit in a team of 10 engineers modeling the hair of the next Assassin's Creed character... and where do you think this money comes from?"

Errr - doesn't it come from the people buying the Assassin's Creed games? That particularly series earns hundreds of millions of dollars each game, and at least some of that value is created by the engineers modeling the character's hair.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by jeffreyrogers on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:50PM (#16433283)
There's obviously a difference between industries like agriculture, oil and gas, steel-making, etc. and something like a game company. Some industries are crucial to the functioning of society, while others are a pleasant way to spend time.

The world would be culturally poorer without music, art, etc., but it would still function. That's not true if you got rid of those other industries.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by bluGill on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:33PM (#16432235)
Is that valuable? Sure it is work and effort and all that, but is it valuable? Would we be better off without movies and video games? There are many in the "bible belt" who will argue that we are (the Amish are the most famous but there are plenty of others).
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by PeterisP on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:46PM (#16433260)
If something creates zero value for many (most) people but some value to others, then yes, that is valuable.

If I get a haircut, that's not valuable to at least 7 billion people worldwide, but it is valuable to me, so it is some positive value created.

In a similar manner, if a million gamers like some game (or a satanic black metal song) and the whole of bible belt does not, well, that's a lot of positive value created anyway; assuming no actual negative externalities where someone else gets harmed by it. Individual value is subjective, but it can be aggregated - if you consider that playing a particular videogame has negative value and don't play it, then the impact is zero; if I consider that playing the same game has positive value to me and do it, then it adds a positive contribution to the global value created; I got something I liked, and that's valuable by itself, asssuming noone else got hurt by this.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by tpallarino on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#16432534)
The money earned from Assassin's Creed isn't by creating value, it's given by others who are creating value. I'm genuinely surprised I'm getting so many people disagreeing with this idea.
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by lovich on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:50PM (#16432859)
That's because the implication is that entertainment has no value, and that sort of argument can be reduced to absurdity. Do we really need any comfort? Sounds like the whole clothing industry other than wool and cotton shirt/pant producers are useless and even then only for what's needed in cold weather. Most dyes are useless,colors are only useful to write signage. The only cars that are useful are the ones that have the currently most fuel efficient setup. Do we really need safety features? We already have enough people and any dead ones can be replaced.

That's why the idea is being disagreed with

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by skookumchuck on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:19PM (#16432598)
The game purchases believe it has enough value to be worth exchanging their dollars for it.

Do you also believe the Rolling Stones didn't create any real value?

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by trophycase on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:32PM (#16432718)
Does getting people addicted to heroin add value? Because people will exchange their dollars for that too.

Just because people pay money for something doesn't mean it adds value or creates wealth. Rolling Stones is a tough case, some entertainment is necessary, but at what level and cost is up for debate, it's not like I have all the answers.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by PeterisP on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:37PM (#16433198)
Necessities is a fixed amount, wants are (nearly) boundless. As we are able to afford things beyond bare necessities, pretty much all value create and consumed isn't 'necessary' - it's one or other kind of comfort, desire, status, entertainment, etc. Those things do add value and do create wealth - if getting enough nutrients and bare minimum of shelter takes just 10% of my resources, then 90% of my wealth is something that's not necessary.

If people prefer hearing a song over getting an (extra) loaf of bread, then hearing that song is by definition more valuable (more valued by that person) as that loaf of bread. There's not much debate needed about Rolling Stones - millions of people have expressed their values, and their choices illustrate that the music of Rolling Stones is literally more valuable than a billion loaves of bread; people have intentionally allocated a billion bread-loaves worth resources towards Rolling Stones because they valued Rolling Stones more than other alternatives.

People paying money for something doesn't necessarily mean it adds value or creates wealth, there are all kinds of edge cases like fraud, exploitation, addiction, etc, but in general, in the vast majority of cases it does mean exactly that - if people genuinely freely wanted to pay money for something and did so, then that's very informative about what they actually value; this is far more informative and truthful than, for example, what they claim they value.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by skookumchuck on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:36PM (#16432748)
You're in a hopeless box trying to decide for other people what they should value and what they should not.
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by mfoy_ on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:35PM (#16431217)
If by "real work" you mean force time distance, then suuuure. The entire software industry does very little "real work", since it doesn't take very much force to move the keys on a keyboard only a little bit down.
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by trophycase on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @12:39PM (#16431252)
By real work I mean the process of actual wealth creation. I'm arguing that certain types of work are net positive wealth creation while others are net negative, meaning that more useful resources are consumed in the process of creating that good/service than the benefit to the system that this good/service provides.

Take my Assassin's Creed example. Consider all the electricity used to run their computers, the food and shelter needed for engineers and marketers, the raw materials needed for game parts and distribution. These resources are essentially burned or are outflows of the system, while providing very little inflow (that is directly or indirectly contributing to the creation of real wealth). The result is a net outflow of real wealth of the system.

As more and more people shift to such jobs, productivity gains in "net inflow" work will be partially distributed to those working in "net outflow" jobs.

I'm also not arguing that all software jobs are net outflow. Something like Google for example, could be argued as a net inflow, because fast information retrieval and distribution can greatly improve the overall efficiencies of the economic system.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by skookumchuck on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:17PM (#16432582)
> actual wealth creation

Actual wealth creation is creating things that other people want to buy. This applies to games as much as it does to food.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by mykull on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @10:25PM (#16434937)
Getting people to buy something doesn't always mean you provided them value. Some methods of making a buck are exploitative, like if they rely on deception, for example. There are scenarios where "middlemen" exist to take part of the wealth and not create any. Or where people are paid to be destructive for various reasons. A corrupt politician paid (in campaign donations, whatever) to pass a law to create a barrier to a market is being destructive, not constructive. It is a net loss overall.
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by quacked on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @01:41PM (#16431792)
What's your working definition of 'real wealth'?
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by trophycase on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:04PM (#16432965)
A little hand-wavy but I will try to give some sort of definition.

If we assume that wealth can be measured with a non-negative real number, then we will set the zero point of the scale at total human extinction. If we set such a zero point, then we will assume that moving away from zero, that is moving away from extinction, is moving in a positive direction. Therefore, anything which contributes to the robustness and stability of the system could be argued as "wealth" or "valuable".

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by stale2002 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @08:27PM (#16434474)
So you believe that the only thing that is valuable is increasing human survival?

What about quality of life? I could make everyone survive better by locking them up in a room, safe from all outside hazards. Is that valuable?

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by sigstoat on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @02:23PM (#16432129)
> ... movie CGI...

why draw the line at the special effects? why not just assert that movies and entertainment are a "net negative"?

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by trophycase on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:23PM (#16432632)
I wasn't drawing a line. You could argue that entertainment keeps people from going crazy and is a net positive to the efficiency of the system. Marvel CGI doesn't apply IMO
Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by jeffreyrogers on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @04:53PM (#16433311)
I don't understand why every post of yours in this thread it getting downvoted. I guess by downvoting you they can pretend that what you're saying isn't true.

Agriculture and manufacturing are the drivers of economic growth. Without them there's no point in having all those other industries.

Re:Technology Change Not the Culprit in Wages Falling Behind... by danbolt on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @10:54PM (#16435044)
I’m really surprised you’re being downvoted, even though I’m not quite sure you think art doesn’t have value. The value I receive from seeing a movie with a friend or playing a video game usually exceeds the dollars I spent for the entertainment.

I agree that making “things” that people “need” is a lot different though, and that’s reflected in their markets.