News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by nothis on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:37PM (#16394639)
It always saddens me how mathematicians seem to look down on “intuition”. Maybe higher math as a full-time job is just hard work and stubborn precision but for me, an intuitive, visual look is probably getting me closer to understanding than any cold-hard-facts book does. Not to mention how much easier it is to appreciate the beauty of it.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by gracenotes on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:54PM (#16396107)
You can take it from one of the most productive living mathematicians:

https://terrytao.wordpress.com/career-advice/theres-more-to-...

I recommend reading the entire post - it's not too long, and links to other great materials - but this is a good relevant quote:

> The point of rigour is not to destroy all intuition; instead, it should be used to destroy bad intuition while clarifying and elevating good intuition.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by eigenman on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:02PM (#16395569)
Mathematians (such as myself) don’t look down on intuition. It is the only way to construct a map through a complex proof.

However what you may have picked up on is we disstain people who insist they have a brilliant idea for which someone should prove they are right. That’s like saying a car engine consists of cyclinders and piston; someone else just needs to do the work to put the pieces together.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by dvt on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:17PM (#16396405)
> It always saddens me how mathematicians seem to look down on “intuition”.

They do this for good reason. I had to take, as part of my philosophy concentration, a bunch of mathematical logic classes. First Order and Second Order logic, as you might imagine, are pretty simple. The rules make sense in a very intuitive way. I'd get 100 on exams just because I'm good at programming. But when I had to study metalogic, model theory, Henkin Proofs, and Godel's Theorems, that intuition quite literally flies out the window. I guess my point is that most interesting stuff is rarely intuitive.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by goldenkey on Friday February 16, 2018 @06:34PM (#16397586)
That is ludicrous. The intuition is just harder to find, harder to grasp. But it is still there because these theorems are logical consequences of the base axioms. And the base axioms are logical consequences of our desire for sensible assumptions.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by dvt on Friday February 16, 2018 @07:07PM (#16397844)
This is provably untrue and all I need to do is think about how weird stuff gets when increasing dimensionality of "household" shapes like circles and squares. It literally goes against every intuitive fiber of my body.

If you think that coming up with theorems about, e.g. infinitary algebra, is intuitive, then I guess you're just a lot smarter than I am. Infinities always throw a wrench into our intuitions. Something being a "logical consequence" of something else is an incredibly simplistic way of looking at things, not to mention that I'm not exactly sure what that has to do with intuition anyway.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by sdenton4 on Friday February 16, 2018 @08:48PM (#16398347)
It /becomes/ intuitive with time, thought, and exposure, as you pick up more tools for understanding the problem space.

That 'non-intuitive' aspect of high-dimensional spheres having very small volume relative to a hypercube becomes a point that builds intuition for how those spheres behave, once you're familiar with it. And then you can start throwing out things that seem intuitively wrong, and following intuition towards new ideas.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by dvt on Friday February 16, 2018 @09:21PM (#16398507)
You just described the opposite of intuition.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by nickpsecurity on Saturday February 17, 2018 @01:27AM (#16399373)
Intuition is a part of the mind that makes approximate models based on experience up to that point. The experiences without anything that would help model infinites would make them non-intuitive. Experiences that would help model infinites would make them at least more intuitive. Experience with rational investigation of them going through examples is actually one way to do that. There's been organizations like Marine Corps incorporating intuition into training for a long time where they set out to program it using realistic scenarios in drills that people do over and over until the intuitive processes pick up the patterns/model. It will happen as many people study that topic as well.

The trick is that you need good data to feed it that makes the patterns clear. You might have not gotten a lot of that on the topic you had no intuition of. On some topics, there hasn't been much of an attempt to do that since people expect it to be hard with everyone forced to do the methods that are non-intuitive. Lots of traditions are like that. Then, there's the possibility something can't be intuitively handled at all. I don't know if those exist but they might. That many activities of people doing math seem to get an intuitive boost during their day-to-day work makes me lean towards intuitive possibilities for about everything that can be approximated (esp with heuristics).

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by dorkwood on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:22PM (#16402781)
A chess master can intuitively tell when mate is three moves away. They weren’t born with that intuition, though. They gained it over time.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by naasking on Saturday February 17, 2018 @04:10PM (#16402717)
You aren't born with all of your intuitions, you learn most of them. This includes mathematical intuitions.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by tashi on Friday February 16, 2018 @11:05PM (#16398926)
At this point a mathematician might step in and say that you all need to define your terms. You're basing your arguments on two subtly different definitions of the word "intuition."
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by dvt on Friday February 16, 2018 @11:44PM (#16399072)
The differences aren't subtle. I'm using the run-of-the-mill definition you might find in a dictionary[1], what other definition could you possibly be using?

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/intuition

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by emmelaich on Saturday February 17, 2018 @12:10AM (#16399162)
From that I would choose 2.c, with the emphasis on evident

> the power or faculty of attaining to direct knowledge or cognition without evident rational thought and inference

There is such a thing as developing your intuition.

I think your meanings are not qualitatively different.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by eftychis on Monday February 19, 2018 @04:39AM (#16411821)
It depends how you define intuition. Maybe we could define intuition as your personal "model" for making guesses on how things work.

Let's claim that writing a proof is similar to writing a program. You start from a state, your premise, and have your assumptions, input, which you process through a series of steps, maybe taking cases in between (branching) and return an output (hopefully True).

Then considering this correspondence, it will be fine to say that you, as a programmer, can guess the output/behavior/semantics of any program without running it. Similarly, a mathematician would be able to reach the conclusion that the theorem holds, without going through all the details of the proof.

Sure, in most cases you can, and as you get more and more experience and knowledge as a programmer you can say you improve your guesses. But this ends up backfiring with a good probability, when our model skipped a step, e.g. the interaction of two concurrent data structures.

Thus I don't think it is right to say "as you are able to know all axioms and rules of inference, you should be able to achieve perfect intuition". You can know the fundamentals of each layer on your stack and you would find it insane if one asked you to guess the output of any non-trivial terminating program.

Note also that the way of inference (logical consequences) can and does change (e.g. ZF vs ZFC).

() I may be misusing the word model here -- it is usually defined (at least to things I work with) as the interpretation of a theory that satisfies all theorems (inferences). () constructive proofs yes. No flame wars please :)

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by lostpathfinder on Friday February 16, 2018 @06:53PM (#16397749)
Working mathematician does derive his ideas from axioms, it is ridiculous perception of mathematical process. And axioms are not logical consequences of sensible assumptions, it is try and fail process, long historical process. Intuition in mathematics has nothing to do with common sense intuition. Respectfully.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by goldenkey on Friday February 16, 2018 @07:00PM (#16397803)
In abstract mathematics, one can choose any axioms one wants. To derive all kinds of consequences/theorems.

But respectfully, ZFC came about because of logical paradoxes that couldn't be accepted as consistent.

You can create a new number system and derive all kinds of consequences but the truth is, most mathematicians care more entirely about prime number theory on the naturals that are entirely based on counting.

Most of modern math is based on the natural numbers. You can't remove all intuition. The thread that holds our love for math is also the same one that tells us we are exploring consequences that tell us a dearth about our universe.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by adyavanapalli on Friday February 16, 2018 @07:07PM (#16397841)
You'll find that no such thing is true. Intuition is something you develop over time in mathematics, and mathematicians will often use this intuition to have certain "feelings" about problems e.g. a feeling that a certain conjecture must be true.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by pflats on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:16PM (#16395053)
There's nothing wrong with intuition, but intuition does not write proofs. It can help you write proofs, but you need more than that.

To pick an example:

Intuition is great for understanding the intermediate value theorem. If the temperature was 40 degrees at 8 am, and is 60 degrees at noon, it must have been 50 degrees somewhere in between.

Why, though? How can you guarantee that there will always have to be a time where it was 50 degrees[1]?

[1] provided that temperature is real-valued and temperature change is continuous, the debate of which I'll leave to the science people

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by tkzzbneig on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:04PM (#16395581)
Am I correct in understanding that it's not that intuition is invalid, but that it's insufficient for communicating a proof to another mathematician.

What I believe to be true is that a solid intuitive proof will be sound, but not necessarily transcribable until formalized. Formalization of the proof is essentially the matter of making a proof communicable.

Putting it one more way: purely-intuitive proofs would be just fine if one could share one's mental state with another.

What do you think?

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by JHonaker on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:36PM (#16395893)
The first senctence:

> Am I correct in understanding that it's not that intuition is invalid, but that it's insufficient for communicating a proof to another mathematician.

is close to correct. It's a very useful tool, but it can sometimes lead you into incorrect assumptions.

However, the rest of it incorrect. Math, and in particular, probability and statistics, are full of things that seem intuitive and easy at first glance, but are actually a bit more nuanced.

Take for example, the Monty Hall Problem. It's probably familiar to most here, but essentially you have three doors. Behind one, is a car or some other desirable object, and behind the other two are goats or something undesirable. Select a door, and you get whatever is behind that door. What's the probability of getting the car in this scenario?

Easy enough right? It's just 1/3. However, if Monty Hall opens one of the doors after you select a door, he always reveals a goat, and he offers to let you switch your door now, should you switch or keep your door?

What's the probability that you get a car if you switch? Is it 1/2 or 1/3? What's the probability that you get a car if you stay? 1/3?

Well, the somewhat surprising answer is that you have a 2/3 probability of winning the car if you switch, and a 1/3 probability of winning the car if you stay.

Often things will break down in the limits as well, so if you try to apply your finite dimensional intuition to something that corresponds to an empty object or an infinite number of objects, you'll find that you're often wrong.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by mkl on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:50PM (#16396056)
Not who you're asking, but I think that is incorrect. Intuitive explanations are how mathematicians usually communicate proofs to each other in person, when discussing mathematics. The receiving mathematician is convinced of the proof's validity if their own intuition and experience tells them that the nitty-gritty details can be formalised correctly.
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by gizmo686 on Saturday February 17, 2018 @12:34AM (#16399243)
>purely-intuitive proofs would be just fine if one could share one's mental state with another.

No, I have had purely intuitive proofs myself that turned out to be wrong.

Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by gowld on Friday February 16, 2018 @06:49PM (#16397719)
Intuition is not proof. We all have many intuitive ideas that are not actually true!
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by curuinor on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:16PM (#16395058)
what the hell kind of mathematicians have you been talking to, if they look down on intuition?
Re:How to Study Mathematics (2017) by gowld on Friday February 16, 2018 @06:48PM (#16397710)
> It always saddens me how mathematicians seem to look down on “intuition”.

citation?