News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by ransom1538 on Thursday February 15, 2018 @04:34PM (#16387862)
I always think of these two monkeys[i] when I consider slowing down my age.

[i] http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/medical_exa...

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by mysterypie on Thursday February 15, 2018 @06:31PM (#16388719)
It's an interesting well-written article, but you realize that their main point was that it contradicts the earlier calorie-restriction study: "The Nature authors found no increase in lifespan; the calorically restricted animals lived no longer, statistically, than their well-fed cousins."

They try to reconcile the studies: maybe it's the natural-ingredient foods vs the refined foods, maybe it's the generous diet vs the more-than-generous free-feeding, or conceding that the monkey's don't live longer, but they live healthier.

IMO, the best paragraph from the article was this: "Many of us simply roll our eyes and click away when yet another medical study contradicts the last study—so what else is new? Coffee’s bad for you, until it’s good for you—and so is red wine. Antioxidants are essential, or they’re useless. And so on."

Other than some very basic common sense things -- like don't eat rat poison -- I never find that these kinds of studies lead to correct and actionable information about how to slow down aging or how to lead your life. And it's extremely frustrating to even try.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by yongelee on Thursday February 15, 2018 @10:23PM (#16389621)
To even try? To try to exercise and not drink sodas is extremely frustrating? Living a healthy lifestyle is about simple choices like going to the gym or adding broccoli to your meal and avoiding junk food.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by mysterypie on Friday February 16, 2018 @03:24AM (#16390780)
> To even try?

Sorry, I should have been clearer. I meant, to even try to keep up with the contradictory medical studies.

Yes, you should exercise; that's a common sense thing I'm referring to. But trying to decide if things like calorie restriction really work in the face of conflicting studies is frustrating.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by mjlangiii on Friday February 16, 2018 @08:28AM (#16392141)
nutritionfacts.org was created for this reason, to consolidate the evidence from nutritional studies so that you don't have to.

spoiler alert - the comprehensive review lead them to the conclusion to eat plants, unprocessed.

But anyway, it is a nice resource to get a round up of studies on a similar topic.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by throwpupper on Friday February 16, 2018 @08:43AM (#16392222)
nutritionfacts.org is an extremely biased site that has been created by a vegan who built his whole career on speaking about health issues. While it has the word "facts" in its title nothing prevents them from cherry-picking studies to support their original views.

If you cherry-pick different studies you might actually find that consuming large amount of plants stresses our digestive system way more than a fatty steak with potatoes.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by cies on Friday February 16, 2018 @09:02AM (#16392335)
> If you cherry-pick different studies you might actually find that consuming large amount of plants stresses our digestive system way more than a fatty steak with potatoes.

You really, REALLY, believe with all information being out there nowadays that a diet of only "fatty steak with potatoes" will be healthier for humans that the "balanced WFPB diet" that is nutritionfacts.org claims is scientifically proven to be the healthiest?

I think you have nothing to back that up. Please cherry pick how you please and present your evidence.

Dr Greger, who started the non-profit nutritionfacts.org, is often attacked for being an ethical vegan. Since people reason that would impair his ability to present unbiased evidence. Though no-one has ever gotten beyond claiming he's cherry picking. I wish someone would describe a different diet that is as well supported by scientific evidence, as what nutritionfacts is doing for WFPB.

There is some scientific evidence building up in for the Keto diet. But that is --as far as I know-- not a diet for life.

On the other hand there is the raw diet movement (basically an uncooked WFPB diet), but that has little scientific and mostly anecdotal evidence.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by debacle on Friday February 16, 2018 @09:58AM (#16392730)
The keto diet's main difficulties are the prevalence and preponderance of available sugary foods, the near inability to eat socially, and the extreme difficulty in adopting the diet in the first 3 weeks for people regularly consuming 200g+ of carbohydrates a day.

The raw diet is mostly a trendy thing people write about. The bioavailability of nutrients in many raw foods is just too meh.

We know what the best diet is. A plant and fish based diet with small amounts of other meat. Meat that doesn't subsist on a diet primarily of corn or other, less edible things. This diet is completely unsustainable on a global scale and would result in even more ecological havoc.

The discussion between plants or plants + meat is complicated, but for now I'm going to ignore it because there's more important considerations:

- Companies are making our produce harder to digest as they try and make products with a longer shelf life.

- Eating industrially produced meat (of any sort) is very unhealthy and in many ways unsafe.

- This entire discussion removes dairy from the equation, which is a large part of the puzzle for most people.

- The low-carb vegan and the low-carb omnivore are far better off than anyone consuming 200g+ of carbohydrates a day.

- Hydroponically grown carrots taste gross.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by cies on Sunday February 18, 2018 @02:10PM (#16407612)
> We know what the best diet is. A plant and fish based diet with small amounts of other meat.

Nope. Fish (most fish) as a central part of diet, will contribute a lot to build up of heavy metals in humans. And what is "small amounts of other meat"? 3x per week? This is basically an omnivorous diet. Compared to the SAD is probably just the junk cut out.

This, SAD-processed, is a very unhealthy diet, compared to a balanced WFPB diet. There are lots of studies to back this up.

> - Companies are making our produce harder to digest as they try and make products with a longer shelf life.

Yups.

> - Eating industrially produced meat (of any sort) is very unhealthy and in many ways unsafe.

Not a problem for those eating WFPB.

> - This entire discussion removes dairy from the equation, which is a large part of the puzzle for most people.

Dairy is a killer. Prolly more so than meat.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3c_D0s391Q

> - The low-carb vegan and the low-carb omnivore are far better off than anyone consuming 200g+ of carbohydrates a day.

Any study on this?

There is a lot of studies (long running, with large size populations) claiming the opposite. Here some arguments: http://www.masteringdiabetes.org/ketosis-ketogenic-diets-mis...

> - Hydroponically grown carrots taste gross.

Personal taste. It prolly has less phytonutrients. Not sure how this is an important consideration.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by debacle on Monday February 19, 2018 @02:19PM (#16414992)
The site you linked is thick which propaganda which makes me doubt your bias and arguments. Choosing your sources is important for making a compelling argument.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by cies on Tuesday February 20, 2018 @01:58AM (#16418347)
One man's truth is another's propaganda, what are your sources? (I've shown mine, and I must say it's pretty convincing and lines up with what I already knew about the human body)

I'm not at all saying there's no use for keto, I just think it should never be a mainstream diet (but something applied in specific cases, under medical supervision). As far as sci evidence goes, WFPB seems to be the "best" diet for the human species as a whole.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by throwpupper on Friday February 16, 2018 @09:09AM (#16392378)
I never said that you should _only_ eat steaks and potatoes, did I?

This diet recommends a pound of fatty meat per day: http://perfecthealthdiet.com/the-diet/

The book that describes the diet cites over 1000 studies and empirical evidence to prove that the diet is healthy. Now who am I to believe?

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by cies on Friday February 16, 2018 @08:53AM (#16392287)
This website is seriously one of the best places to find science backed nutrition info. The advice comes down to: eat a balanced Whole Food Plant Based (WFPB) diet with a minimal supplementation regimen:

https://nutritionfacts.org/2011/09/12/dr-gregers-2011-optimu...

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by njarboe on Thursday February 15, 2018 @07:30PM (#16388998)
I think that individual genetics and behaviors are very important for these kind of health studies. Some things are quite clear and apply to all humans. For example: you need vitamin C in your diet or you will get scurvy. Then less general rules that might not apply to you given your genetics and behavior. Vitamin D supplements? Maybe, but probably won't hurt. Drinking Milk? Very variable on its benefits and costs to different people. Down to things that some people should do and others should not do depending on genetics and behavior (most studies these days).

Massive individual genetic testing and constant cellphone behavior monitoring might be able to produce decent studies in the future for your specific attributes, but for now advice from parents and grandparents may be the best you can do.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by sgt101 on Friday February 16, 2018 @02:55AM (#16390691)
Why would cell phone data help?
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by sgt101 on Friday February 16, 2018 @10:59AM (#16393223)
Genuine question... answers?
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by njarboe on Saturday February 17, 2018 @02:13AM (#16399485)
Most studies use self-reported behaviors for how people behave. More invasive studies (as some people have mentioned in this comment section) show that self reporting is inaccurate and, for example, people eat many more calories than they self report. If you have some system of automatic recording of behavior, which smart-phones might be able to do, and individual DNA results, then these large scale studies might be able to tease out what is healthy behavior for people with specific DNA.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by sgt101 on Wednesday February 21, 2018 @03:42AM (#16427929)
Thanks - is there any literature that you are aware of on this so I can get started?
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by njarboe on Sunday February 25, 2018 @12:22PM (#16459977)
Googling "problems with self-reporting in diet studies" gives a good listing of scientific papers for me. Of course such a search is screaming out "confirmation bias", but it is still useful I think. This[1] is one study that seems to cover what I was talking about, although I have not read it in full.

If you want to take a deep dive into a subject, search for a recent paper on the subject and as you read it the paper will reference other papers, especially in the introduction. Here is where you can find possibly a more relevant paper on the subject. Read that paper and repeat. Soon you will have a decent idea of what is going on in the field. Hard to do if you don't know the jargon and the mathematical methods though.

[1]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3025654/

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by mtgx on Friday February 16, 2018 @04:34AM (#16391080)
I don't know about the other studies, but I assume they were short-term? I think I remember one of them being only 3 months. That could have been the issue, as I believe calorie restriction leads to a slower metabolic rate. So if you need 2,000 calories, but eat 1,500 for a year, your body should get used to eating 1,500 and maintaining your weight (after losing some initially before it adapts to fewer calories).

But I believe intermittent fasting where you eat the same 2,000 calories but just shorten the window of eating to allow your body to crank-up the growth hormone and start autophagy does have long-term benefits, that should lead to prolonged life.

And of course, a calorie isn't a calorie. If you eat 200g of net carbs a day, intermittent fasting probably won't prolong your life too much, but it's also going to be more difficult to do IF when you're body is used to having high-levels of blood sugar and insulin in it.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by drcross on Thursday February 15, 2018 @09:57PM (#16389535)
>I never find that these kinds of studies lead to correct and actionable information about how to slow down aging or how to lead your life.

I think the modern life has maxed out as much life extension as we are going to get from our nutrition and lifestyle. We need to do interventional genetic modification to see any further improvements.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by truculation on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:16AM (#16390317)
>Other than some very basic common sense things -- like don't eat rat poison

Common sense is often mistaken. Here are two rat poisons which are also medicines:

Ergocalciferol -- a.k.a. Vitamin D2 (used as a supplement for many years; now D3 is preferred)

Warfarin -- oral anticoagulant widely in use today

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by somenewacc on Thursday February 15, 2018 @10:17PM (#16389593)
A single study will almost never be actionable, but a series of studies, accompanied by systematic reviews, could be the basis of such recommendations.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by greendestiny_re on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:56AM (#16390449)
>I never find that these kinds of studies lead to correct and actionable information about how to slow down aging or how to lead your life.

Don't salt your food _at all_ to maintain a healthy blood pressure.

>Furthermore, it also found that populations with low average daily salt intakes had low BP (blood pressure) and very little or no increase in BP with age. INTERSALT study indicates that BP increases with age only if accompanied by increased salt intake.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4105387/

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by evo_9 on Thursday February 15, 2018 @06:46PM (#16388808)
Yeah I have gone and done it, I have decreased my calories by roughly 30% in the past year or so and dropped around 30 pounds in the process, plus an aggressive vitamin and supplement routine, along with taking metformin. I also workout 7 days a week including playing hockey 2, sometimes 3 days (and also working out before or after), the group I skate with is highly skilled and the intensity is pretty up there, I've been skating with them for about 15 years or so.

I just turned 50 but am regularly assumed to be 36, the age everyone always guess... including by my gf's parents who are just a few years older than me. I am a rather crazy outlier though, I actually enjoy working out and do a hundred+ pull-ups a week, and even on my light workout days tend to do at least 20 or so just to loosen up a bit.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by d1zzy on Thursday February 15, 2018 @07:08PM (#16388909)
(this may be an unpopular opinion but...)

The problem with having a healthy lifestyle is that our lives aren't statistics. Big number theory does not apply, we only have one draw, one life and if it happens that we are one of those unlucky ones to get lung cancer while never having smoked or generally lead a healthy life then we still die within a year and there's nothing we can do about it.

Any drastic lifestyle change has costs: serious time, commitment, money and we sacrifice opportunities, things that we could be doing/enjoying instead. So my advice is: for anyone deciding to drastically change their lifestyle to a "healthier" one, do so for all the _other_ reasons (feeling fit and good, looking younger, improved relationships, having more energy, etc) but not expecting for that to increase your life span. Because then you may be up for a one nasty disappointment when cancer strikes and you are left wondering why did you do all that, why did you sacrifice so much. You better have a good answer when that happens is what I'm saying. :) (and that is true no matter what lifestyle you lead)

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by csallen on Thursday February 15, 2018 @08:30PM (#16389251)
I have two ways of thinking about death that I've found helpful.

The first is to sincerely imagine that I will die in 10 years. That's far enough away not to require drastic changes in my life — I still want to work hard on something that I'm passionate about — but close enough to remind me not to fuck around and take these years for granted. There's also a bonus that, if I do happen to run into some bad luck and have my life expectancy cut short, then it won't come as such a shock, because I've been living like it's my last decade anyway. And if that doesn't come to pass and I live a normal life, I'll feel more gratitude for it.

The second trick I use is to imagine that reincarnation is true, but that instead of "coming back" as plankton or a bug or another person, I come back as me and relive my life, over and over again, forever. In that situation, I'd want to optimize to have a great quality of life, and spend as little of it as possible worrying about my inevitable death, or agonizing over things that have gone wrong in my past. Since my rebirth is inevitable, I'd just be dooming myself to future agonizing. It sounds morbid, but I've found that this helps me to recover a bit when I feel down about something.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by andai on Thursday February 15, 2018 @09:35PM (#16389459)
What, if some day or night a demon were to steal after you into your loneliest loneliness and say to you: "This life as you now live it and have lived it, you will have to live once more and innumerable times more; and there will be nothing new in it, but every pain and every joy and every thought and sigh and everything unutterably small or great in your life will have to return to you, all in the same succession and sequence—even this spider and this moonlight between the trees, and even this moment and I myself. The eternal hourglass of existence is turned upside down again and again, and you with it, speck of dust!"

Would you not throw yourself down and gnash your teeth and curse the demon who spoke thus? Or have you once experienced a tremendous moment when you would have answered him: "You are a god and never have I heard anything more divine." If this thought gained possession of you, it would change you as you are or perhaps crush you. The question in each and every thing, "Do you desire this once more and innumerable times more?" would lie upon your actions as the greatest weight. Or how well disposed would you have to become to yourself and to life to crave nothing more fervently than this ultimate eternal confirmation and seal?

Friedrich Nietzsche, The Gay Science

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by csallen on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:06AM (#16390282)
Well damn.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by Waterluvian on Thursday February 15, 2018 @07:16PM (#16388945)
That's great. But that seems like a large commitment. I don't want to die at 70 but I also don't intend on spending my life thinking and working hard on prolonging it.

I'm kind of taking the 80 / 20 approach to living healthy. Don't smoke. Don't eat too too much. Sleep well. See the doctor each year. I'll let you know how it goes.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by sushid on Thursday February 15, 2018 @07:09PM (#16388920)
Are you taking metformin because you're prediabetic or because you think it can extend your life expectancy (or both)?

Don't you have problems keeping warm, sleeping, and maintaining muscle mass at that level of calorie deficit?

Also wondering what your supplementations are. I take Vit D, Zinc, pre/probiotics but having an aggressive vitamin routine isn't considered ideal these days.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by giardini on Friday February 16, 2018 @01:39AM (#16390387)
I told two diabetic friends about the results showing that metformin significantly reduced cancer. They looked at each other and then one said "I've got a closet full of that stuff; I never take it!" Turns out that neither were using metformin, but picked up their prescriptions religiously.

Next time we met they were both taking their metformin, although intermittently and apparently somewhat reluctantly. One of them was late for our meeting. In way of explanation he said that he had taken a metformin tablet just before driving off but, on the way, a fart proved to be untrustworthy: he had to drive back home and changed his pants.

I've heard the drug termed "metfartmin" b/c of its effects on the GI tract.

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by pmiller2 on Thursday February 15, 2018 @07:03PM (#16388887)
I'm assuming you're not diabetic, so how did you persuade a doctor to prescribe metformin?
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by HugoDaniel on Thursday February 15, 2018 @08:54PM (#16389326)
Did you try https://how-old.net/ ? It usually doesn't care about hurting your feelings.
Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by musha68k on Thursday February 15, 2018 @05:38PM (#16388424)
Thanks for sharing – always those poor monkeys though...

An even stronger data point to me would be the actual people of Okinawa who are (were?) among the healthiest and oldest in the world.

In addition to having a high quality diet and a rich social life in general, they are practicing “hara hachi bu” – the confucian tradition of always eating only until “about 80% full”.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hara_hachi_bun_me

Re:As we age, cancer rates go up as immune system winds down by baxtr on Thursday February 15, 2018 @04:41PM (#16387941)
This is really great! Thanks for the link. I think you should post it to HN