News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fall of Voodoo by oblio on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @11:35AM (#16377019)
In 1998 3dfx was incredibly dominant in the market. I don't think that after the release of Voodoo 2 many people would have bet on another company being the market leader. Riva TNT was ok, but it wasn't a breakthrough for Nvidia.
Re:Fall of Voodoo by rayiner on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @11:51AM (#16377151)
TNT was the first viable Voodoo 2 competitor, though it didn't quite catch up. The year after, NVIDIA released GeForce, which was indisputably better. 3dfx never recovered after that.
Re:Fall of Voodoo by oblio on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @11:55AM (#16377195)
3dfx also misread the trends. I remember something about them staying on 16 bit graphics for way too long.
Re:Fall of Voodoo by georgemcbay on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @09:17PM (#16381440)
Yeah, I was a pretty serious PC gamer (Quake/Q2/Q3) back during the rise and fall of 3dfx. Pretty much everyone I knew went from software rendering to 3dfx-chipset cards but then jumped ship when the Riva TNT2 cards came out, primarily because they just produced much better visuals due to support for 32-bit color while the 3dfx offerings were all limited to 16-bit.

There was still a bit of a split in the market back then between those who went TNT2 (amazing, at the time, image quality) and those who went to the Voodoo3 (good raw speed, but limited to 16-bit color and thus noticeable banding artifacts)... 3dfx still held on to a bit of a niche there for a while longer, but then once the GeForce and GeForce 2 came out 3dfx was just dead in the water with nothing that could compete anywhere on the performance versus image quality axes.

Re:Fall of Voodoo by rasz on Thursday February 15, 2018 @08:41AM (#16383877)
Color depth was never the problem, 3dfx used dithering comparable to ~22bit depth (according to company itself).

https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=36548

Texture memory capacity, texture size limit (256x256!) and lack of s3tc/DXT1 compression were the real culprit. TNT shipped with 16MB, in TNT2 32MB came standard. Texture quality played the biggest role in perceived visual difference. Not to mention TNT performance went 1/2 down in 32bit mode, TNT2 fared only slightly better.

Quality is great, until you learn both Nvidia and ATI repeatedly cheated in benchmarks and games dropping quality below old 3dfx limits. ATI Quake 3 was quite dramatic: https://techreport.com/review/3089/how-ati-drivers-optimize-...

Re:Fall of Voodoo by laumars on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @02:21PM (#16378495)
The year after the TNT was the TNT2 (which was a great chipset).

Geforce didn't come out until Oct 1999 and even then it was only one chipset. The rest of the product range came the following quarter (2000).

I skipped that generation and jumped to the Geforce 2 (this time first party rather than a 3rd party card with nvidia GPU), which was also an awesome card.

As for the fall of 3dfx, I dont think the rise in popularity of DirectX and OpenGL helped their case as that really levelled the playing field. After that, specifically targeting Voodoo cards felt more like a chore than an enhancement.

Re:Fall of Voodoo by theandrewbailey on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @08:01PM (#16381086)
> I skipped that generation and jumped to the Geforce 2 (this time first party rather than a 3rd party card with nvidia GPU)

Wait, nVidia made their own cards? I can't ever recall seeing one that wasn't made by a partner.

Re:Fall of Voodoo by pandaman on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @11:44PM (#16381967)
I had an NV-branded GF3, which was sold or given to developers since they had some issues with supplying enough chips to OEMs. Looked like this: http://www.ixbt.com/video/images/leadtek-tdh/geforce3-ref-fr... (and judging by the URL name it was made by Leadtek).
Re:Fall of Voodoo by georgemcbay on Wednesday February 14, 2018 @09:02PM (#16381384)
AFAIK, Nvidia have never fabricated their own cards, but they do design the reference boards that most OEMs use as a basis for their own cards, and they did at one point release cards directly under the Nvidia brand (the cards were fabricated by Foxconn using Nvidia's designs).
Re:Fall of Voodoo by laumars on Thursday February 15, 2018 @05:52AM (#16383102)
Yeah I had an nvidia branded Geforce 2. Didn't realise it was fabricated by a third party