There are meaningful comments, but usually people have to fill their review quota.
Lowest hanging fruit should be just an in-place edit that would be automatically retested and that a reviewee can easily take as a patch and check himself. Instead of the back and forth bullshit.
It's a bit funny that placing a red herring comment that anyone can safely comment on makes the workflow faster. It's like this story about an artist who would place something ridiculous so when the time comes the CEO would just say: "It's good, just remove the thing".
Usually, it is some combination of a and b. All cases are an indication of a deeper problem. None can be fixed by calling your "pull request" a "managed push" nor by giving people unrestricted access to pushing code. It's typically either a problem with communication or priorities/expectations.
Is this a typo for "willingness"?
Code review is important not just for preventing junk from entering the codebase but for ensuring that someone else has seen the thing and has some idea of how it works. I agree that "pull request" is the wrong terminology for a commercial environment.
For example, you mention waiting until the last minute and throwing away work. If this is such a big deal, maybe the units of work are too big or too loosely defined. Loosely defined as in "eh, we never needed this in the first place" or big as in "sorry about that but your 2000 LOC commit just isn't the right approach". Maybe github style reviews/pull requests are also not the best way to go about it. IMO the github style is pretty weird and shouldn't be conflated with reviewing in general.
At my current workplace, we use gerrit to review every commit. The only way that they'll ever get to master or a shared development branch is if they get a +2 vote. Maybe this is closer to a "managed push"? It's not rare that someone finds an issue, and when that happens it's very rare that it means scrapping the entire patch, and when that happens, it's usually a very small patch for a problem/feature that ended up being fixed elsewhere, so I definitely don't think it's a waste of time. Instead I am grateful that many of the patches didn't enter the codebase in their initial state.
What would you do different in "managed push"?
Erm ... GitHub is entirely proprietary!?
This is something I still struggle with. I think it's a result of an open source tool (GitHub) bringing bits of culture along with it.
In open source world, all contributions are entirely voluntary, and most follow the Benevolent Dictator For Life form of governance. So you do a bunch of work, and you submit a polite request for the BDFL to pull your work into the project. He or she may decline your Pull Request, request a long list of changes, or just wait ten years to give any response at all.
In a business setting with hourly pay, deadlines, and co-workers chosen for you, not by you, it makes less sense. People tend to wait until the last minute to give or request feedback which leads to a lot of thrown-away work. Unfortunately, willingness to throw away work becomes a mark of pride at some places. Maybe enterprise projects need some kind of "managed push" system instead of a "pull request" system.
Edit: "Unfortunately, willingness to throw away work becomes a mark of pride at some places." to elaborate, the thing that makes this unfortunate is that the person assumes that throwing away work is necessary for code quality to stay high. By requesting feedback at intervals (which is what the author of the article recommended), you can avoid throwing away work without sacrificing quality.