News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by gipp on Saturday February 10, 2018 @12:41PM (#16348417)
The show is mostly _fun_, but I definitely wouldn't call it a _great_ or well-made show, apart from the visuals. Too much clunky dialogue and half-baked subplots.

In particular, there's a certain traumatized daughter whose plot never makes sense at any turn. The show seems to expect us to already know and have a major emotional investment in a character who we've never seen speak and who seems to have almost no tangible relationship to anything else happening in the show. Plus the way other characters react to what's going on with her is completely nonsensical.

The show has plenty of issues but that one in particular really bothered me for some reason.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by Joeri on Saturday February 10, 2018 @01:40PM (#16348762)
Personally, I really liked altered carbon. The acting was good, the sets great, and the story intriguing. The show doesn’t go out of its way to surprise you like GoT, but it had enough mysteries and twists to keep things interesting.

The only lesser part for me wasn’t the story but the technology. I’m ok with unexplained advanced tech, but it has to make sense. Why are the only things run by advanced better-than-human AI’s hotels and brothels? Why is it so trivial to transfer minds between bodies but so difficult to make a simple backup? Why are prosthetic replacement arms so powerful they can crush metal, and why if that tech is available don’t the special ops use bodies which are all-prosthetic? Too many things didn’t make sense.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by philipkglass on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:04PM (#16348880)
I re-read the book a few weeks ago in anticipation of the series. The inconsistencies that you notice are real and present in the source material. I didn't notice them so much the first time I read the book 10+ years ago. The relentless action was fresh the first time around and helped paper over weaknesses in the logic of the world. Also I've apparently become less able to overlook internal inconsistencies with time.

The vast majority of SF uses technologies as cool set props for minor variations on familiar kinds of stories and social dynamics. Star Trek was/is terrible about this too. It's hard for a creator to model the higher-order effects that would be introduced from (e.g.) starships, teleporters, AI, or what-have-you. Do that hard work too well and most of the audience won't be able to understand what's going on without lengthy infodumps. The only current show I can think of that tries to show how technologies could drastically change societies is Black Mirror. Almost everything else is "familiar social dynamics, Amazing Gizmos are just props for the adventure." The proportion of internally consistent works is somewhat higher in written SF, but I'd say over half still follows the Amazing Gizmos Somehow Leave Society Basically Familiar template.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by carapace on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:20PM (#16348992)
(Oh man, Star Trek... Artificial gravity that no one ever talks about. Gravity control would be a total game-changer.

Also, One day I realized, how does the Klingon disintegrator ray stop at the soles of the boots? It never disintegrates the floor.)

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by dingaling on Sunday February 11, 2018 @10:09AM (#16352950)
> Artificial gravity that no one ever talks about.

Much the same as how most people today don't talk about how 4G works, or how pressurisation on an airliner prevents them from asphyxiating. Until it stops working, like in Star Trek VI...

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by carapace on Sunday February 11, 2018 @02:03PM (#16354161)
Yeah, but we mention 4G, pressurized cabins, what-have-you.

My point is that of all the futuristic fictional technologies that ST presents and deals with: teleporters, replicators, phasors, warp drive, etc... they never ever even mention the artificial gravity. (Spoiler alert: There is one part in one of the movies where the bad guys turn it off on a ship during an attack. But still no one actually talks about it.)

Arguably, gravity control would be a huge thing (Larry Niven has a book where one of the characters has developed g.c. and done spectacular things with it.)

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by amag on Saturday February 10, 2018 @04:20PM (#16349667)
Ah, but it works the same way light sabers in StarWars shoot out super-focused light (in fact so focused that it acts as solid matter) and then suddenly terminates about a yard from the shaft.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by Joeri on Saturday February 10, 2018 @05:26PM (#16350003)
I always understood lightsabers to be a force field confining plasma, with the plasma leaking through the force field, especially when the field is deflected by impact.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by smnrchrds on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:34PM (#16349072)
To add to your list of questions,

Since it is so trivial to fake video evidence or transfer to a new body, why would a video confession have any value? And why on earth are their bank accounts DNA-locked when they can and do change bodies like they change cloths?

In the future so technologically advanced, why would a contract need to be physically printed and stamped?

Who holds the power in this universe? One episode Meths are gods, untouchable by mere mortals. The next, police show up and easily arrest not one, but two of them. One week a nobody can slaughter an entire clinic and walk away with impunity, the next a Meth is arrested for what can be arguably called a manslaughter, under influence no less. Who is the ultimate untouchable, Meths or CTAC? It seems it changes from episode to episode.

If people can live in the virtual, why wouldn't more people do so instead of simply dying? Living in the virtual should cost nothing or close to nothing. Why isn't everyone who can't afford a new body at the end of their natural lifespan simply move to virtual for the rest of eternity, or until they gather enough money for a new body?

I can go on and on. Nothing about the show made sense. The visuals were great, but everything else was terribly lacking.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by crankylinuxuser on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:43PM (#16349130)
We (wife and I) quit watching halfway through the second show. The plot didn't make sense.

Why would someone who is effectively immortal care if a body was destroyed?

Aside from "plot point", why was the update of the meth's upload 48 hours? Why not also local, and uploaded to the cloud?

For anyone who can upload, which seems everyone except Catholics (plot point), why can't people trade bodies as needed? 7 year old gets old person body - why can't they trade as needed?

And of course, add in the appropriate amounts of violence and "Game of Thrones" forced sexuality. I guess pandering to the masses is a thing. :/

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by philipkglass on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:54PM (#16349211)
There's a lot of internal inconsistency in the story but

Why would someone who is effectively immortal care if a body was destroyed?

Doesn't seem so weird. Bancroft has no memory of being in a suicidal frame of mind, he has a lot of enemies, and somehow his last body ended up destroyed with his own weapon inside his secure mansion. It doesn't matter that it's impossible to really end him by destroying that one body. It should have also been impossible for one of his enemies to destroy that one body in those circumstances. As long as Bancroft isn't convinced of the suicide or wife-did-it explanations he's going to care a lot about how that body ended up dead.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by crankylinuxuser on Saturday February 10, 2018 @03:16PM (#16349342)
We already live in a world with cameras, microphones, and recorders of all sorts spooling data to the "cloud". And this futuristic world wants to sell me the idea that one of the richest families in the galaxy can't afford security that entails in recording all physical happenings that goes on in the house?

I don't accept that.

Sure, video can be forged or deleted. But we can even solve that by spooling to write-once read only systems. A dot matrix printer is an early form of that for Syslog. Hard for a hacker to 'hack' a printout. Or, in this case, whatever techno-magical hardware can be used.

And regarding killing his body and device, all he needs to do is increase the update frequency and make it realtime backup for his residence. Then, no mystery. He'd remember.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by viperscape on Saturday February 10, 2018 @01:50PM (#16348808)
The last two bother me especially. Only thing I can think of is that bodies are expendable and for police that means good second skins, they get first or second dibs. No need for cyborg parts when blasters kick so much butt.

The stack backup reasoning is lame, "too expensive" is not really defining, and if a stack can be transferred to another stack, having two with one in a strongbox seems logical. You possibly lose memories then, but live on. It seems to come down mostly to money and socioeconomic disparity. At one point someone says, fixing a broken leg is too expensive. That's ridiculous

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by darksim905 on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:31PM (#16349056)
I don't think it was hard to make backups, but that it was expensive, cost prohibitive by the 'have nots' who are unable to afford or acquire the ability to say, clone themselves on demand.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by evo_9 on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:03PM (#16348877)
Laughably bad, actually, esp. if you cut your teeth growing up on Neuromancer, Snowcrash, etc. I honestly thought it was written by a teenager, the scene with the Ai's playing poker was when it went off the cliff for me.

Philip K Dick's Electric Dreams, however, is worthwhile and a nice bookend to the new season of Black Mirror.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by Fnoord on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:29PM (#16349043)
I've only seen about 20 minutes of the first episode and couldn't enjoy it. I'd like to at least finish the first episode before I make judge for myself whether this one's worth my time (though I'm gonna first watch The Man in the High Castle). Generally though as a rule of thumb: Nice CGI doesn't make up for a terrible story, but a good story can make up for the lack of good CGI. E.g. I did not find the story good in the follow-ups of The Matrix.

I fully underline your statement regarding PKD's Electric Dreams as well as all the Black Mirror seasons. Furthermore, let us not forget that several other of PKD's works have seen a movie adaptations. I can recommend Total Recall (both; watch older first), Blade Runner (both; watch older first), A Scanner Darkly (if you can stand the art style; personally, I loved it), Minority Report, and The Adjustment Bureau (Screamers was OKish). There are series adaptations as well. Check Wikipedia for all the adaptations [1]

I'm not aware of any motion picture adaptations of Stephenson's or Gibson's works. Although I just found out via Wikipedia that the game Netrunner [2] is a derivative work of the Sprawl trilogy, and also The Matrix heavily "drawn" from the Sprawl trilogy as well [3].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_adaptations_of_works_b...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Android:_Netrunner

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuromancer#Literary_and_cultu...

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by BerislavLopac on Saturday February 10, 2018 @03:40PM (#16349454)
> I'm not aware of any motion picture adaptations of Stephenson's or Gibson's works.

Well, for what it's worth, there is Johnny Mnemonic, which wasn't very well received although I personally liked it. Another short story set in the Sprawl, New Rose Hotel, was also adapted to a film (I haven't seen it), and many other works, including Neuromancer, have been in various stages of development for a while. More details at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Gibson#Film_adaptation...

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by Fnoord on Sunday February 11, 2018 @06:24AM (#16352239)
Keanu Reeves in the former, Willem Dafoe in the latter. I'll give both a whirl, thank you.

From what I can tell nobody brought up David Cronenberg either. I liked his works [1] when I was younger (not sure if I still would now). I especially liked eXistenZ, but also Videodrome, The Fly, and Scanners.

I just started binge watching The Man In The High Castle and it exactly underlines my statement in my previous post: great storyline (IMO), but not depending much on CGI. I think if the story lacks, all you got going for it is CGI (or not if there is none). CGI may impress you when you're still young, but as you grow older you see through the façade. Especially when its overdone. Because older movies lack it, and therefore are rather limited (take for example old Star Wars which heavily used costumes, models, and camera tricks). It might feel a bit dated, if not just from the hair models. Yet sometimes the nostalgia hits the nail (such as in Black Mirror's San Junipero episode). Not exactly sure why. While I'm thoroughly enjoying The Man In The High Castle series my partner hates anything related to WWII so thats yet another series we cannot watch together.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Cronenberg#As_director

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by amag on Saturday February 10, 2018 @04:33PM (#16349734)
Agreed, there are so many plot holes in AC it wouldn't even do as a sieve. Still I watch it because it's cyberpunk. I just disconnect my brain and enjoy the settings.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by rbaud on Saturday February 10, 2018 @12:59PM (#16348524)
In the book, which I'd recommend if you enjoyed the concepts surrounding digitized consciousness, the subplot with the traumatized daughter serves to introduce a pretty pivotal character/plot point.
Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by gooseus on Saturday February 10, 2018 @01:04PM (#16348557)
Yes, I agree... character development was very weak for pretty much everyone but Tak and Ortega, and even they were pretty shaky.

I put this show in the camp good concepts, good visuals, decent fights, but the characters are just along for whatever ride the writers want to take them on.

Also, the plot had my eyes rolling a little too often for my taste. Much of the future tech ended up being a hammer that could force the story through any hole they wanted while other elements didn't make sense to exist in the way they were portrayed.

The Raven AI was cool, but their weak excuse for how those constructs were neglected and not used everywhere didn't make any sense given his role as the story played out.

Re:Altered Carbon – All the DNA of great science-fiction wit... by darksim905 on Saturday February 10, 2018 @02:30PM (#16349047)
What needs to make sense of her plot, exactly? She (or her sleeve?) was damaged or had an issue to the extent that all that was left was her stack. It was fascinated to me to see a AI help bring a human back as an individual & use methods it thought would help someone the best.