Re:Antidepressants aren't much better than sugar pills
by phnofive on Friday February 09, 2018 @08:56PM
(#16345397)
>First off, if you’re absolutely sure you want to take an SSRI, take Lexapro. It’s pretty clearly safer and stronger than any other SSRI.
>GlacierMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
It's an interesting article otherwise, though the comparison to placebo as a measure of efficacy was new to me. I've always suspected acetaminophen was a gamble, but I had no idea it was so statistically ineffective.
Re:Antidepressants aren't much better than sugar pills
by keyboardhitter on Friday February 09, 2018 @08:47PM
(#16345366)
The title should state SSRIs and not antidepressants as there are numerous drug types that can be considered antidepressant (e.g. SNRI, NASSA, tricyclic)
Re:Antidepressants aren't much better than sugar pills
by incompatible on Friday February 09, 2018 @08:58PM
(#16345404)
The interesting story is often that placebos work so well. According to the article: A typical participant in a depression study can expect to shave 9 points off their HAMD-D score—just by taking a sugar pill. In contrast, the group taking the actual SSRI might improve by around 10 points, so the effect of the treatments is dwarfed by the placebo effect.
Re:Antidepressants aren't much better than sugar pills
by saulrh on Friday February 09, 2018 @08:58PM
(#16345405)
p(benefit) is an awful way of looking at these medications. Yes, if you pull a random medication off the shelf and try it on someone at random, of course you'll have a terrible result! Go ahead, walk into the pharmacy and try a random medication off the wall! I dare you! But if you find the right one it is life-changing. And there are enough of them out there that each one only needs to be a hair better than random for it to be unlikely that none of them work. Same math that powers techniques like random forests. I don't know what the numbers are, but if you look at p(any medication working) instead of p(this medication working), it's damn sure not sugar-pill statistics.
>GlacierMD does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
It's an interesting article otherwise, though the comparison to placebo as a measure of efficacy was new to me. I've always suspected acetaminophen was a gamble, but I had no idea it was so statistically ineffective.