News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jahaja on Thursday February 08, 2018 @06:57PM (#16336667)
The main thing the so called gig-economy brings to the table is a regression in workers rights and benefits. That's the core. That's the profits. I can't understand why people are wilfully accepting that this is somehow the inevitable result of some smartphone app having been created.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by dragonwriter on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:13PM (#16336779)
> The main thing the so called gig-economy brings to the table is a regression in workers rights and benefits

In the present regulatory environment, sure; one could argue that that environment is using employers as a vehicle for general social services in a way which is undesirable and reduces employment, economic output, and well being especially for the poor.

Moving the basic protections to public benefit schemes with appropriate tax support might be a better option. E.g., UBI instead of minimum wage, universal (single-payer or mandatory and subsidized default minimum coverage) healthcare instead of employer-mandated insurance, etc.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by eropple on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:16PM (#16336805)
> In the present regulatory environment, sure

In almost any likely regulatory environment we are likely to see in the next decade, and definitely in absolutely any regulatory environment that the the-poors-are-revolting HN zeitgeist has any influence on forming.

I realize I am not telling you anything that you, specifically, don't know. (And I don't think you are the type to approve of those environments.) But having that out there provides important caveats for your "might be"'s. The problem exists and the problem is real and bad people are using it to hurt people and while I know you know the difference, underlining that "might be" might be doesn't erase what is.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jahaja on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:40PM (#16336929)
I'd like to point out that the difference between contractor and employee is even larger in Europe since more rights have been fought through to the same "Everyone will become unemployed!" cries of capital during the whole 20th century.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by ars on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:01PM (#16336694)
> is a regression in workers rights and benefits.

But, it also brings an expansion in available jobs, and much greater flexibility in deciding when to work.

For a LOT of people, those are worthwhile tradeoffs.

> of some smartphone app having been created.

Piecework (which is basically what this is), long long long predates the smartphone.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by eropple on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:22PM (#16336830)
It is absolutely, positively, incontrovertibly full-stop dishonesty to throw up the smokescreen of "oh they're choosing the 'gig economy' because of flexibility!". They're "choosing the 'gig economy'" 'cause there's no real jobs. The choice being made is between that and unemployment, not that and full-time work.

"Flexibility" is what it's called when PR flacks, from their actual-full-time jobs (but, ha ha, not for long, the bell tolls for thee too), have to hide the hatchet job they do to the poor. It's not some "but fairings!" situation--it's a systemic attack on people.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by smallgovt on Thursday February 08, 2018 @08:34PM (#16337196)
The vitriol and blanket generalizations are neither helpful nor accurate.

It's an indisputable fact that these gig economy jobs provide more flexibility in the form of being able to choose your hours of work.

Is this flexibility a critical motivation to accepting work? For some people, yes. For others, no.

Is unemployment a critical motivation to accepting this type of work? For some people, yes. For others, no.

You want to paint this as black and white when the reality is only SOME of the workforce is faced with unemployment as the only alternative.

My question to you is: Do you know what fraction of gig workers would actually otherwise be unemployed?

If I had to guess, it's a small minority.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by ars on Thursday February 08, 2018 @10:12PM (#16337636)
> They're "choosing the 'gig economy'" 'cause there's no real jobs.

Unemployment is historically low right now. Yet, tons of people are still choosing gig work.

So there is something about it that people value. You can't just say there are no other jobs, because that's just not true.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by longerthoughts on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:37PM (#16336916)
>They're "choosing the 'gig economy'" 'cause there's no real jobs. The choice being made is between that and unemployment, not that and full-time work.

This may very well be the more common case but it's not responsible to generalize either way. If you have evidence to support your claim please share.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by lovich on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:36PM (#16337920)
I know when I was told to go home at 31.5 hours every week it wasn't by my choice. The months it took to scrape together enough money to get a car and interview at non retail jobs also wasn't really a choice unless you count "give up and be homeless" as a reasonable option
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jeremyjh on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:12PM (#16336764)
Piece rate workers are employees,and full time workers are not exempt. A subset of them (locals who work only during harvest season, and kids, basically) are exempt from overtime status and minimum wage. https://www.dol.gov/whd/regs/compliance/whdfs12.pdf
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jstanley on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:03PM (#16336705)
Corollary to that is that it makes work available where previously it was uneconomical to employ somebody.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by cbcoutinho on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:09PM (#16336738)
How is that the case when looking at ridesharing services? Using uber instead of a cab takes away work from one and gives it to another by undercutting them. As much as it's 'creating work' for a lyft driver, it's also taking someone else's job. I don't mean to defend the cab industry herr, but it's not like this work wasn't being done elsewhere.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by function_seven on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:15PM (#16336787)
Sure, in dense metros like NYC you can say each Uber/Lyft is replacing a cab ride. I won't argue with you there. But in the suburbs, using a cab was not a normal thing to do, but using Uber or Lyft is.

Maybe I'm being too anecdotal, but I can only think of a couple of rides (out of dozens) where I would have called a cab had Lyft not been available.

Trying to get a cab ride from my house to a random place 15 miles away was a nightmare. Bad dispatch, no-show drivers, etc. Never really bothered after a few bad experiences, just designated a driver instead.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by cbcoutinho on Friday February 09, 2018 @05:38AM (#16339259)
I would totally agree with you there regarding getting to/from a random place. Getting to downtown from where I grew up was a cool half hour drive, and no cab would dare giving you a ride down there. In that way, Uber definitely added value to anyone who didn't want to park downtown for an evening. I just assumed that that was not the majority of ride-sharing usage, where most of the action was in NYC/LA where cab-usage was already relatively high.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by Trundle on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:24PM (#16336847)
There are plenty of rides happening with Uber/Lyft now that just wouldn't have happened at all previously, not just gone to a taxi.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by stale2002 on Thursday February 08, 2018 @09:18PM (#16337401)
Taxi cab drivers already work as contractors in many real taxi companies.

Uber did not invent this practice. They took it from the existing industry.

The existing industry was actually WORSE in that you would have taxi medallion owners who would charge people rent for the luxury of using their taxi medallion!

So please, do not blame Uber for the existing taxi cab contractor business practices.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by kelnos on Friday February 09, 2018 @07:16AM (#16339625)
I don't think that's entirely the case. It's true that taxi drivers in many markets are seeing less work because of Uber/Lyft, but many many many more people are taking Uber/Lyft than would have been taking taxis otherwise. I and literally everyone I know in SF are prime examples of that. (And I literally mean "literally"; there is not a single person I know for whom this is not the case.) People don't even think about ordering up a Lyft when they need one; they just do it. It's nearly as automatic as breathing. Attempting the painful process of getting a taxi was always pretty low on anyone's list of "reasonable ways to get from point A to point B".

(You can certainly argue that now having all these extra cars on the road is a bad thing, but that's a separate issue.)

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by aidenn0 on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:27PM (#16336861)
Assuming that Uber is either more convenient of cheaper than a cab, one would assume that the number of cab rides goes up.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by woolvalley on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:15PM (#16336793)
If you work at a typical retail store or do pizza delivery, what kind of benefits do you receive? Do you actually receive a usable healthcare plan working at a typical US retail operation?

If america had universal health care like the rest of the developed world, would anyone really care about this stuff that much?

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by aidenn0 on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:25PM (#16336850)
It varies from state to state, but the two main protections that employees get but contractors don't are unemployment and minimum wage.

There are others as well, which stems from the fact that for the most part the law considers contractors to be entities negotiating on equal footing with their customers (i.e. those who would otherwise be considered employers), whereas employees are required to have certain protections.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by eropple on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:17PM (#16336808)
Probably not. But we don't, so we care.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by hkmurakami on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:22PM (#16336835)
Iirc many fast food places will try to limit your hours so you don't qualify for benefits.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by colechristensen on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:03PM (#16336706)
It's an exchange. The freedom of the gig economy vs. the loss of rights and benefits. If it's worth it for you take it, if not, don't.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by eropple on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:06PM (#16336726)
Sure. It's an exchange. It's an exchange designed to consign the poor into being ever poorer. But hey--you get your food delivered for two bucks and you never have to talk to a person. So that's great.

The "gig economy" is designed to break employment. It's designed to turn people who already are living hand-to-mouth or worse into always-available scutworkers for the upper class and the (smaller than one would expect) middle class that serves them in ways the participants in that "gig economy" cannot. But you can choose to not do it! And when, obviously and inexorably, that becomes the game in town available to vast swaths of the working poor, what then? There aren't even any workhouses anymore. Scrooge can't even offer that whatabout.

Most people may not have much of a choice about feeding themselves (ourselves) or their (our) kids into the thresher, but the people who do can have the minimal decency not to oh-but-it's-fine about it. And that includes most people on HN.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by smallgovt on Thursday February 08, 2018 @08:22PM (#16337144)
It's neither accurate nor constructive to make it seem like there's an evil villain in these companies who's ACTIVELY designing/rigging the system to screw over the poor.

The reality is that these companies are just being driven by profits. And, one way to maximize profits is to minimize costs by offering fewer benefits to workers.

This outcome has a lot more to do with capitalism as a whole than the gig economy.

If you are a proponent for worker's rights and mandated benefits then by all means argue for that. But, please don't make it seem like there's some evil person on the other side that you're seeking justice against. That doesn't exist.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by eropple on Thursday February 08, 2018 @10:11PM (#16337630)
There are villains in this. They're the people who exploit, who maximize profits on the backs of the poor instead of treating their employees like human beings and trying to not grind them into powder.

Maybe capitalism has problems and it's not just the "gig economy"? This is creeping towards an epiphany--maybe choosing to participate in capitalism at a high level rather than mitigate its excesses makes you complicit? Maybe you own what you do and when what you do hurts people, you own that harm and that hurt?

Yes, this does characterize many HN-sanctioned heroes. Too bad. Maybe they should instead be decent.

Nobody forced these companies to exist. If you can't do business without bloodying the poor who are your "human resources," maybe you shouldn't do business.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by zaroth on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:28PM (#16337888)
If the legal standard finds they are employees the added cost is just more incentive to automate the jobs away completely. Soon enough all these terrible horrible jobs you speak of (which every driver I’ve spoken to is happy to have, usually having quit some other full-time employment to do gig work instead), soon enough all these jobs simply won’t exist at all.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by lovich on Thursday February 08, 2018 @11:39PM (#16337929)
You are incentivized to hurt people and steal their money if you reasonably think you can get away with it. That fact being true does not mean that actually hurting people for your benefit isn't evil. There are lots of actions that you are theoretically incentived to take, but it _is_ evil to do so.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by kelnos on Friday February 09, 2018 @07:22AM (#16339650)
Every time I read arguments like this (the threat of increased cost leading to more automation), I just further believe that some sort of guaranteed basic income is what we need to be moving toward. Ideally in the utopian future we automate "all" jobs away to the point where we have so few jobs compared to the number of people, and obviously people will still need to be able to tend to their basic needs and then some. Owning the automation just cannot mean you get all the profits from it.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by indubitable on Friday February 09, 2018 @02:25AM (#16338537)
Let's think about money for a minute. Money itself of course has no meaning. But we apply meaning to it. It essentially works as a proxy for the value we assign to labor and materials - both of which are finite in reality. So obviously you'd prefer drivers make more money, so they could live a better life. Well how much? I imagine you think a ballpark for a 'fair' wage would be somewhere around $15/ride. Now let's consider your person that relies on taxi type services for transportation. We'll say they go out and return to their house once a day. And every other day they also go in/out again for entertainment, essentials, and so on. For a 30 day month that's a total of 30 x 2 + (30/2) x 2 = 90 trips. And 90 x 15 = $1350. On a yearly basis that's 365.25 x 3 x 15 = $16,436.

Well that's a lot of money. Of course I expect you'd probably say that that's because the 'bourgeois' are holding back the 'proletariat.' Okay. Let's go full on social system economics. Let's just pretend the entire GDP in the US is spread completely evenly between each and every person. And that's quite unreasonable as our GDP would decrease dramatically under such a system, but for arguments sake I'll give you that. Okay, that's easy. That's the GDP/capita or $52k. The total value of all annual goods and services in the US produced works out to $52k/person/year. But we can't forget about taxes now. To sustain our social utopia we'd need quite a high tax rate. But again, I'm going to let you have that and we'll just maintain current taxes. So we're each taking home about $42k. I'm also going to pretend that state and other taxes don't exist.

Now look at your $15/ride. If somebody was going to depend on that, they'd end up spending nearly 40% of their entire income just getting around even with a perfectly fair share of all income generated nationwide! And I gave you several unreasonably optimistic assumptions that makes that number a real lowball. The point here is that even in what I assume is your idealized system, this would not be a sustainable industry. It's very easy to see things through the lens of a victim complex because of the apparent inequality of our society. But these optics are in large part caused by inconceivably large population numbers. Imagine you earned just $1 from each person on this Earth. You'd be the 65th richest person in the world! Far from a 1%er, you'd be a 0.000000001%er. Earn $12 and you'd be the single richest person alive. Even if we just consider the USA. Imagine you took every penny Bill Gates, currently the richest person in the world, is worth and equally distributed it to each and every person in the US. That'd be a total of $275. Maybe you would say well do that to them all! By the time you're down to the 100 richest person you're only getting $17/person, and again that's for the US population only.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by kalleboo on Friday February 09, 2018 @05:34AM (#16339248)
Yes, it's unsustainable to be privately chauffeured around everywhere if you're not wealthy. Is this controversial? It's also ecologically and infrastructurally unsustainable so it's not something anyone actually wants.

Most people in places where wages are livable walk, bike, ride a bus or train or drive themselves around. For the infirm there are subsidized transportation services.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by indubitable on Friday February 09, 2018 @09:14AM (#16340265)
It's 'controversial' only in the sense that most people don't understand this. Many people seem to think that the only reason companies aren't giving great salaries to people, and 'letting' everybody earn a very good living doing most of anything, is greed. The person I was responding to went so far as to call these companies "villains." Or look at the other poster's response to this very topic. In reality, what people want is impossible, and but very few understand that. And I think the nature of this fact is often met with cognitive dissonance of some sort or another, which is sad. We are definitely becoming a nation that has an increasingly tenuous relationship with facts.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by bad-joke on Friday February 09, 2018 @04:18AM (#16338936)
If wealth was evenly divided in the US, each household would have $760,000 [1]. Assuming a person spends $16,436 on taxi rides per year (instead of buying a new car every year), that would be 2% of their income, not 40%.

[2]https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/yellen20141...

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by indubitable on Friday February 09, 2018 @04:55AM (#16339092)
Let's talk about terminology now. First is households. A household in the US is a bit more than 2.5 people. You can go ahead and bump up your costs to $41k a year on transport alone. The next is wealth. Let's hit on two points:

- Wealth is not renewable, which is why income is vastly more important. If you have $100 of wealth and you only spend 10% of it a year. You're completely broke a decade. 'Only' spending 5% of your total wealth on transport per year is a path to very rapid ruin.

- There's nowhere near the amount of 'real' wealth as there is 'paper' wealth, which is the number you're indirectly citing. Most wealth is tied up in the form of various investments, stocks, and so on. When you liquidate these assets, it results in a decline in their value. If you were to liquidate large amounts of market assets into spendable money, simultaneously, you would find the total wealth in the US to be a very small fraction of the numbers stated.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by mdorazio on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:07PM (#16336731)
You're assuming that it's a choice people want to make. If you talk to a few gig economy workers it becomes pretty clear that many of them would much prefer a 9-5 job with decent pay and benefits, but are unable to find such jobs.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by fosk on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:12PM (#16336766)
These apps wouldn’t exist in the first place without these caveats since they operate on thin margins. Sure, we could put them out of business and then how will that help people who can’t find a regular job? At least now they have options. Also we have a big problem with unskilled workforce nowadays - if you are unskilled by choice or (unfortunately) by circumstances this world is not going to be kind on you. That’s the sad truth.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by colechristensen on Friday February 09, 2018 @01:27AM (#16338336)
The deal is, I have, I am not assuming. There are a lot of people I have met personally who seem honestly to want the situation.

Many of them are people seeking a little extra money, a way to fund a new car, something to hold them over between jobs, a way to pick their own schedule... I have had a lot of conversations with a lot of workers in the gig economy and never have heard "I wish this was my full time job". Maybe that is the random set of people I've interacted with, maybe there is a bias for what people want to talk about.

What is absolutely clear though, is that a sizable amount of people participating in the gig economy are doing so because they want to take advantage of how it works, not despite how it works.

Many of them had other jobs, many of them clearly wouldn't want a full time job doing the gig.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by saas_co_de on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:18PM (#16336813)
People are not choosing between full time work and the gig economy. They are choosing between unemployment and the gig economy.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by colechristensen on Friday February 09, 2018 @01:38AM (#16338381)
This is just false though.

The guy who was the creator of a local web design business driving me around on a weekend afternoon wasn't choosing between unemployment and the gig economy, he was supplementing his income while worked on his dream.

The programmer giving me a ride to SFO from the peninsula wasn't choosing against unemployment, we had worked at the same company in similar positions, we had a great time talking about how things were going. He was just making money as he commuted home.

The Afghani translator who immigrated after the war was a student making money over the weekend on his own schedule. Neither of us understood football at all.

A lot of the things I pay for "gig economy" employees to do are things I think would be awful as full time jobs, it would make me sad to support a business that put people in the position where that was their life. When it's optional, people using those bits of work to fill in the gaps or add a bit of extra on top of whatever else they were doing with their life, I am a lot happier to support those workers and those businesses.

Not so say that the businesses are doing everything perfect, but I think it's obvious that the 'lead generation' role (companies like uber, lyft, etc) are going to become more of commodities to the benefits of the workers using them.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jstanley on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:33PM (#16336892)
So how exactly is the gig economy harming them? Would you rather see these people unemployed?
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by linkmotif on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:22PM (#16336836)
People leave this comment 1,000 times every day on HN; a million times of the internet. Left to their devices, people who push this line of thinking would put kids back in mines, chimneys and mills. Hey, it's an exchange, am I right?
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by alphonsegaston on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:11PM (#16336756)
Any “exchange” that’s premised on the “loss of rights” is just the Capital class leveraging their power to further exploit the poor.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by kelnos on Friday February 09, 2018 @06:47AM (#16339492)
There's a trade off, though. It might not be the right one just yet, but it's there. Gig economy workers have much more flexibility to set their own hours, schedule, and what jobs they want to do than traditional employees do.

Really the only problem here, and the only reason why there are lawsuits, is that these workers aren't being paid enough. I really doubt any of these people care whether they're classified as employees or contractors; they just want to feel like they're making enough money to support themselves (plus take care of self-employment taxes and healthcare costs) without feeling like to do so they need to work themselves to the bone. If these jobs provided a decent standard of living, I don't think these issues would exist at all.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by jahaja on Friday February 09, 2018 @07:47AM (#16339771)
My entire point was that the fact that they are not paid enough - including the loss of rights and benefits which translates to labor costs - is a feature not a bug. The core feature. I have no idea why there is this insistence on some kind of "benefit of the doubt" ad infinitum.
Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by peterjlee on Thursday February 08, 2018 @07:13PM (#16336774)
Who are the "wilfully accepting" people you speak of? I think most people aren't accepting nor rejecting anything.

Someone is hungry and now they have food delivered. Someone doesn't have a job and now they have a delivery job. It's a win-win situation in a short-term micro scale and people are just responding to short-term incentives. It may have a bad effect in the long term but hungry/unemployed people don't have time to think about that and middleman-apps are making good profit exploiting that.

Re:GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors by stale2002 on Thursday February 08, 2018 @09:14PM (#16337379)
Taxi drivers working as contractors is not something that started when the App was invented.

They have been working as contractors, for companies, for decades.

Maybe you think the law should be changed, but situations like this have been established and determined for a very long time.