Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon...
by dredmorbius on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:50PM
(#16306289)
There's an alternative approach: we could consider the cost-basis of fossil fuels, and whether or not that is appropriate.
It turns out that the basis and rationale (economic, legal, financial, actual) for the present regime are ... highly suspect. Hotelling's Rule is generally cited by is dismissed by virtually all parties as not describing reality (see for example BP's petroleum pricing data to 1859 in its annual survey of energy). The Rule of Capture is a legal justification for mineral taking that has no justification in the geological reality of the situation, a point recognised by some judges, though to date largely in dissenting opinions. Actual market prices are defined by the marginal extraction price, and in the absence of some cartel or regulatory body artificially constraining extraction rates (Standard Oil, the Seven Sisters, the Texas Railroad Commission, OPEC, Saudi Arabia), prices fall to absurdly low levels so long as there is any capacity to extract above current market demand (as with the $0.02/bbl prices of post-Daisy Bradford #3 oil-strike Texas in 1931, prior to the seizure at force of arms by the Texas and Oklahoma National Guards, and Texas Rangers, of wellhead production, and establishment of a quota system via "certificates of transport" for U.S. oil, and, by virtue of the U.S.'s status as global surplus oil producer, global oil markets, from 1931 - 1972.
If we consider the capital stock depletion to formation ratio of oil, which is on the order of about five million to one (years of formation consumed per present year), a fair argument might be made that petroleum and natural gas are very significantly under-priced.
A point at which other alternatives become far more viable.
(The situation is similar for coal, though the ratio imbalance is somewhat smaller.)
It turns out that the basis and rationale (economic, legal, financial, actual) for the present regime are ... highly suspect. Hotelling's Rule is generally cited by is dismissed by virtually all parties as not describing reality (see for example BP's petroleum pricing data to 1859 in its annual survey of energy). The Rule of Capture is a legal justification for mineral taking that has no justification in the geological reality of the situation, a point recognised by some judges, though to date largely in dissenting opinions. Actual market prices are defined by the marginal extraction price, and in the absence of some cartel or regulatory body artificially constraining extraction rates (Standard Oil, the Seven Sisters, the Texas Railroad Commission, OPEC, Saudi Arabia), prices fall to absurdly low levels so long as there is any capacity to extract above current market demand (as with the $0.02/bbl prices of post-Daisy Bradford #3 oil-strike Texas in 1931, prior to the seizure at force of arms by the Texas and Oklahoma National Guards, and Texas Rangers, of wellhead production, and establishment of a quota system via "certificates of transport" for U.S. oil, and, by virtue of the U.S.'s status as global surplus oil producer, global oil markets, from 1931 - 1972.
If we consider the capital stock depletion to formation ratio of oil, which is on the order of about five million to one (years of formation consumed per present year), a fair argument might be made that petroleum and natural gas are very significantly under-priced.
A point at which other alternatives become far more viable.
(The situation is similar for coal, though the ratio imbalance is somewhat smaller.)
See: https://dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.... (PDF)