I don't see how this is remotely possible. The synthetic diesel here is just a high-density energy storage medium. It's better than batteries because it's denser and compatible with the majority of today's engines. It's also denser than H2 (which is also just a store) and easier to handle.
But the plant here is not producing any energy, it's converting energy (probably electricity) into a form better suited for storage. Solar, wind, nuclear or fusion would be good sources of energy to convert into diesel, at most.
It all depends on whether their process is efficient enough to be worth it.
However, i did find this similar French work, which suggests taking advantage of the output from nuclear power plants at off-peak times:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187661021...
I don't see an estimate. But:
> The achilles heel of all negative emission technologies is cost. Government policy units assume that they will become economically viable, but the best hope of Carbon Engineering and other direct air extraction companies is to get the price down to $100 a tonne from the current $600.
I get that $600 per tonne CO2 is about 1.7 times the current global mean price of diesel. And $100 per tonne CO2 is about 0.3 times that. Given diesel-electric conversion efficiency of ~40%, you increase those estimates 2.5 fold. And then there's the energy input for hydrogen production, and the efficiency hit for chemical conversion.
It doesn't seem workable to me.
> [CE's A2F] needs 100 times less land and water than biofuels ... but for it to work, it will have to reduce costs
I think the research in TFA is very important -- I'm quite sure we'll be able to beat nature at this game in the long run and projects like this are how we'll figure it out -- but it's worth mentioning we have workable air-to-fuel technology right now but it has been largely abandoned because of the renewed supply of cheap oil.
But of course we'd need some kind of non-carbon energy source to make the fuel. Right now maybe we get the best bang for the buck by applying those sources to the electric grid, but with a carbon price the market would work that out.
Or maybe a nuclear-powered site which can convert CO2 into CxHy on an industrial scale. With the added advantage of removing CO2 in the process.
You also have the added advantage of not having to ship fuel in from chaotic regions of the world. Shipping produces a significant amount of the world's CO2.
http://bioage.typepad.com/greencarcongress/docs/greenfreedom...
They estimated that it required a pump price of $4.60/gallon for gasoline to be economically viable, given their other assumptions. The authors assumed relatively low cost nuclear power from Generation III reactors. But the Green Freedom concept seems like it would also work with sufficiently cheap large scale renewable electricity production.
Of course not, that would be the perpetuum mobile :) nor they claim that it can. Thing is, energy in form of liquid fuel is whole lot more expensive than in form of say, intermittent electricity from solar panels (which are now dirt cheap).
Even in the long run, though- gas currently has something like a 100-fold energy density advantage over most batteries. It will likely continue to have uses long into the future.
A2F fuel is still hydrocarbon so will still spit out similar pollutants along with contributing to the associated health impacts. As the second half of the article notes it's far better not to have the pollution in the air in the first place.
What about the economic, industrial, and environmental cost of creating and running the A2F infrastructure and process?
In 10 years, probably less, most vehicles will have been replaced. Keeping internal combustion viable for +20 years will just avoid the issue and help delay the inevitable switch to renewables; be that electric, fuel cell, or something more exotic. Worst case scenario - in 20 years internal combustion is still pervasive, in part thanks to the adoption of A2F, with both fuels at the pump: oil sourced £2, A2F £2.10.
So in 20 years I sincerely hope gas powered cars are not common, and are fast becoming an occasional historic entertainment found in clubs, tracks and preservation societies. Rather like steam trains and horses have perhaps.
It could perhaps be very useful for aviation where renewables seem unlikely to make much impact any time soon.
I would also note that for electric vehicles to be worth the bother at all, you also have to believe that the electric grid will be mostly renewable. And our current crop of coal plants will, sadly, last much longer than our cars, even if we stopped building them already (which we haven’t.)
The problem of EV is not their efficiency though, it's that they are extremely heavy for the range they provide, due to batteries still having terrible specific energy and energy density. And they basically only work in temperate areas (good luck running EVs in winter in Yakutsk).
ICE have much lower efficiency, but the sheer amount of energy in the fuel more than makes up for it.
And electricity storage at scale is still a problem we're nowhere near solving. Carbon-based fuels are extremely stable, if the generation process is not too lossy, they make for a pretty good storage medium: light, easy to manipulate, shelf-stable, and usable as-is.
In the 'real' world, the fact that you are reducing the wind speed by some fraction, or reduced insolation thermal temps on the ground, and that if you scaled this to one million square miles: those 'it doesnt work' sums don't apply.
it doesn't have to be efficient, to be worth doing, if you are prepared to sink capital into a source of energy.
It turns out that the basis and rationale (economic, legal, financial, actual) for the present regime are ... highly suspect. Hotelling's Rule is generally cited by is dismissed by virtually all parties as not describing reality (see for example BP's petroleum pricing data to 1859 in its annual survey of energy). The Rule of Capture is a legal justification for mineral taking that has no justification in the geological reality of the situation, a point recognised by some judges, though to date largely in dissenting opinions. Actual market prices are defined by the marginal extraction price, and in the absence of some cartel or regulatory body artificially constraining extraction rates (Standard Oil, the Seven Sisters, the Texas Railroad Commission, OPEC, Saudi Arabia), prices fall to absurdly low levels so long as there is any capacity to extract above current market demand (as with the $0.02/bbl prices of post-Daisy Bradford #3 oil-strike Texas in 1931, prior to the seizure at force of arms by the Texas and Oklahoma National Guards, and Texas Rangers, of wellhead production, and establishment of a quota system via "certificates of transport" for U.S. oil, and, by virtue of the U.S.'s status as global surplus oil producer, global oil markets, from 1931 - 1972.
If we consider the capital stock depletion to formation ratio of oil, which is on the order of about five million to one (years of formation consumed per present year), a fair argument might be made that petroleum and natural gas are very significantly under-priced.
A point at which other alternatives become far more viable.
(The situation is similar for coal, though the ratio imbalance is somewhat smaller.)
See: https://dge.carnegiescience.edu/DGE/Dukes/Dukes_ClimChange1.... (PDF)
That sounds like free energy / perpetual motion, i.e. physically impossible. Ok, there are inputs, but you don't expect the opposite of combustion to be a net producer of energy.
...or instead of reducing costs, just wait until oil increases past it.
No.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_law_of_thermodynamics
"But for it to work, it will have to reduce costs to little more than it costs to extract oil today, and – even trickier – persuade countries to set a global carbon price.”
Their feedstock costs are probably quite low. Air, and from the sounds of it, water to produce hydrogen through electrolysis. They're probably then doing some combination of reverse water-gas-shift + Fischer-Tropsch to go from CO2 + H2 to diesel. Not unlike a similar project in Qatar using natural gas as their hydrogen source.
Problem is that carbon and hydrogen from methane is much cheaper than from air and water. Their electric/energy bill is probably massive, and also begs the question: could they fuel their plant with their own product and still have net energy gain? Or do they depend on cheap energy from more thermodynamically favorable fuels like coal and oil to be viable?
Solar, wind, nuclear, batteries, electric self-driving cars, next gen A/C, hopefully fusion someday... these are the energy or conservation technologies of the future, not something that's DOA because of basic thermodynamics.