News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by xupybd on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:50PM (#16305856)
I think there is more at play here. Some of the highest birth rates are still in the lowest economic groups. While high rents are a problem and a no doubt causing economic hardships preventing young families from having children I think this is an over simplification of a larger problem.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by hackits on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:05PM (#16305900)
It is cheaper for us to down-size to a 2 bedroom unit and have one partner working full time than it is to pay for day care for the little one. Even with all the reduced childcare here in Australia the difference at the end of the week comes to $20.

Granted I'm all-ways amazed that in the West on one hand the news proclaim and medical professionals to have children when the women are in there 20's. Although the support and service's such as cheap day-care and family centered activities are completely lacking to support that mind-set.

The message most young people receive is `It is healthy to have children when you're younger`. The reality is `Yes you can, but I hope you like living in a studio apartment counting your monies well all your colleges/friends are having fun`.

That and in today modern world having a child in your 20's is more or less considered social suicide.

The only to maintain a life-style and support structure for young women would be to find a partner who can support them and their child well at the same time maintaining their quality of life. Something such partners are very small so there is a lot of competition for this type of partner.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by xupybd on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:14PM (#16305938)
Yes that's a real challenge for double income families. That it's self is a big change that's not that old. Don't get me wrong I'm not saying women shouldn't work. I'm saying society is still adjusting to that change is all.

For me I chose to get my education and start a career before even thinking about starting a family. Now I'm in my mid 30's I'm really starting to think I may not have played this very smart. I'd have been better off spending more time looking for a partner in my 20's. I'm a man, I hate to think what this looks like for a women who has a more limited fertility time span than I do.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by hackits on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:22PM (#16305975)
Choosing a female partner (depending if you live in the west) is one of the biggest financial decisions a man will make that can have ramification on your stress/emotion/and success in the future.

Don't take this the wrong way when I read you're in your mid 30's I basically cheered! Go out and meet new people and experience life that you have some money/experience under your belt.

Personally if I had time to rewind the clock, I wouldn't of got Married (here in the west). The legal system, law is blantly sexiest against men it's beyond a joke. Seeing from first hand account of this myself.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by angmarsbane on Monday February 05, 2018 @01:35PM (#16310837)
Choosing your partner whether male or female is one of the biggest financial decision anyone can make. The person you choose will have more influence over you and the directions your life takes than anyone else.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by closeparen on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:32PM (#16306011)
I’ve always wondered how this can sanity-check. Surely the pool of potential child-care workers is approximately all of humanity, and one worker can care for several children. It’s socially important, but not scarce. How, then, do childcare costs exceed the productive capacity of so many educated, specialized, experienced professionals?

This would seem to indicate that many jobs are bullshit, wages are suppressed, or there is artificial scarcity in the day care business.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by hackits on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:41PM (#16306049)
Supply/Demand, also consideration when government get involved it's like doing brain surgery with a base ball bat (its going to get messy)

To my understanding talking to the ladies at the child-care center's. The center is required to not exceed x number of children per day/per hour. They can only hire people with the clearance to supervise children after getting their Certificate 3 in child care. Then the staff need to under-go skills/training on their time to improve working with children.

Then you have insurance for the workers, building and also the necessary security and fire drills to be conducted regularly and kept up-to-date.

You have over-time pay, inclusive of when parents are late to pick up the children from day care.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by crdoconnor on Monday February 05, 2018 @05:22AM (#16307860)
And yet the costs of all of those pale in comparison to rents paid on the school building. In my area, at least, that's the line item that dominates.

That rent then usually gets pumped straight into the bottom line of some REIT or a millionaire's property portfolio.

Back when property taxes were higher, building rents were lower (because as you pointed out, supply usually meets demand) and those taxes helped pay for things like, well, childcare.... rather than yachts.

But sure, we have regulations that keep children safe too, and it's true that they impose a cost.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by closeparen on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @01:28AM (#16314773)
Childcare was just as exorbitant in my hometown with its glut of real estate (due to being a shadow of its 20th century industrial peak). In many places you’re allowed to run a small childcare facility out of your house (the one permitted commercial use in residential zones). I don’t think the facilities costs can explain it either.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by closeparen on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:54PM (#16306099)
I mean sure, regulation adds some friction, but it seems incredible that the childcare certificate regime could be so difficult that it prevents legions of un/underemployed workers from meeting the extreme demand for childcare services.

It’s a barrier, but so is a Masters in Education. My mother had one, as well 15+ years of classroom experience, and still found it less economically favorable to teach 25 kids vs. directly care for my brother.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by hackits on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:09PM (#16306156)
I agree it's incredible but (shurg) it's what is. Granted like I said before on the top above/bellow the only real choice Women can make is to Marry or Partner who can financially support them and there children during the first five years. Then once the children go to kinder-garden, school they re-enter the work-force on a part-time basis.

Though I don't have the numbers with me but here in Australia Asian families out-source the raring of infant's and children to the grand-parents. Although talk to any Western family (especially baby boomers) they want nothing to do with raising grand-children.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by flukus on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @01:44AM (#16314803)
> but it seems incredible that the childcare certificate regime could be so difficult that it prevents legions of un/underemployed workers from meeting the extreme demand for childcare services.

One big factor is the number of convicted felons, ~10% for the general population and significantly higher for the un/underemployed, that's a huge amount of the potential workforce gone. Another win for the war on drugs.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by xupybd on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:42PM (#16306052)
One big thing is income tax and benefits. Often the lower your income the better. In New Zealand there are a huge number of extra payments you miss out on if you work more, working for families, lower taxes, WINZ child care and more. So if you earn more than someone in working in childcare you have to earn significantly more to cover the taxes (approx 25% in NZ) you're paying and to cover the loss in benefits you don't get.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by Eridrus on Monday February 05, 2018 @01:09PM (#16310642)
Add to this that tax benefits are particularly friendly towards single income families, which leads to the second income being taxed at the marginal rate of the first.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by pavel_lishin on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:42AM (#16308659)
> Surely the pool of potential child-care workers is approximately all of humanity, and one worker can care for several children.

Speaking as a parent, I don't consider every Tom, Dick and Henrietta off the street as equivalent caretakers for my child. The pool of potential child care workers is much, much lower than "all of humanity".

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by mirimir on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:16PM (#16305951)
It strikes me that there are roughly three categories: 1) people who choose to never have kids; 2) people who want kids, but choose to wait until they can live comfortably, save for college, and so on; and 3) people who just want kids, and figure that they'll work out the details later.

Maybe it's the first and second categories who tend to end up in large cities. And maybe it's the third category who tend to live in the poorest regions. That is rather consistent with the standard understanding that education and economic development tend to reduce population growth.

Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by pavel_lishin on Monday February 05, 2018 @08:46AM (#16308671)
5) People who have unplanned pregnancies, which can then be subtyped into 5.1) people who keep them, and 5.2) people who don't.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by mirimir on Monday February 05, 2018 @05:59PM (#16313039)
OK, so I maybe got too Aristotelian.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by Powerofmene on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:07PM (#16306147)
And 4) people who cannot have children for some physical reason (infertility etc)
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by mirimir on Sunday February 04, 2018 @09:59PM (#16306317)
Thanks. I missed that one :( Sorry.
Re:Fertility rates decrease as rents increase by killjoywashere on Sunday February 04, 2018 @08:53PM (#16306092)
The poor have more insecurity on a wide variety of issues, including odds of children surviving to adulthood, and odds of maintain the relationship the begat each child (woman loves 3 men, loses each to prison, migratory employment, etc, society gets at least 3 babies).