News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by exabrial on Sunday February 04, 2018 @10:56AM (#16303213)
A few notes to help get this to the mainstream. Take these quotes:

* "persuade countries to set a global carbon price"

* "paid for by the emitters, or by the fossil fuel suppliers"

I think they should carefully examine how such efforts have failed or been sabotaged in the past. The issue most libertarians and conservatives have is not "co2 offsetting" itself, the issue is they don't like taxes and regulations because it interferes with individual liberties. From past experience, hinging an entire industry on a government-created market appears to be a sure path to failure. For all of the clever ingeniuty described here, I'm baffled why no one is addressing that, which seems to be the bigger issue.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by breakyerself on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:01PM (#16304207)
What is a more libertarian solution than a tax? It's a price signal to the market to reduce consumption. I can't think of a more hands off approach. Everything else I can think of involves expanding beurocratic oversight and allowing the political class to choose winners and losers. To me the knee jerk anti-tax attitude of many people is a mental shortcut for people who don't have the attention span to actually think through ideology and economics.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by graeme on Sunday February 04, 2018 @11:50AM (#16303484)
I am surprised that "add carbon taxes, cut income taxes" doesn't take off. Income taxes distort the economy, so lowering them is a massive benefit - if they can be replaced with another, better revenue source.

A carbon tax is an infinitely better revenue source as it reduced externalities.

I think rather than focussing on emissions reduction, global climate talks should focus on a global carbon tax, offset by reductions in other taxes.

(It's somewhat ineffective for one country to do a carbon tax now. Past a certain point it will just send carbon producing activities to countries without a tax. A globally agreed tax reduces this.)

A tax would be the mechanism to reduce emissions. Absent such a mecanism, emissions have only grown, despite accords to reduce them.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by hedora on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:05PM (#16303895)
Carbon taxes are regressive. I’m not disagreeing with your premise, but it makes them politically difficult. (Global warming will hit the poor the hardest too.)

Anyway, it is easy to make the carbon capture economy work, assuming you’re OK with instituting a fair carbon tax:

Give carbon capture plants 0.5 tons of carbon credit for each ton captured, and have the government sell unlimited carbon credits at 2x the market rate capturers charge.

I guess cutting income/corporate tax (could they even go negative?) could prevent this from crashing the economy, and let you adjust for the inherently regressive nature of fuel taxes.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by graeme on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:07PM (#16304236)
Do credits have a good track record anywhere? My assumption is that the system will develop leaks and exceptions.

Taxes do have a track record of being applied successfully.

If regressivensss is a concern, you can either cut another regressive tax, or implement some kind of carbon dividend.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by skosch on Sunday February 04, 2018 @02:51PM (#16304517)
Yeah, regressiveness is easily overcome by dividing up the money among the population and giving everyone a constant income tax decrease – that way it's wealth transfer down, not up.

In case you haven't heard of it: Citizen's Climate Lobby [1] exists purely to advance this scheme, and is well worth investing your volunteering time into.

[1] https://citizensclimatelobby.org/

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by graeme on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:24PM (#16305024)
I should also add that if we don't solve this, we basically destroy the planet for all future generations.

"Marginal increase in regressive taxation load in the present" doesn't seem that bad, in that view. Though I do agree it affects the politics of it.

Of course, there's also the non-neglible social benefits of lower income taxes.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by scentoni on Sunday February 04, 2018 @11:48AM (#16303476)
The carbon tax (and cap-and-trade) is the right-wing think tank alternative to reducing emissions by regulation, much like the individual mandate/Romneycare/Obambacare/ACA is the right-wing think tank alternative to single-payer/Medicare for all/universal health care. The issue is that the right wing think tanks come up with these alternatives, and then the right wing labels them as a left-wing attack upon America.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by nielsole on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:14PM (#16305253)
> the issue is they don't like taxes and regulations because it interferes with individual liberties

It would entirely be possible to make a libertarian argument, because emitting CO_2 reduces the liberties of others. Thus it is important that the individual liberties of the victims of climate change are also considered and be considered as if it was property.

Since reassigning property rights on a global (public) good don't work well, a (Pigouvean) tax seems like a sensible thing to preserve individual freedom of everyone.

Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by jeffbax on Sunday February 04, 2018 @01:47PM (#16304128)
There's certainly a libertarian argument that pollution is the exact type of externality government should be solving given its tragedy of the commons in a way most things are not, as well as framing under core defense. I also imagine many would trade in the many other distortions for a simpler carbon tax scheme than things like funding Solyndra's which go bust.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by jmatthews on Sunday February 04, 2018 @07:01PM (#16305663)
Rothbard argues strongly that pollution is a property rights issue and an ancap/libertarian solution is fully compatible with all types of tort or financial solutions. Not to say a "carbon tax scheme" could be thought of as libertarian. But libertarian theory certainly addresses the externality issue of pollution.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by incompatible on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:44PM (#16305100)
Tell that to all the "content" industries whose business models depend on copyright and patent restrictions, aka government-granted monopolies. Or the transport industry that is already so dependent on government-provided roads.
Re:Stripping CO2 from the air and using it to produce carbon... by jlebrech on Monday February 05, 2018 @05:09AM (#16307818)
or stockpile it