News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by jacquesm on Monday August 23, 2010 @11:38AM (#1627040)
"We received the machine with the original tamper-evident seals intact. The software can be replaced without breaking any of these seals, simply by removing screws and opening the case."

Ouch.

Incompetence doesn't even begin to describe it. Or is this by design?

Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by limist on Monday August 23, 2010 @12:52PM (#1627252)
"What's inside the AVC Edge? It has a 486 SLE processor and 32 MB of RAM—similar specs to a 20-year-old PC. The election software is stored on an internal CompactFlash memory card. Modifying it is as simple as removing the card and inserting it into a PC."

Seems to be a history of dubious competence for this machine and company:

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:vVOdcOpBZ_EJ:w...

http://sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=Sequoia_AVC_Edge

Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by jacquesm on Monday August 23, 2010 @02:11PM (#1627495)
I'm not too shocked by the use of the processor, that may very well have something to do with reliability. You'd be surprised how demanding industry is in this respect, and it's not rare at all to find what you'd class as 'ancient' hardware when it comes to doing jobs where you have to make the results reliable. Not saying that was the case here, but it could be, also I'm imagining these boards might be run from a battery backed-up power supply so they may want to have them consume as little power as possible (that's a guess though, but I can imagine that if your election is in an area where there is a power failure you don't want to lose the results).

Compare for instance with avionics and stuff on space flights. If crashing is not an option the rules about hardware change dramatically. It's a pity the article does not say whether the ram was ECC ram or not, that would be a hint that this is not just a way to be 'cheap'.

Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by varjag on Monday August 23, 2010 @01:34PM (#1627382)
Mind you, this could be because they were

- spending years on certification and legal compliance of hardware to many jurisdictions

- already had an old and tried platform that is powerful enough to do the job

Before anyone cries "obsolete", be aware that e.g. your Canon digital cameras run a DOS clone (ROM-DOS) on similar CPUs. You don't really have to have quad core everywhere just because you can.

But of course it doesn't address the whole seals fiasco.

Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by electromagnetic on Monday August 23, 2010 @11:16PM (#1628814)
A good design would have riveted the machine shut, ensuring the only way in was through the tamper-evident seals.

At work today (I work in construction) I managed to remove a latch & lock system from a door without damaging either part. I manipulated the door hook with the padlock on and loosened the top screws, which gave me enough room to remove the top two screws on the door frame latch, which gave me enough room to remove the two screws on the door hook. I then removed the bottom two on latch by using the new upward-slack. I forced the latch section around until the middle screw became loose, angled the latch and slowly removed the centre screw. I essentially just broke into the customer's garage with no signs of forced entry.

Had the lock been installed properly (IE no slack in the system) it wouldn't have been easy to remove it with no signs of tampering. However it wasn't installed properly. Incidentally, one of the easiest ways to solve this problem is to take a drill bit and to strip the head of the screws. This leaves only manually forcing of the lock to open it, which takes a lot of effort if you're using 3 inch screws through a proper stud.

Re:Install PAC-MAN on Sequoia voting machine w/o breaking ta... by ovi256 on Monday August 23, 2010 @12:35PM (#1627204)
Could very well be security theater. Or maybe the researchers missed another layer of seals that protected the screws.