EDIT: Thanks for everything CoreOS team, and congrats on the sale! This immutable distribution was a breath of fresh air in a crowded "enterprise / kitchen sink" space.
I was a big fan of Red Hat back when they were leading the way in the early days of linux with things like application packaging, and a general vision towards simplicity. This is the same thing that attracted me to CoreOS' elegant engineering. I don't object to companies focusing more on revenue, as Red Hat's Enterprise move clearly was. But I cannot abide the erosion of vision in pursuit of profits. In particular when elegance and simplicity are replaced with complexity, and user hostile design to increase switching costs.
I realize there is probably a natural selection process at work here, and user hostile design is clearly a more profitable strategy, but I can't keep from hoping that one of these times the well engineered, simplicity focused, user centric design will find the right business model and survive... vision intact.
The split of Fedora and RHEL was a great move for users IMHO. Serving the needs of desktop users and enterprise (servers) with the same distro just isn't doable. They have wildly different and incompatible needs. I've been a happy fedora user for years.
Red Hat has also done tons of things that directly fly in the face of a company seeking profits. Like continuing to release your full source code, even when punks like Oracle just rip it off and sell it for less. They even directly support the CentOS project, even tho it cannabalizes people who might otherwise buy RHEL.
Red Hat is an amazing company that has poured countless millions of dollars in both money and time to make all of our lives better. Even the Gnome project may not be a thing without Red Hat's contributions, and everybody on linux benefits from that work. I wish there were more companies out there like Red Hat.
Disclaimer: I have zero affiliation with Red Hat. I'm just an appreciative observer and beneficiary.
“Free taster” is certainly an apt anaology, I know there’s plenty of people who will never buy the supported products but there are likely a lot of other organizations like us that decide to buy in AFTER trying the upstream projects first.
Red Hat really believes in the power of open source. It must be a great place to work at.
[1]: https://github.com/ansible/awx I wish more companies had that kind of courage.
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/coreos-user/GR4YlF2c...
I'm using NixOS happily since 2014 after getting messed up in pacman dependencies on Arch and haven't looked back. But their too radical shift from LSB makes for a less attractive enterprise story. Hopefully GuixSD[1] can plug that hole due to the GNU brand as it has been progressing nicely.
We've also built https://github.com/vpsfreecz/vpsadminos recently which is based on not-os / NixOS
Also Atomic is more than just an OS; it's a system of reliable upgrades / versions switching. So it's got something in common with NixOS.
I used to be a gnome foundation member (I trained Andrea Veri on the sysadmin team who trained Patrick Uiterwijk, the current lead sysadmin for GNOME) when Colin Watson wrote OSTree. He was talking about it and some of the ideas from it at the KDE/GNOME desktop summit in Berlin (2011ish) in some of the comments after https://desktopsummit.org/program/sessions/improving-how-we-...
At the following Boston (GNOME) developer summit one of the big conversational points sans Ubuntu pulling away from GNOME to build Unity was the idea of GNOME OS because Linux was hard then. He built rpm-ostree after that, and it was after CoreOS as a distro was a thing.
rpm-ostree's first commit was Dec 21, 2013: https://github.com/projectatomic/rpm-ostree/commit/958dfa435...
https://coreos.com/blog/coreos-fourth-birthday CoreOS as a company was created on July 13th, 2013.
TL;DNR: It's complicated, but Atomic as a distro most definitely does not predate ContainerLinux as rpm-ostree didn't exist when CoreOS the company was founded.
Forgive me for poking around a little more but I like reading computer history. That rpm-ostree first commit was an import from something called pkgsys-ostree. The first commit in pkgsys-ostree was only a little earlier; Aug 2013.
[1]: https://nixos.org/nix/ [2]: https://ostree.readthedocs.io/
CoreOS = 2013 Atomic host = 2014
But Atomic was architected as containers infrastructure and is/was a direct competitor to CoreOS and other lightweight container OSes.
People in the desktop team had been working on read-only root OS's for a long time, and it was only at a certain point that RH management bought off on forming a product/spin. But to say that work only started once Atomic was a thing would be inaccurate.
It's probably fair to say that ChromeOS/CoreOS lit a match under some upper management though.
Congratulations to the CoreOS team, by the way.
Also CoreUpdate is based on Chrome and ChromeOS but it's the only os that integrated it nicely. Running CoreOS is way simpler to manage than most other distro's because of that fact.
basically on coreos I don't need to run "rpm-ostree" to have an updated system. it is actually updated automatically.
It's also open source
But yeh, Matchbox + Ignition for automatically bringing up configured nodes with iPXE was an extremely powerful combination. However, those ideas can be easily ported over or already exist through cloud-init.
So for bare metal use cases, I'm EOL?
we actually play around with tectonic at the moment.
Could you or anyone else recommend any literature on ContainerLinux boot image and its use of ChromeOS as a foundation?
https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/faq-red-hat-acquire-coreos
Container Linux and its investment in container-optimized Linux and automated “over the air” software updates are complementary to Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Red Hat Enterprise Linux Atomic Host and Red Hat’s integrated container runtime and platform management capabilities. Red Hat Enterprise Linux’s content, the foundation of our application ecosystem will remain our only Linux offering. Whereas, some of the delivery mechanisms pioneered by Container Linux will be reviewed by a joint integration team and reconciled with Atomic.