People would gladly accept a corrupt Democrat over a Republican and vice versa purely based on political lines.
To contrast that with partisan affiliation when it comes to national politics, the last time NYC went for a Republican presidential candidate was 1924 for Calvin Coolidge.
You aren't talking about "let's ban smoking and soft drinks" bloomberg are you?
There, fixed that for you.
Look, I'm very progressive, but we need to firmly stand behind "innocent until proven guilty" especially when it is so easy to create a slander campaign against a political opponent. And, yes, even the democrats are capable of that.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-past-the-post_voting
Approval voting is the future of democracy, if we can manage to get our elected officials to change the law out of their favor. Semi-direct democracy would be a nice addition, too.
Approval voting is good for lots of things, but public elections by secret ballot aren't among them, because outside if open ballots and some kind of defined consequence of a particular vote, “approve” vs. “disspprove” doesn't mean the same thing on different ballots.
For single-winner elections Condorcet-satisfying methods are pretty much the gold standard; but minimizing single-winner elections for ones that can use proportional systems (not necessarily party-list; candidate-centered options like STV are viable) is also an important technique.
http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html
Approval Voting is extremely competitive in terms of performance, and _dead simple_.
There is actually a theorem that Approval Voting will always elect the Condorcet winner anyway, given plausible models of voter strategy. http://scorevoting.net/AppCW
There are lots of other problems with Condorcet, enumerated here. http://scorevoting.net/CondorcetExec.html
This particular argument is pretty devastating. http://scorevoting.net/FishburnAntiC
> minimizing single-winner elections for ones that can use proportional systems is also an important technique.
This is really not well supported. Even compared to the horrendously bad Plurality Voting system, PR has had mixed results. http://scorevoting.net/PropRep.html
No comparison exists between the best PR methods and the best non-PR methods, so it's still very much an open question.
And you may have to get Score Voting or Approval Voting to get PR in the USA anyway. http://asitoughttobe.com/2010/07/18/score-voting/
> Approval voting is good for lots of things, but public elections by secret ballot aren't among them
A significant fraction of the world's major electoral procedures experts support Approval Voting. E.g. www.electology.org/approval-voting
Circa 2011, a group of 22 voting experts researched 18 different systems, and selected Approval Voting as best. http://www.lse.ac.uk/website-archive/newsAndMedia/newsArchiv...
I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on the book "Gaming the Vote" by William Poundstone.
What such simulations consistently miss is the information problem facing range voting (approval voting has a similar problem; preference systems don't entirely lack information problems but they are much smaller.) And that is that, contrary to simulations where preferences are based on quantified utility and there is a clear and consistent relationship between that and ballot markings on a numerically scored ballots, real world preferences are ordinal preferences which, while they do vary in intensity, are not consistently quantifiable, resulting in radically different score ratings for the same preferences by different voters. (There's quite a lot of research showing that numerical rating systems in all domains have this problem.)
> Approval Voting is extremely competitive in terms of performance, and _dead simple_.
Approval Voting again suffers from an information problem like range voting; there's no consistent mapping from actual preferences to ballot markings. This is easily solved if you are doing open-ballot voting for a group activity—eithet treating “approve” as a binding commitment to participate if the approved action is chosen or “disapprove” as a binding opt-out nearly resolved the information problem. In scenarios like that, Approval is a great system.
Likewise, Range Voting is great in a scenario where your score is a commitment to contribute an amount of resources proportional to the rating if the option is chosen.
But when you are voting with secret ballots in public elections, these information-problem mitigations don't apply.
> No comparison exists between the best PR methods and the best non-PR methods, so it's still very much an open question.
Comparisons in actual government satisfaction between countries do exist and show that proportionality of outcomes is key. See, e.g., Lijphart’s Patterns of Democracy. The absence of flawed, limited, abstract mathematical comparisons that ignore key features of the real world is not particularly a problem.
> And you may have to get Score Voting or Approval Voting to get PR in the USA anyway.
The article making that case considers the federal situation ignoring the possibility of bottom-up reform from the states, which is possible because many states permit the citizenry to bypass the politicians to institute reforms from the ballot box directly. And bottom up reform is desirable anyway.
> A significant fraction of the world's major electoral procedures experts support Approval Voting. E.g. www.electology.org/approval-voting
I don't see any support for that claim on that page.
> I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on the book "Gaming the Vote" by William Poundstone.
I haven't read it, but unless the book's own promotional copy substantially misrepresents the argument it makes, I can't imagine I'm missing much of value. Arguing that US Presidential elections going to a candidate other than the most preferred is due primarily to spoiler effects on simple majority elections and that a solution to that would satisfy both the left in the right ignores completely the existence, original purpose, and continued structural effect of the Electoral College.
I work in healthcare and we all know WHY it costs outrageous amount here in the states, but nobody wants to fix it because EVERYBODY has his or her finger in the pie.
Yes, price gouging is a problem, but it's only side effect of a bad system. Healthcare is expensive because there are too many damn fingers in the pie, and nobody wants to pull his or hers out first.
Doctors, hospitals, private insurance, drug distributors, medical device makers, lawyers, pharma, pharmacists, physical therapy center. Guess what all these entities have? IT, HR, Sales & marketing, etc.
So many people seem to always have a point about "Oh if we just moved everything to medicare" or "if we just repealed obamacare" as if there is a silver bullet.
The only thing i think we can know for sure about why the US healthcare system is expensive, it's because of what you said, so many special interests groups that all work within the system and gouge each other every day to keep their heads above water.
Why does Google not want to make all salary and compensation information public? Why do insurance companies want to keep their contracts and payouts with hospitals secret? There is zero reason for these things to be secret. These things should be required to be public.
We can't fix problems if we can't see them.
EG: We find out that 30% of road costs are being wasted by nepotism/contracts given to mates. I just can't imagine how it would work that someone could point it out and anyone would even care.
If the county hired him, he wouldn't get any coverage.
If the state government did, they would probably just bury it to cover their own ass.
The federal government maybe, but then you have issue of jurisdiction and dealing with 50+ audits at once and trying to explain to every state voter about what is happening in their state.
Only other option is independent watchdogs or companies but it still like it would be almost impossible to be even get a proper view of the real corruption from that angle as the government would never let you close enough to the deal making process.
In the end, I really don't know how you can overcome the losses due to government corruption unless voters make significant changes in their behaviour. That or just wait for a whistleblower to blow the lid off it all in some spectacular way.
So people in Upstate New York don't care about mass transit in NYC, and so the representatives they elect to NY state government don't care about it.
Public transit honestly is not even on my radar of issues I care about, because where I live it makes no sense at all.
The city I live in (Los Angeles) covers an area 10x bigger than Vancouver. Even when you compare the metro areas, Vancouver is ~4 times denser
If it were truly the case that rural voters down play the importance of intercity public transit, then Vancouver should have the same dismal public transport priorities that plague NYC. In contrast, Vancouver has a long history of progressive public transit initiatives despite being attached to a very large and sparsely populated province which suggests that NYCs problem isn't the upstate voters.
That would make sense if there were no political subdivisions below the state level with the power to tax and spend, but there are. NYC has both its own revenue sources, including income, sales, and special excise taxes, and its own (quite vast) governmental apparatus with which to spend that revenue in the service of its residents. They ought to have more than the tools required to get projects done -- it's a government on scale with many smaller countries!
NYC also has structures in place like the Port Authority, set up specifically to solve intra-jurisdictional problems (and IIRC with its own funding from tolls).
None of this seems to have helped stop costs from spiraling out of control.
Other first-world countries in Europe and Asia manage to create comprehensive public transit systems cheaper and faster than the US does -- yet they also have environmental reviews, safety standards, unions, contractors, etc.
They are able to do it simply because the people running the city fear that they won't be reelected if they fail to provide comprehensive, properly functioning public transit. Voters there believe that providing public transit is one of the basic duties of government. It's amazing how streamlined a public project can become if the politicians fear for their jobs.
In the US, voters don't punish politicians for problems with public transit, even in places like New York where most people use it. So it's no surprise that it sucks.