News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Follower Factory by djsumdog on Saturday January 27, 2018 @08:31PM (#16249175)
> much like Gmail has mostly solved spam.

Gmail has not solved spam. Gmail and Microsoft dump so much legitimate e-mail that it's basically made e-mail totally unusable:

http://penguindreams.org/blog/how-google-and-microsoft-made-...

Re:The Follower Factory by fjsolwmv on Saturday January 27, 2018 @09:40PM (#16249451)
No they don't. They, like most abuse sensitive recipients, don't accept mail from small indie servers, so people know not to use small indie servers to send mail.
Re:The Follower Factory by fyfy18 on Sunday January 28, 2018 @02:16AM (#16250239)
I’ve read this a lot, often as a counter argument to running your own mail servers, and I believe it to be mostly FUD.

I run a small SaaS and it sends out quite a lot of notification emails to customers (they are paying me for these emails, they aren’t spam or newsletters). I was originally using SendGrid but their deliverability rates were pretty bad and I was about to hit a ceiling for my plan, which would meant the monthly cost would more than double, which was unaffordable for me.

I decided to try setting up my own mail server. Everyone said don’t do it, you emails won’t be delivered, it’s too much work, etc. I setup a VPS with OVH as I’ve heard their policies regarding email spam are pretty strict (I contacted them before to clarify - if they find out you are spamming they cut your off ASAP to protect their other customers). The IP I got was actually on one blacklist, but I got that resolved in a few days.

The deliverability rate was better than SendGrid and it was costing me 1/10th of the price. One thing that I would assume helped is the domain had already been in use for a few years, and I setup proper DKIM and SPF records.

The server has been running for a year and a half now, and the only bounces I get are due to invalid or suspended email accounts. Most of my customers are small to medium sized businesses, a lot of which run their own Exchange servers - with SendGrid those were usually the ones who were bouncing my mail due to being on a blacklist. Now admittedly just being accepted doesn’t mean it is ending up in a users inbox, but I haven’t had any complaints from paying customers.

Re:The Follower Factory by bzbarsky on Sunday January 28, 2018 @01:25AM (#16250121)
It's not just small indie servers. They do "reputation scoring" of senders that penalize them for things like sending plaintext mail. See https://groups.google.com/forum/#!msg/mozilla.governance/WWK... for more details of one example.
Re:The Follower Factory by cookiecaper on Sunday January 28, 2018 @01:27AM (#16250124)
Right! We can't trust those "small indie servers" on the world wide web. Who knows where they've been?! Make sure you use mail servers furnished by Google, Microsoft, and other NSA-approved facilitators. They only cost $10 / mo / user, that is easily affordable for anyone who is not a Russian agent tricking the unwashed masses into preventing Hillary Clinton from ascending to her rightful place as ----- errrm, uh, from "corrupting democracy".

Any non-Google, non-Microsoft mailers will be blocked, lest users be asked to renew their VIAGRA prescription from a Canadian pharmacy, or a non-compliant political message be received. It's for your own good, citizen!

Thank you, wise and great Google! Thank you, wise and great Microsoft! I wouldn't know how to use this free, non-controlled computer network without your benevolent work!

unsnark: Seriously, the way that Google et al have captured "anti-spam" mechanisms and converted them into "pay a big company for your mail" mechanisms is extremely sad, and speaks to the true forces at work behind all the warm and fuzzies about an "open web".

Re:The Follower Factory by lucb1e on Sunday January 28, 2018 @05:02PM (#16253852)
Even if that were true, then your parent's statement still holds: "basically made e-mail totally unusable"

If it's down to a few big senders and the rest is rejected, they might as well get rid of SMTP, close it off, and just talk a proprietary protocol among each other.

Re:The Follower Factory by pilif on Sunday January 28, 2018 @02:21AM (#16250256)
I'm not convinced about this generalization. Case in point is the mail relay server of our company which definitely counts as a small indie server and whose email is accepted and not marked as spam.

Of course we have configured SPF, DKIM and a proper reverse dns lookup on both ipv4 and IPv6, but that’s just being a good email-citizen anyways.