News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by js8 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:12PM (#16233024)
"The problem, according to Wray, is that law enforcement is stymied by phone encryption, which is now widespread."

Not American, but isn't criminality in the U.S. like at about lowest point in history? Is there some actual evidence that the lack of ability to do mass surveillance is somehow making criminal investigations less effective?

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by heroprotagonist on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:29PM (#16233204)
Maybe that's the problem? That they want more criminals?

I mean, it's always been a bit skewed. Example, Nixon targeting blacks, hippies, and the anti-war left: https://www.cnn.com/2016/03/23/politics/john-ehrlichman-rich...

There's an intimidation factor behind the thought that the government can read any communication you make, if you give them cause, even if you aren't doing anything wrong.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by danjoc on Thursday January 25, 2018 @07:39PM (#16236137)
>Nixon targeting blacks, hippies, and the anti-war left

According to Dan Baum, after Ehrlichman died, years after Ehrlichman supposedly told him. Furthermore, even if Ehrlichman did tell him this, Ehrlichman was convicted of perjury, conspiracy, and obstruction of justice.

Hearsay, from a convicted liar, retold by a biased individual with no apparent proof other than his own word.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by heroprotagonist on Thursday January 25, 2018 @08:11PM (#16236278)
> Hearsay, from a convicted liar, retold by a biased individual with no apparent proof other than his own word.

This could also be posed as:

> statement from at-the-time President's chief domestic advisor to a journalist during an interview, in 1994

But yeah, he's dead, and the fact that the reporter took so long to make it public makes it suspicious and doubtable.

Your criticism is fair, but surely you can think of a few other examples if you dislike this one? MLK wiretapping, McCarthyism, etc?

If not, and you are up for a read, check out this 69 page document from the ACLU:

https://www.aclu.org/other/unleashed-and-unaccountable-fbis-...

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by danjoc on Friday January 26, 2018 @05:54PM (#16243560)
You already destroyed your credibility with the Ehrlichman point. If you try to mislead people, you lose trust.

I don't need to read the aclu document. I'm not arguing with you. I'm pointing out that the moment you reference Ehrlichman in any way, you will lose all your credibility again. You do damage to your own causes when you try to mislead people like this.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by heroprotagonist on Monday January 29, 2018 @04:17AM (#16256359)
It wasn't an attempt to mislead. You're reading way too much intent into this. I conceded your point, there's no need to linger and dig it in when it doesn't advance the conversation.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:26PM (#16233172)
> Not American, but isn't criminality in the U.S. like at about lowest point in history?

It's generally been declining since the trailing edge of the Baby Boomers got out of the prime criminality age range.

But the demographically (and possibly also lead-exposure) driven “crime wave” was a boon to political support for law enforcement and authoritarian politicians, so both have learned that selling the idea of rampant crime is a good way to get what they want politically.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by iNate2000 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @06:17PM (#16235676)
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by cat199 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:46PM (#16233353)
> It's generally been declining since the trailing edge of the Baby Boomers got out of the prime criminality age range.

Not sure if you are making a claim, but I don't really think this is generational other than a coincidence in technological timing - the time you are talking about is the 90's-2000s, which is when improved surveillance techniques, information sharing databases, and other deterrents became more possible and widely used. At that time most of the people on the ground would be gen-Xers (think 21 jumpstreet, colors, new jack city, boyz n the hood, etc, usa wise)

Also, timing wise, the cold war ended and so along with it much of the foreign funny money on all sides for subversive activities, and police spending went up bigtime in most areas..

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:03PM (#16233523)
> Not sure if you are making a claim, but I don't really think this is generational other than a coincidence in technological timing - the time you are talking about is the 90's-2000s, which is when improved surveillance techniques, information sharing databases, and other deterrents became more possible and widely used.

As you say, most of that became available in the (mid-to-late-) 1990s and into the 2000s, the crime peak happened in the early 1990s (violent crime specifically in 1991.)

There's something of a demographic case to be made (not so much generational as the fact that the Baby Boom was a boom, and a big demographic bulge going through that age range has an impact), there's a plausible, and arguably stronger, lead exposure case to be made (the decline, and the preceding rise, closely tracks the drop off, and preceding rise, in use of leaded gasoline.)

The variety of intended policy mitigations adopted well after the peak certainly didn't cause the drop, and probably have no-to-minimal impact.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by jessaustin on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:46PM (#16233937)
Especially since most comparable nations displayed the same drop in crime over the same period, without the out-of-control enforcement increases we suffered in USA.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by bitcurious on Thursday January 25, 2018 @05:18PM (#16235245)
I would hesitate to attribute the decline to Big Brother when there is already a widely accepted hypothesis explaining both the increase and the decline.

tl;dr: Lead exposure has been shown to stunt intellectual development and increase aggression. With the 50s came the personal automobile, powered by leaded gasoline. Crime rose as that generation grew to adulthood. In the 70s use of lead in gasoline declined due to the clean air act. As that generation grew to adulthood crime rates fell. In the 90s the use of lead was banned. That generation is reaching adulthood now.

Lead polution peaked in 1973, violent crime peaked in 1993.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lead-crime_hypothesis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead

https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2016/02/lead-exposur...

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ams6110 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:53PM (#16233423)
So, we're back to what, the mid 1990s? Before anyone had a phone that stored any information at all? They should be grateful for the few decades of easy work. Now it's back to being real detectives.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by stanleydrew on Thursday January 25, 2018 @04:42PM (#16234952)
Not exactly. We used to have to keep many more paper records, which are really hard to manually encrypt/decrypt. Those were easily available to law enforcement.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by jessaustin on Thursday January 25, 2018 @05:40PM (#16235398)
The fact that paper records make many things more difficult meant that many fewer records were kept. For example, no one had a paper record of your exact location (or rather that of a flattish oblong chunk of plastic and metal that was always in your pocket), all day long every day of the year. No one had a record of which article in the newspaper you read first, how long you spent reading it, which article you read next, etc. No one had an audio recording of everything uttered in earshot of a stupid-looking speaker that sits in the kitchen of every bored housewife in the nation.

All of those records exist now, and LEOs should have access to precisely none of them.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by murftown on Friday January 26, 2018 @12:55AM (#16237295)
I'm pretty sure people leak a lot more data into the "cloud", through their SMS messages, emails, apps, etc., than they used to keep in their desk drawer. On average I presume that there is more for law enforcement to go on these days than before technology got so pervasive.

And at least if they search your desk you know about it. The idea that people can go behind your back and look at your info is disconcerting.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by DarronWyke on Thursday January 25, 2018 @04:31PM (#16234871)
Pretty much this. Law enforcement is trying to get their monetary share from crime (or "crime" depending upon how you look at it), and anything they can do to make that easier they want.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by da_chicken on Thursday January 25, 2018 @05:07PM (#16235148)
> Not American, but isn't criminality in the U.S. like at about lowest point in history?

Sort of. We're approaching 1960s level of crime, but it was lower in the early 60s and 50s. I don't know if we tracked it before then. Crime rates, including homicide rates, are about half of what they were 20 years ago, but about 20% higher than they were in the mid 50s.

> Is there some actual evidence that the lack of ability to do mass surveillance is somehow making criminal investigations less effective?

No. Police investigations still tend to use things called search warrants and interrogation of witnesses and suspects to acquire incriminating evidence. Mass surveillance is very expensive in order to be effective.

I have family involved in law enforcement and they are able to request access to stingrays from state or federal police, but their use is fairly limited and still requires a search warrant in many cases. I don't believe it's gone to SCotUS yet, but many appellate courts have ruled that you've got to have one.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by toyg on Thursday January 25, 2018 @06:14PM (#16235658)
> it was lower in the early 60s and 50s

But there is reason to believe pre-1980 statistics had a huge problem of under-reporting more or less everywhere, especially in countries as big (and relatively desolate, at the time) as the US. Even just collating reliable statistics is a challenge today, let alone in the '50s.

Nowadays we almost have the opposite problem, with cellphones and vague laws resulting in increased reporting of entire classes of crimes. So having a declining trend despite these development, is either a huge win or proof that statistics can be tweaked at will (as The Wire taught us, and we all know The Wire is all true... /s )

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by da_chicken on Friday January 26, 2018 @08:47AM (#16239049)
I agree the older crime statistics are a little suspect, but it's all we really have to go on. And, yeah, the US was a much bigger and much newer nation back then. The Apache Wars and other associated wars against the native Americans didn't wrap up until 1924! Crime statistics just weren't that important.

> as The Wire taught us, and we all know The Wire is all true... /s

I could never get in to The Wire.

The very first scene of the very first episode is a courtroom where a woman changes her testimony on the stand, and the prosecutor doesn't: a) show the woman her sworn deposition, b) request an immediate continuance (surprise testimony is one of the things that warrants one), and c) threaten and then carry out charges of perjury against the woman for refusing to testify according to her statement. Instead, the prosecutor keeps asking questions over and over, driving into the jury's mind the woman's changed testimony. I'm not a lawyer, but I feel like I know something of courtroom procedure. This was just so unbelievable that it made me angry that the writers expected me to believe it. It would be like someone hacking a System/360 Model 30 from their iPhone in 10 seconds.

I understand it was for dramatic purposes to lead to the other witness's murder, but it broke my suspension of disbelief so badly I had a hard time watching the rest of the episode. I don't remember if I ever watched the second episode.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by toyg on Friday January 26, 2018 @12:21PM (#16240930)
Sorry to hear, but please do yourself a favour and give it a second chance! As my sarcasm indicates, way too many people think It's All Exactly Like That (which of course it isn't, as you just demonstrated), but it's a really good series that makes some very interesting points on the fabric of modern society.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by e12e on Friday January 26, 2018 @09:42AM (#16239489)
> Mass surveillance is very expensive in order to be effective.

Not if done right, according to William Binney who worked on designing the systems that eventually (d)evolved to what Snowden leaked information about.

That was re: (actual) national security - but the same mechanisms are at play: if you can record what you need to achieve a stated goal for 250m - why do that if you can spend N billion on a less efficient system?

Compared to manual policing, automated surveillance is a really cheap way to run a police state.

Now, if the goal is to minimise crime, as opposed to maximise catching criminals (which really should be a means to an end, not a goal in itself) - better welfare, psychic health services and after school activities are probably the way to go...

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by da_chicken on Friday January 26, 2018 @11:27AM (#16240391)
> psychic health services

Mental health services?

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by e12e on Friday January 26, 2018 @06:16PM (#16243676)
Sorry, yes.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by anfedorov on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:15PM (#16233058)
Source?
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ch4s3 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:53PM (#16233418)
Crime rates are the lowest they've been since 1970 at least, [1] and murder rates are the lowest since WWII[2].

[1] http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/427758/careful-panic-vi...

[2] https://www.factcheck.org/2016/07/dueling-claims-on-crime-tr...

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by anfedorov on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:56PM (#16233464)
Violent crime, gun crime, murder rates.

What other kinds of crime are there, and how would you measure how much of it there is?

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by maxander on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:06PM (#16233547)
What other kinds of crime are there due to which we're willing to give up our right to privacy? Several, perhaps, but remember that this conversation is happening while we're discussing a way in which too much law enforcement has significant downsides to a free and happy society. We wouldn't let the government monitor everyone constantly in order to catch shoplifters.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by philipkglass on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:36PM (#16233842)
I suspect that the FBI antipathy to encryption, if it's not fundamentally irrational, is actually about white collar crimes: trade secrets theft, money laundering, insider trading, tax evasion... Violent crime leaves abundant physical traces. White collar crimes may sometimes be un-prosecutable or even undetectable without access to electronic records.

They know that "outlaw secure encryption to stop inside traders" is going to be an even tougher sell than "outlaw secure encryption to stop murderers," so they try to make an illogical argument involving scary criminals instead of a stronger argument with not-scary criminals.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by js8 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:45PM (#16234488)
My first guess, when I posed the original question, was organized crime. People who do organized crime would be the ones to benefit the most from encrypted phones. But anecdotally, it seems to me that organized crime is down in the U.S. too. I might be wrong, that's why I asked for evidence.

The white collar crime, yeah, some forms of it might benefit from encrypted communication. But again, where is the evidence? Is the tax evasion (non-institutionalized) skyrocketing?

The whole claim is just very suspicious. I think there is so much open data today that even with encrypted phones it's much harder to leave less trace than in the past.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by philipkglass on Thursday January 25, 2018 @04:26PM (#16234824)
I too suspect that the FBI's antipathy to encryption is disproportionate to how much it actually hinders law enforcement. But if there were some real reason for the FBI to be this hostile to encryption, I don't think it can be about violent crimes. It has to be more subtle crimes that don't leave physical evidence.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by cuckcuckspruce on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:04PM (#16234089)
How many bankers have gone to jail for crashing the US economy?

The FBI doesn't give a shit as long as it's the anus of the average citizen being ravaged. They only care when it's against the 1%.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by jessaustin on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:53PM (#16233999)
This would be more plausible if federal prosecutors ever prosecuted "white collar" crime in general, rather than only in particular situations to defend the commercial interests of big donors. To see this, look at how many insider trading investigations are targeted at randoms who occasionally learn some privileged information, compared to those targeted at senior executives who bathe in it all day long. The ratio of bitcoin convicts to great recession convicts is still infinite.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by Zak on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:31PM (#16233794)
Property crime is also down to around the rate of the mid 1960s.

http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=property+crime+rate

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:35PM (#16233831)
Fraud is probably greatly increased.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by Retric on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:26PM (#16234307)
Fraud has largely moved outside of the US as Fraud takes a lot of legwork.

In the 60's you also got a lot more check fraud. Which is similar to CC fraud, but that's again for more global.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ben_w on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:26PM (#16234310)
Opinion or rational deduction from evidence?
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ch4s3 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:02PM (#16233508)
Well, people tend to still report other crimes, like property crime, and police still investigate them. Sure, reporting rates aren't perfect but you can still draw meaningful conclusions from trends. I'm not going to do the leg work for you, but almost all types of crime are declining in the US and have been for decades.

There's no data I've seen that suggest anything other than a broad decades long drop in crime.

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ben_w on Thursday January 25, 2018 @03:46PM (#16234494)
If “attempting to access a computer system without authorisation” counts, a former aquaintance reported over 24k such attempts per day. Against just his private server.

While I count all attacks from a single process to be “one attack” and “one crime”, others may not.

Then there’s “unlawful pornography”, which varies wildly by jurisdiction — when a friend pointed me at fetlife, one of my thoughts was that the entire site is illegal to view in the UK unless you disable images (I’m no lawyer though).

There are probably a lot of other things describable as “conspiracy to X”, but that’s a guess on my part.

(I think there may be a lot of victimless crimes too, but that’s a different topic).

Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by pdpi on Thursday January 25, 2018 @04:28PM (#16234841)
There's white collar crime. There's several non-violent variations on theft. Loan sharking isn't violent per se (though usually comes with an unhealthy side order of violent crime).
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by IncRnd on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:45PM (#16233341)
The source is the first sentence in third paragraph of the article that you commented.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by anfedorov on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:00PM (#16233487)
Link? Curious how one would go about measuring, e.g., criminal insider trading facilitated by wide-spread e2e encryption.
Re:Senator asks FBI director to name the cryptographers who ... by ch4s3 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @02:07PM (#16233562)
What evidence do you have to suggest the existence of this happening at any scale?

The problem with large scale conspiracies is that they require a lot of people, and eventually someone slips up. This sort of crime is the bread and butter of the SEC, and they aren't making any claims about it increasing.