News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by dmm on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:01AM (#16213569)
The tax situation is interesting. Many believe that you owe taxes as soon as the funds for a bitcon fork are available to you. For someone with bitcoin in a private wallet that's instantly. For someone with bitcoin in an exchange that's whenever the exchange implements the coin or you withdraw to a private wallet.

For example bitcoin cash was forked August 1, 2017 but coinbase didn't implement it until December 19, 2017.

https://bitcoin.tax/blog/how-to-tax-bitcoin-cash-bch/

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by nokcha on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:16AM (#16214183)
>Many believe that you owe taxes as soon as the funds for a bitcon fork are available to you.

I think that belief is mistaken. (1) Suppose Bitcoin has a contentious fork into two chains, say BitcoinA and BitcoinB. The supporters of each chain claim that their chain is the "true" Bitcoin. Before the split, you had 1 btc worth $10k, and after the fork, you have 1 btcA worth $5k and 1 btcB worth $5k. Which of the two chains do you owe taxes on? (2) Even if a hard-forked chain is treated as a new asset instead of a split of an old asset, it shouldn't be taxed until the user actually exercises control over it. In order to control funds on a new hard fork, generally the user must take the risky action of installing new (potentially malicious) software and importing their private keys --- this would seem to be a "substantial limitation or restriction" under 26 CFR 1.451-2(a).

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by dmm on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:41AM (#16214378)
That's an interesting position. This is definitely an area that needs more clarification. I do think that treating forks like income is the most conservative interpretation and the one least likely to result in trouble from the IRS.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by raybayfay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:51PM (#16216217)
Really? So you're going to declare income on the 20 hard forks in 2017 (many were scams / questionable value... if any, also not listed on US exchanges), and on the 50 hard forks this year? Don't you think this is a bit insane??
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by jebeng on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @02:07PM (#16216399)
There should be some sort of value threshold or something similar. If your holdings of the hard fork's resulting coin is worth less than some trivial amount, then it shouldn't be necessary. But if for some crazy reason the market decides that another joke like Bitcoin Cash is actually worth some significant amount, then it seems hard to argue that this should somehow be immune to tax.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by raybayfay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @07:21PM (#16219219)
Sure I agree that there be a way to differentiate, but the only reasonable approach is that the new fork coins should be unrealized gains until when (or if) you use them (aka trade/sell). It has a 0 cost basis until proven otherwise. Seems simple; meets the requirements; stops bad actors. Only negative is IRS may only get long-term cap gains if someone holds it for a long-time.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by Cyberdog on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:29AM (#16213754)
It illustrates how ludicrous the idea of being taxed for a fork is (along with taxes on crypto not exchanged for fiat in general). I had never even heard of most of the forks discussed in this article. Were I a holder of BTC, how am I supposed to pay taxes on the "wealth" "generated" from forks I didn't even know existed?
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:39AM (#16213827)
The idea of crypto taxation (besides forks) is same as stocks. Thus, selling crypto for fiat is same as selling crypto to buy another crypto tax wise.

Taxation in general is not a happy event, but it is consistent in this case.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by raybayfay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:53PM (#16216241)
Once again - you expect people to somehow magically track the value on 20 hard forks in 2017, many are scam / not listed on US sites / unclear value, and on the 50 hard forks in 2018? Not possible - not feasible - and goes counter to what many EAs and CPAs are advising their clients. People need to stop giving "couch" advise without considering the consequences.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:05PM (#16218224)
Best effort. If you went the lengths to "cash it out" because it was free money, you should pay someone to keep track of it for you, if you don't intend to.

Wasn't the whole point of bitcoin that it was auditable? IF you know and want to use a fork for something, you can figure out the exact price fork has happened.

IF you don't know, you have plausible deniability.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by raybayfay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @07:24PM (#16219237)
Responded somewhere else; but to be fair hard forks should be unrealized gain with 0 cap gains. IF/when someone wants to cash out is when they should pay the tax. It resolves the bad actor issue with scam coins; meets the need to pay tax on gains and ultimately saves everyone in bitcoin land (or other crypto for that matter) from inadvertently not declaring income. It's a win win for everyone; including the IRS. This is the most common sense approach and it stuns me that many of the couch / tax advisers are positioning otherwise.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @08:56PM (#16219717)
I agree with this, and i hope this is how hard forks are taxed. It makes sense to me.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by kmkemp on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:55PM (#16216260)
Also, many cryptos' primary use case is a replacement for fiat that isn't centrally controlled. Saying that you shouldn't pay taxes on crypto to crypto is similar to saying that you shouldn't pay taxes at all.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by Cyberdog on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @03:05PM (#16217096)
Tax avoidance is one of the benefits of using cryptocurrency as a currency. Yeah, I'll say it.

But what is bitcoin except a database plus some math equations? By "owning" bitcoin, you have a cryptographic key which lets you do certain operations on the database. At what point does this all get abstracted far enough from real money that it becomes ludicrous to tax it?

Obviously, the US government and most cryptocurrency users have widely differing opinions on that.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:09PM (#16218256)
With the same logic, my stocks in my brokerage is an entry in the database where i hold the password. I don't ever recall owning a paper stock, for example.

If i keep it in the brokerage, without withdrawing the cash, why do i pay taxes? That sounds stupid right? Then the next thing you know, people sell each other stocks in exchange for goods.

"Plumbing service stock" on a broker, if you buy it, you get legal right to have plumbing service at your house free of charge. This way you can keep everything in brokerages. Of course there are flaws with the argument, but saying "crypto to crypto isn't taxable" ignores the fact that USD taxation happens based on USD.

PS: while i said usd, i mistakenly wrote USDT, which was very ironic haha.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:04PM (#16218216)
Most cryptocurrency users are chasing their own moon. I agree that it's not practical to do book keeping if you want to buy real world goods with crypto (you cannot keep calculating capital gains everytime you buy a coffee with it), but that's not the common use today _anyway_.

This is also the exact reason why it's taxed the way its taxed. There's no way government is gonna let you build wealth without paying taxes.

Private key is surely a database password that lets you do certain operations, but that exact feature make it an asset. As long as you can buy "things" that has value with it, it's a capital you need to pay taxes on.

It's hard, but it's what it is.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by Cyberdog on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:11PM (#16218276)
I personally think cryptocurrency is more interesting as a currency than as an investment. I want "Satoshi's vision" to catch on.

But you're right, the reality is that many are using it as an investment instead, so now, I suppose, it's being regulated like one. Unfortunately, at the same time that we solve some of the problems making usage as a currency impractical (even if one of those solutions is just Bitcoin Core becoming an outdated relic), regulations treating it as an investment will hamper its adoption.

Oh well. I have faith the tech will win in the end.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by tehlike on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @05:37PM (#16218528)
I am all for parts of satoshis vision. I wish it was somehow universally accepted, so i could give my dollars and get them burned (legally, somehow), and can keep transacting with my digital coin.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by yock on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:43AM (#16213871)
This seems to be a greater indictment of taxation in general rather than the notion of an asset created to represent something of value in the market. An unscrupulous state actor could manipulate this system to their advantage.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by pjc50 on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:22AM (#16213703)
Isn't it treated as an unrealised capital gain?
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by bpicolo on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:42AM (#16213858)
New tax bill specifies that currency-to-currency transfers are now taxable events, I assume this falls in line. It's not only about turning things into fiat.

Really the law's going to have to adapt here if people are ever going to use crypto as an actual currency. Owing capital gains every time you order a latte is nuts.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by Retric on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @10:18AM (#16214203)
There is no sale from a new coin being created. There is a sale if you trade coin X for coin Y.

PS: Trading cars with someone counts as 2 sales, assuming the titles change hands.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by raybayfay on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @01:54PM (#16216250)
exactly
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by Glyptodon on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @11:46AM (#16214927)
This seems more like a stock split than a transfer.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by dmm on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:35AM (#16213795)
The site I linked argues not because unrealized gains occur when something you own goes up in value. But during a fork you are given (access to) something new.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by twohlix_ on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:29AM (#16213757)
And if you realize it I imagine your strike price was $0, so its full profit. IANAL tho.
Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by jsty on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @09:42AM (#16213861)
(This thought experiment may be completely wrong, I'm unfamiliar with US tax law)

If people were attempting to propose improvements via forking and this were true, would that not create rather dire tax liabilities?

Say you bought into bitcoin 'original', and then it forks into bitcoin 'improved' as well. Loads of people agree that the improved version is much better and switch to it, leaving the original near worthless.

But then if this interpretation of tax rules were true you'd be left paying cap gains on the full value of the improved version, rather than the difference between original and improved at sale time. Ouch.

Re:Bitcoin May Split Many Times in 2018 by my_username_is_ on Tuesday January 23, 2018 @11:23AM (#16214745)
I think there's an implication in your thought process that the 'bitcoin original' value, which you bought into, goes to $0. This would constitute a capital loss, and you would have gains up from $0 on the secondary blockchain ('bitcoin improved'). This would seem reasonable to me, as it's essentially a wash. The only thing that would muddy the whole thing up is the holding period for short term and long term capital gains.